Papyrus Rampant

Papyrus Rampant delves into the essence of storytelling across various contexts, exploring the construction and impact of narratives in history, literature, and theory. It examines storytelling techniques, historical events, the role of explorations, and the intersection of fantasy with reality, while offering critical analysis and reflections on books and story-driven themes.

Storytelling Techniques Historical Analysis Fantasy and Historical Fiction Literary Criticism and Reviews Theory of Story Cultural and Historical Events Character and Narrative Development Exploration and Discovery

The hottest Substack posts of Papyrus Rampant

And their main takeaways

A Tale of a Lost Heir

119 implied HN points • 02 Nov 24
📚 Literature Fiction History Storytelling Character development Cultural analysis
  1. When writing about a lost heir, it's important to show why others want to follow them. A strong character, like Bonnie Prince Charlie, can inspire loyalty in others, making the story more engaging.
  2. Authors need to create believable circumstances that allow the heir to gather support without being quickly defeated. Historical events can provide inspiration for how to craft these situations.
  3. A lost heir's eventual reign should hint at their ability to lead. Even if they don't win, showing how they would govern helps readers connect with the character and understand the challenges they face.

Luther and the Spark of the Reformation

178 implied HN points • 26 Oct 24
💾 History Religion Education Politics Europe
  1. Martin Luther posted his Ninety-Five Theses in 1517, which wasn't meant to start a movement but turned out to spark the Protestant Reformation.
  2. He challenged the sale of indulgences, emphasizing that faith in God, not money, is what saves people from sin.
  3. Luther's actions led to a push for education and Bible translation, helping more people understand their faith and read scripture in their own language.

Short Reviews for October 2024

119 implied HN points • 19 Oct 24
📚 Literature Books Fiction History Reviews Public Health
  1. Mindtouch is a cozy sci-fi story about two alien dormmates who build a strong friendship. It focuses more on their character growth than on action.
  2. The Rolling Stones is a fun sci-fi adventure featuring family banter and problem-solving on a trip through the Solar System. The resourceful twins turn a fun vacation into a business venture.
  3. A Good Time to Be Born highlights how public health efforts helped reduce childhood mortality over the last century. It shows both the struggles and the successes in improving children's health.

Across the Divide: What It Means to Be American

138 implied HN points • 12 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics National Identity Political division Historical Narratives Civic engagement Civil Rights
  1. People often have different views of history based on their experiences and backgrounds. This can lead to disagreements over what events mean and how they shape our identities.
  2. National stories are important because they give people a sense of belonging. These narratives help define what it means to be part of a nation and influence how people understand each other.
  3. It's okay to disagree, but we need to learn to accept our differences without hostility. True connection comes from love and understanding, even across political divides.

A Lawful Insurrection: The Massachusetts Provincial Congress

119 implied HN points • 05 Oct 24
💾 History American Revolution Governance Political Movements Military History
  1. In 1774, Massachusetts set up its own government, independent from British rule, even before the American Revolution officially started. They did this peacefully and with strong community involvement.
  2. General Gage, the British governor, faced growing resistance from the people of Massachusetts. They were organizing and defying his orders, making it clear they opposed British authority.
  3. The Massachusetts Provincial Congress acted like a government by making decisions, collecting taxes, and preparing for war. Their actions laid the groundwork for the future American government and the fight for independence.
Get a weekly roundup of the best Substack posts, by hacker news affinity:

Medieval Historical Fantasy

158 implied HN points • 20 Jan 24
  1. There are two approaches to historical fantasy: rewrite society with fantasy elements or fit fantasy into historical society.
  2. Medieval people believed in magic, making it easy to integrate in a historical setting without needing explanations like the 'Masquerade' in urban fantasy.
  3. A historical setting adds depth and contrast to the magical elements in a story, enhancing the overall experience for readers.

The Short Fairy-Tale

158 implied HN points • 13 Jan 24
  1. Fairy tales are short and sparse, focusing on events rather than emotional depth.
  2. Fairy tale retellings expand upon the original story, adding depth and complexity.
  3. The oral nature of fairy tales may explain their short, sparse style, highlighting the importance of writing in enhancing storytelling.

When the Guns Fell Silent

198 implied HN points • 11 Nov 23
  1. No one expected the devastation of World War One, which lasted over four years and had massive casualties.
  2. The war defined a generation, with people questioning its purpose and finding themselves in a devastated Europe.
  3. After the war, the world had to rebuild from the chaotic dreams and devastation, with the treaty of Versailles seen as merely an armistice.

Short reviews for December

119 implied HN points • 30 Dec 23
  1. The Witches of Karres is a pulp sci-fi novel with engaging characters and an interesting magic system.
  2. Caught in Crystal is a fantasy book that beautifully combines realistic children with a magical adventure.
  3. Passionate Sage provides insights into John Adams' character and political philosophy, depicting a more realistic view of America's Founding Fathers.

Short reviews for January 2024

99 implied HN points • 27 Jan 24
  1. Book review of 'Victory Rode the Rails' highlighting the importance of railroads during the Civil War
  2. Book review of 'Gods, Graves, and Scholars' focusing on the adventures of archaeologists from ancient civilizations
  3. Book review of 'Doomsday Book' mentioning a mix of charming banter, serious plots, and a dark second half in a time travel narrative

Theology in Story

119 implied HN points • 23 Dec 23
  1. In Narnia, Lewis integrated Christian theology directly into the story through characters like Aslan, contrasting with Tolkien's approach of keeping theology in the background.
  2. Tolkien's stories like Lord of the Rings focused on human heroes achieving victory through their own efforts, while Lewis' Chronicles of Narnia often portrayed protagonists' efforts as secondary to Aslan's interventions.
  3. The differing approaches of Lewis and Tolkien in incorporating theology into their stories showcase how the prominence of theological elements can impact storytelling and audience perception.

The Boston Tea Party

119 implied HN points • 16 Dec 23
  1. The Boston Tea Party marked the 250th anniversary of a significant event in American history
  2. The Boston Tea Party was unplanned and a result of escalating tensions with Britain over taxes
  3. The Sons of Liberty orchestrated the Boston Tea Party as a protest against British taxation and their actions further fueled revolutionary sentiments

Narrators and Perspectives

158 implied HN points • 07 Oct 23
  1. Narrators in stories can add depth and character to the plot.
  2. Choosing the right perspective can help readers relate and understand the story better.
  3. The interplay between protagonist and narrator can bring complexity and richness to a narrative.

In-Universe Metafiction

138 implied HN points • 04 Nov 23
  1. Authors can create fictional histories within their novels
  2. Having a book exist inside the world can allow for changes in characters and the world
  3. Choosing the right narrator for in-universe metafiction can greatly enhance a story

Short Reviews for October 2023

138 implied HN points • 28 Oct 23
  1. The Good Shepherd by C. S. Forester is a naval war story set during WWII with a unique focus on the uncertainty of battle and the challenges faced by the captain.
  2. Imperial Purple by Gillian Bradshaw is an engaging novel set in the fifth-century Eastern Roman Empire, focusing on intrigue and character development.
  3. At Home by Bill Bryson offers detailed anecdotes about the history of daily life, exploring various historical topics through the lens of housing in England and America.

What Makes a History Book Good

138 implied HN points • 14 Oct 23
  1. A history book can be good by bringing history to life and providing a vivid picture of a specific time period or event.
  2. A good history book should introduce new facts and perspectives that expand the reader's understanding.
  3. Highlighting themes and connections within history can make a history book engaging and insightful.

The Burr Conspiracy in History and Story

138 implied HN points • 30 Sep 23
  1. Aaron Burr's actions, notably his duel with Alexander Hamilton and attempt to raise a private army, left a lasting mark on American history and perception.
  2. The uncertainty surrounding Burr's true motives and intentions in his conspiracy added to his mystique and the larger-than-life image of treason he acquired.
  3. Despite the dramatic narrative, Burr's conspiracy was ultimately a flop, facing lack of support, public outcry, and legal acquittal that left many disappointed.

The Spirit of Exploration

138 implied HN points • 16 Sep 23
  1. Explorers throughout history have been driven by the urges for glory and accomplishment, even when there were no practical gains.
  2. Early explorers like Columbus and Magellan sought profit in their expeditions, contrasting with later explorers who continued the tradition of exploration despite lack of profitability.
  3. Modern exploration, such as space travel, requires immense resources and preparation, making it more challenging to embody the spirit of past explorers.

Emancipation on the Ground Level

178 implied HN points • 17 Jun 23
  1. Juneteenth celebrates actual emancipation on the ground level, not just legal abolition of slavery.
  2. During the Civil War, the North didn't initially fight to abolish slavery, but it evolved due to various factors.
  3. The impact of the Emancipation Proclamation was significant on the ground during the war, leading to the enlistment of US Colored Troops and the collapse of slavery in many areas.

Rigging a Thought Experiment

257 implied HN points • 21 Jan 23
  1. Authors should stick to the story they set out to tell without changing course
  2. Rigging a thought experiment by manipulating the narrative or characters detracts from the authenticity of the story
  3. Readers appreciate when characters grapple with moral dilemmas honestly and don't necessarily come to clear-cut conclusions

The Thin Line Between Science Fiction and Fantasy

119 implied HN points • 02 Sep 23
  1. Defining the line between science fiction and fantasy is not straightforward, as simplistic definitions break down upon further analysis.
  2. Examples like Star Wars and Star Trek blur the boundaries between science fiction and fantasy with elements like psychic powers and the Force.
  3. Ultimately, the distinction between science fiction and fantasy may come down to how the story feels in terms of rational laws of nature, even if exploring different natural laws.

Short Reviews for November 2023

79 implied HN points • 25 Nov 23
  1. Epilogue focuses on a group of teenagers returning from a portal fantasy adventure, dealing with consequences and unexpected twists in relationships.
  2. The Last Guardian of Everness tells a story of an invasion from the land of dreams and nightmares, with interesting elements but a convoluted plot.
  3. Lion of Liberty delves into the life of Patrick Henry, detailing his rise to prominence, political positions, and impact on American history.

Constraints as the Writer's Friend

138 implied HN points • 08 Jul 23
  1. Constraints can be a challenge for writers, but they can improve the story
  2. Constraints can spark creativity, leading to better ideas and plot development
  3. External and internal constraints can lead to creative discomfort, pushing authors to come up with new and better ideas to enhance the story

Goodreads and the Hard Problem of Book Recommendations

119 implied HN points • 05 Aug 23
  1. Goodreads faces challenges beyond just review-bombing, even if reviewers are sincere.
  2. Star ratings on Goodreads may not be very helpful due to different tastes and preferences.
  3. A weighted book recommendation system, considering personal tastes, could improve Goodreads' recommendations.

Augustus Caesar and the Masquerade of the Republic

99 implied HN points • 19 Aug 23
  1. Augustus Caesar cleverly accepted honors and titles from others without demanding them.
  2. Augustus ruled as a Roman Emperor, but presented himself as a protector of the Roman Republic.
  3. Augustus brought stability to Rome after years of civil wars and unrest, despite his ultimate control over public affairs.

The Madness of Yankee Doodle

119 implied HN points • 01 Jul 23
  1. Historically, not everyone believed in the idea of equality among individuals.
  2. John Locke's ideas influenced revolutions in the United States by promoting the concept of equality among property holders.
  3. The United States was founded on the ideal of equality, even for political enemies and marginalized groups.

Short Reviews for September 2023

79 implied HN points • 23 Sep 23
  1. The novel 'Persuasion' by Jane Austen focuses on internal emotional journey and limitations of aristocratic British life.
  2. In 'Trapped' by James Alan Gardner, a group of Ohio schoolteachers go on a quest in a world of collapsed civilization and magic.
  3. 'The Making of Roman Italy' by Edward Salmon explores how Rome conquered and integrated various cities in Italy through bilateral agreements.

What Talking Animals Can Say

59 implied HN points • 18 Nov 23
  1. Talking animal stories often depict animals as more humanlike than realistic
  2. Authors can use the concept of talking animals to explore unique characterizations and themes
  3. Stories with talking animals can create a magical and adventurous atmosphere

Early-Installment Weirdness

79 implied HN points • 09 Sep 23
  1. Early-Installment Weirdness is when a story changes over time and leaves behind initial quirks
  2. Authors may not plan out entire stories, leading to unexpected shifts in tone or plot
  3. Changes in a series can be interesting but may detract from overall worldbuilding and storytelling

Visions Towards Utopia

138 implied HN points • 08 Apr 23
  1. Imagine a utopian world where people can live in peace and abundance.
  2. Cory Doctorow reimagines a utopian society based on present-day internet communities.
  3. The novel 'Walkaway' explores a society with advanced duplicator technology but also raises questions on human nature and societal organization.

Framing the Reconstruction Amendments

39 implied HN points • 06 Jan 24
  1. After the Civil War, the South faced uncertainty on what societal structure would replace slavery.
  2. The Reconstruction Amendments, particularly the 13th, 14th, and 15th, aimed to reshape society and enforce civil rights.
  3. Despite facing setbacks, these Amendments have played a crucial role in enforcing civil rights and challenging discriminatory laws.

How It Allegorically Happened

119 implied HN points • 15 Apr 23
  1. Historical fiction films can tell stories well, even if not completely accurate.
  2. Movies like 'The Death of Stalin' and 'Harriet' offer allegorical truths about historical events.
  3. Stories in films and plays can compress historical details but still convey the overall arc of history.

The Late Partial Redemption of Stephen A. Douglas

99 implied HN points • 03 Jun 23
  1. Stephen A. Douglas stood up for his principles in his last years, even though he had a career of political compromise.
  2. The Kansas-Nebraska Act and the Lecompton Constitution were pivotal moments in Douglas's political journey.
  3. Despite his belated moral stand, Douglas's principles played a crucial role in opposing slavery and preserving the Union.

Short Reviews for July 2023

79 implied HN points • 29 Jul 23
  1. The book 'Modernizing a Slave Economy' by John Majewski explores the impact of soil quality on Southern economy during the Civil War era.
  2. In 'The Perfectionists' by Simon Winchester, the author discusses the importance of precision in modern industrial development and the impact on society.
  3. H. Rider Haggard's 'The Brethren' is a Victorian adventure novel set during the Crusades, focusing on a romantic quest with historical events as backdrop.

Imagining Traffic Jams In a Far Universe

79 implied HN points • 15 Jul 23
  1. Sci-fi novels can explore worlds with different fundamental principles
  2. Authors like Greg Egan delve into universes with unique physical laws
  3. Science fiction stories predict the world resulting from their premises

Cross-Country Cutscenes and Dramatic Unity

39 implied HN points • 09 Dec 23
  1. Peter Jackson used cross-country cutscenes to juxtapose characters and create fun twists in storytelling.
  2. Jackson compressed chronology and showed quick action-response sequences to emphasize dramatic unities in the story.
  3. Good storytellers, like Jackson and Shakespeare, can create the illusion of characters in different locations interacting as if in one place, enhancing the storytelling experience.

Abandoned Series

99 implied HN points • 29 Apr 23
  1. Authors should complete their series to maintain story quality and fulfill reader expectations.
  2. Serialization can limit story development by tying authors to early decisions and hindering improvements over time.
  3. Market pressures in the publishing industry can push authors to start series they may not finish, impacting the overall quality of storytelling.

It's been a year

59 implied HN points • 08 Sep 23
  1. Celebrating one year of Papyrus Rampant with gratitude for subscribers, readers, and commenters.
  2. Promising upcoming posts on early American and Roman history, fiction series, and historical fiction.
  3. Highlighting favorite posts from 2022 and 2023, inviting readers to share their own favorites.

The Treaty of Versailles

39 implied HN points • 02 Dec 23
  1. Making peace after a war can be as challenging as the war itself.
  2. The Treaty of Versailles aimed to prevent Germany from becoming a threat again.
  3. The League of Nations, set up to prevent future wars, ultimately failed in its mission.

Short Reviews for May 2023

79 implied HN points • 20 May 23
  1. The novel 'Mistress of the Waves' combines speculative fiction with economics, focusing on an entrepreneur protagonist in a low-technology colony planet.
  2. The book 'Quarantine' delves into quantum mechanics and explores the philosophical implications of the multiverse theory in a unique and serious way.
  3. 'Rabble Rousers' analyzes mass hysteria incidents in history but falls short in providing a deeper understanding of the underlying causes and implications.