The hottest Songwriting Substack posts right now

And their main takeaways
Category
Top Music Topics

Maybe God is a curious God

Blackbird Spyplane • 1958 implied HN points • 22 Oct 24
🎶 Music Songwriting
  1. Father John Misty thinks that writing long songs can be as effective as short ones. He usually writes big, unstructured pieces that turn into several songs later.
  2. He reflects on how fame has taught him humility and changed his perspective on music. His recent experiences as a parent have also influenced his songwriting and personal growth.
  3. The new album explores themes of identity and existence, suggesting that our experiences might be part of a larger, non-human consciousness. He sees God as a curious presence that experiences life through individual human experiences.

You and I Meet in a Cosy Cafe

a constellation • 297 implied HN points • 23 Oct 24
🎶 Music Songwriting
  1. Writer's block can happen to anyone, and it's okay to not feel like writing sometimes. Sometimes life gets overwhelming, and we just need a break.
  2. It’s normal to want to keep certain creative projects private until they feel ready. Sometimes it feels special to keep things to ourselves.
  3. Feeling stuck on what to write about is common. It's important to remember that writing should be enjoyable, not just for others' expectations.

A Deep Dive Into 'I Feel Fine'

The Ruffian • 1014 implied HN points • 21 Feb 26
🎶 Music Songwriting
  1. I Feel Fine compresses a long musical lineage into two minutes — its riff can be traced from Dizzy Gillespie’s Latin-jazz ideas through Bobby Parker and R&B into the Beatles’ pop form.
  2. The Beatles used simple material with bold studio and arrangement choices — a riff-based structure, Ringo’s Latin-jazz beat, three-part harmonies, and the first deliberate guitar feedback — to turn a throwaway tune into something memorable.
  3. The song shows how 20th-century music mixed across genres and borders — Afro-Cuban rhythms, jazz, R&B and rock fed into each other and then were broadcast worldwide through popular acts.

Janis Ian

Van Cliburn Punched Me In The Mouth • 99 implied HN points • 21 Oct 24
🎶 Music Songwriting
  1. Janis Ian finds a community in Nashville that supports songwriters. She appreciates the polite and welcoming environment compared to New York.
  2. Her recent album, 'Folk Is The New Black,' is the easiest one she’s ever made, showing a cohesive flow and emotional depth. She focuses on expressing feelings without unnecessary filler in her lyrics.
  3. The music industry is changing rapidly, and artists now have to be more independent and proactive. This shift means they need to handle more business tasks themselves, which can take time away from creating music.

Brian Wilson Is My Brick

The Honest Broker • 26397 implied HN points • 12 Jun 25
🎶 Music Songwriting
  1. Having a special object, like a brick from school, can remind us of our roots and where we come from. It's important to cherish those memories as they shape who we are.
  2. Being different or feeling like an outsider can be tough, especially in youth, but it can also be a strength later in life. Embracing that uniqueness can lead to personal growth and success.
  3. Music can express feelings that are hard to put into words. Artists like Brian Wilson show us that being open about our struggles can connect us with others who feel the same way.
Get a weekly roundup of the best Substack posts, by hacker news affinity:

💌 Liner Notes: Cascade

a constellation • 138 implied HN points • 15 Oct 24
🎶 Music Songwriting
  1. The song 'Cascade' is about the journey of rocks, inspired by the sedimentary cycle. It reflects the idea of change and transformation.
  2. Sometimes songwriting can come easily, but certain parts, like the bridge in 'Cascade,' can take more time and thought to express deep emotions.
  3. The singer encourages listeners to explore her music and shares her creative process, letting them know that there's more to come from her debut album.

Things Worth Remembering: ‘White Christmas’ Is a World War II Anthem

Common Sense with Bari Weiss • 2123 implied HN points • 14 Dec 25
🎶 Music Songwriting
  1. Today it’s treated as a classic secular Christmas song, but when it debuted during World War II listeners immediately heard it as a wartime anthem.
  2. The lyrics capture a longing for snow and simpler times, channeling the homesickness felt by soldiers and families separated by the war.
  3. Bing Crosby’s recording (with backing vocals) turned the tune into the best-selling single ever and locked it into popular Christmas culture.

Steve Earle

Van Cliburn Punched Me In The Mouth • 158 implied HN points • 09 Oct 24
🎶 Music Songwriting
  1. Steve Earle believes music has always had a political side, and right now it might be more important than ever. He thinks artists should write about what they feel strongly about, even if those topics are heavy.
  2. Earle points out that in the past, music played a big role in social change. He feels that today's artists have the chance to create impactful songs, especially with current issues in the world.
  3. He also emphasizes the need for empathy in songwriting. When artists connect with their emotions and experiences, they can reach people's hearts better, making them more powerful in conveying their messages.

Tori Amos

Van Cliburn Punched Me In The Mouth • 178 implied HN points • 04 Oct 24
🎶 Music Songwriting
  1. Tori Amos explains that she can't force creativity like some songwriters can. Inspiration for her songs comes from moments in life, not from a set schedule.
  2. She emphasizes that great songs and hit records are not the same thing, and real artists often avoid formulas to make authentic music.
  3. Tori believes that understanding emotions and personal experiences is crucial for songwriting. Living a full life helps writers create deeper, more meaningful art.

How an Exiled Russian Noble Became a Great American Songwriter

The Honest Broker • 6915 implied HN points • 15 Jul 25
🎶 Music Songwriting
  1. Vernon Duke, originally Vladimir Dukelsky, was a talented composer who fled Russia after the revolution and became a famous American songwriter. His ability to adapt to a new culture and succeed in a different musical genre is truly inspiring.
  2. He wrote classic songs that are still loved today, like 'Autumn in New York' and 'April in Paris.' It's amazing how his background in classical music shaped these popular tunes.
  3. Duke's memoir, 'Passport to Paris,' shares his unique experiences and connections with other artists, showing a lighthearted side of his life while touching on deeper themes of longing and happiness.

The Don't Cha Edition

Why is this interesting? • 542 implied HN points • 08 Jan 26
🎶 Music Songwriting
  1. The original recording was darker and more experimental than the radio hit, and critics noticed how unique and artful it sounded.
  2. A dispute over rights led the original performer to relinquish the song, after which the label reworked it into a polished pop version and gave it to a mainstream act.
  3. The original still gets rediscovered and appreciated, showing how production choices and legal control can completely change a song’s character and reception.

"Stage Fright" by The Band (1970) with Todd Rundgren as engineer/producer

Rock 'n' Roll with Me • 559 implied HN points • 18 Jul 24
🎶 Music Songwriting
  1. Todd Rundgren worked as the engineer and producer for The Band's album 'Stage Fright,' which showed his skills in the studio. He had to face challenges while recording, like setting up a makeshift control room.
  2. The song 'Stage Fright' is about the feelings many artists face, capturing the emotion of performing. It became one of the highlights of the album and a classic rock song.
  3. Despite being younger and less experienced than The Band members, Todd's dedication and hard work helped make the project a success, boosting his reputation in the music industry.

"Dancing Barefoot" by the Patti Smith Group (1979) with producer Todd Rundgren

Rock 'n' Roll with Me • 379 implied HN points • 25 Jul 24
🎶 Music Songwriting
  1. The song 'Dancing Barefoot' by the Patti Smith Group is a notable track from their 1979 album 'Wave', produced by Todd Rundgren. It's well-loved and has been covered by many artists.
  2. Patti Smith and Todd Rundgren share a deep friendship that began in the late 60s. Their bond was built on mutual respect and admiration for each other's artistic talents.
  3. The song is dedicated to women artists, showcasing Patti's love for strong female figures. It's recognized as a powerful piece about love and longing.

Epiphanies

Dada Drummer Almanach • 178 implied HN points • 01 Feb 26
🎶 Music Songwriting
  1. He finds freedom inside musical limits, stretching time and phrasing like a jazz musician to make his drumming and singing constantly surprising and expressive.
  2. He lives simply and generously in retirement, valuing small pleasures, leftist principles, and warm, kind interactions with fans and friends.
  3. His work turns ordinary details into deep feeling and has profoundly influenced other musicians, teaching new ways to play drums and sing.

Todd Rundgren as a songwriter and performer: The Creator Series #5

Rock 'n' Roll with Me • 279 implied HN points • 02 Aug 24
🎶 Music Songwriting
  1. Todd Rundgren believes there are different levels of musicians: entertainers, performers, and artists, with artists being the rarest who create unpredictable and unique expressions. He thinks being a performer is the best way to make a stable living in music.
  2. He values artistic freedom over chasing fame, using his success as a producer to create music that reflects his true self without worrying about commercial success. He sees the process of creating something from nothing as a key motivation for his work.
  3. Todd emphasizes the importance of practical help for artists, sharing how his manager supported him in both personal and professional matters, allowing him to focus on his music. He also finds inspiration from the music ecosystem around him and the collaborations he engages in.

Zac Brown Show At The Sphere

Points And Figures • 532 implied HN points • 13 Dec 25
🎶 Music Songwriting
  1. The concert is a narrative journey from darkness to light that emphasizes personal growth, forgiveness, and life after failure.
  2. The Sphere's bold visuals and symbolic moments — skeletons, King Neptune, poems and Roosevelt interludes — build a coherent story rather than anything satanic.
  3. The show urges people to take agency: face fear, take risks, be the 'man in the arena,' and stop being a passive spectator in their own lives.

"I'm a Believer" by the Monkees (1966)

Rock 'n' Roll with Me • 399 implied HN points • 12 Jul 24
🎶 Music Songwriting
  1. The Monkees were a popular band created for a TV show, and they captured the hearts of many young fans with their music and antics.
  2. Their song 'I'm a Believer' was a huge hit written by Neil Diamond, making it one of the best-selling albums in the U.S. during its time.
  3. The B-side 'I'm Not Your Steppin' Stone' shows a different side of the band with a more psychedelic and edgy vibe.

Skylarking by XTC (1986) with Todd Rundgren as producer

Rock 'n' Roll with Me • 239 implied HN points • 26 Jul 24
🎶 Music Songwriting
  1. Todd Rundgren produced the album Skylarking by XTC, which was a big deal because the band needed a successful record to stay with their label. They had many songs but no clear direction when they started.
  2. To create a more cohesive sound, Todd visualized each song with images, connecting music to themes like seasons and emotions. Most of the album turned out great, but one song, 'Another Satellite,' didn't quite fit and caused some tension.
  3. Despite some challenges during the album's creation, Skylarking ended up being successful, helping XTC to continue making music. The album received recognition and is considered one of the top albums of the 1980s.

"Shambala" by Three Dog Night (1973)

Rock 'n' Roll with Me • 179 implied HN points • 06 Aug 24
🎶 Music Songwriting
  1. The song 'Shambala' by Three Dog Night emphasizes positivity and kindness as a way to improve our lives and the world.
  2. Shambala is a legendary place in Tibetan Buddhism that symbolizes hope and peace, especially in tough times.
  3. Three Dog Night was a successful band known for their strong vocals and hit songs, including 'Shambala' which reached #3 on the charts.

RAW WEEKS

Entering The Lung • 3655 implied HN points • 20 Oct 23
🎶 Music Songwriting
  1. The author reflects on feeling too sad to be productive at home
  2. The author shares a demo of a song being worked on with a friend
  3. The author has opened up their content for free for the month of October

"Day After Day" by Badfinger (1971) with producers George Harrison and Todd Rundgren

Rock 'n' Roll with Me • 239 implied HN points • 22 Jul 24
🎶 Music Songwriting
  1. Badfinger had strong ties to The Beatles, which helped them get noticed and signed to Apple Records. They created hits partly thanks to Paul McCartney's early support.
  2. The band faced challenges with production and management, especially when inexperienced producers were assigned to them. This affected their music quality and output.
  3. Todd Rundgren eventually took over production and helped Badfinger achieve significant success with hits like 'Day After Day,' showcasing their musical talent.

"Chain of Fools" by Aretha Franklin (1967)

Rock 'n' Roll with Me • 299 implied HN points • 11 Jul 24
🎶 Music Songwriting
  1. Aretha Franklin's song 'Chain of Fools' is a powerful anthem about heartbreak and feeling trapped in a relationship. It's a classic hit that resonates with many people.
  2. The song showcases Aretha's incredible talent not only as a singer but also as a captivating live performer. Her ability to connect with the audience makes her performances special.
  3. The post suggests upcoming songs, encouraging listeners to engage with requests and offers a fun vibe like a retro DJ. It's a great way to discover new music and reminisce about the past.

"Purple Haze" by the Jimi Hendrix Experience (1967)

Rock 'n' Roll with Me • 279 implied HN points • 13 Jul 24
🎶 Music Songwriting
  1. Jimi Hendrix is considered one of the greatest guitarists ever, and his song 'Purple Haze' showcases his unique style and innovative techniques.
  2. The live performance of 'Purple Haze' captures Jimi's impressive guitar work and the skill of his bandmates, making it memorable for fans.
  3. The song has become iconic in rock music and is loved for its energetic rhythm, perfect for dancing and acrobatics.

"I Saw the Light" by Todd Rundgren (1972)

Rock 'n' Roll with Me • 219 implied HN points • 17 Jul 24
🎶 Music Songwriting
  1. Todd Rundgren wrote 'I Saw the Light' very quickly, in just about 20 minutes. He played all the instruments and sang all the parts himself to make it sound just how he wanted.
  2. The song was part of his album 'Something/Anything?' and became a Top 20 hit, even though another song from the same album, 'Hello It’s Me,' ended up being more popular later.
  3. Rundgren also performed 'I Saw the Light' with Daryl Hall, showing that their music is still great as they get older. You can hear both his original version and this performance to compare.

"We Gotta Get You a Woman" by Todd Rundgren (1970)

Rock 'n' Roll with Me • 219 implied HN points • 15 Jul 24
🎶 Music Songwriting
  1. Todd Rundgren's song 'We Gotta Get You a Woman' was inspired by his experiences as a young man in New York, feeling lonely and wanting to connect with others.
  2. The song faced some controversy over its lyrics, with some people feeling they were misogynistic while others saw it as just a story from a character's perspective.
  3. Songs can reflect different meanings depending on who sings them and when, so it's important to remember they aren't always giving advice, but are telling stories instead.

Todd Rundgren as a songwriter and performer: The Creator Series #3

Rock 'n' Roll with Me • 219 implied HN points • 14 Jul 24
🎶 Music Songwriting
  1. Todd Rundgren's early exposure to music shaped his career as a songwriter and performer. He found inspiration at a young age, often experimenting with different instruments and sounds.
  2. His journey through various bands, like The Nazz, showed his evolution as a musician and leader. He faced challenges in managing relationships within the band, especially when artistic differences arose.
  3. Rundgren's creative process includes a strong DIY attitude, blending his musical skills with innovation. He emphasized the importance of playing live and getting experiences over waiting for big opportunities.

Carole King: The Creator Series #2

Rock 'n' Roll with Me • 319 implied HN points • 23 Jun 24
🎶 Music Songwriting
  1. Carole King started making music at a very young age, with supportive parents and lots of practice. She began writing songs at just three years old.
  2. She faced challenges throughout her career but never gave up. Her perseverance helped her succeed in the music industry, and she learned a lot from her experiences.
  3. Carole's creative process involved teamwork and collaboration, especially with her husband. Together, they wrote many hit songs, including classics like '(You Make Me Feel Like) A Natural Woman.'

Studio Diary: Part 1

Colin Meloy's Machine Shop • 2555 implied HN points • 15 Feb 23
🎶 Music Songwriting
  1. The Decemberists are recording music in a studio and sharing the process openly with fans.
  2. They operate on practical hours, record fragments of songs, and focus on the music rather than late night sessions.
  3. The band tracks multiple takes of a song, focusing on drums and bass, and decides to take a break and return the next day with fresh ears.

"I Say a Little Prayer" - The enduring magic of Hollywood's greatest songwriters, Burt Bacharach and Hal David

Rock 'n' Roll with Me • 419 implied HN points • 28 May 24
🎶 Music Songwriting
  1. Burt Bacharach and Hal David were an amazing songwriting team that created many famous songs together. They made music that took listeners on an emotional journey, combining catchy melodies with deep lyrics.
  2. Dionne Warwick was a key artist for their songs, bringing a unique style and emotion to their music. Her ability to handle complex tunes made her the perfect fit for their unique sound.
  3. The song 'I Say a Little Prayer' has been reimagined by many artists, showing its versatility. Aretha Franklin's cover turned it into a soulful classic, proving great songs can be interpreted in fresh and powerful ways.

Let’s Overanalyze: ‘Cattle and the Creeping Things’ By The Hold Steady

Singal-Minded • 179 implied HN points • 18 Dec 25
🎶 Music Songwriting
  1. The song uses biblical imagery and jittery vocals to show jaded, addicted characters who treat sacred stories like worn-out scripts.
  2. The Hold Steady’s plainspoken bar-rock leaves room for dense storytelling, with recurring characters across songs and albums forming a dark arc from teenage parties to druggy, violent consequences.
  3. Repetition and unreliable narration are central: stories get retold and distorted so sacred and profane blur and cycles of addiction keep repeating.

The Todd Rundgren Creator Series

Rock 'n' Roll with Me • 99 implied HN points • 05 Aug 24
🎶 Music Songwriting
  1. Todd Rundgren has had a big impact on music as both a songwriter and a performer, especially during his time with The Nazz.
  2. He is also known for his work as a producer, where he has helped create hits for many famous artists over the years.
  3. The series includes insights into his career and aims to introduce new fans to his work while reminding old fans of his achievements.

5 lessons pop music can teach us about creativity

Make Work Better • 152 implied HN points • 17 Dec 25
🎶 Music Songwriting
  1. Creative work comes from showing up and making a lot of stuff; persistent output and practice give you the few big wins.
  2. Being together in person helps creativity because small, quiet cues and half-formed ideas get noticed and built on.
  3. Creativity thrives in messy, relaxed, playful spaces and from outside inputs, so embrace chaos, laughter, and unexpected sources to get unstuck.

James Taylor: The Creator Series #1

Rock 'n' Roll with Me • 239 implied HN points • 08 Jun 24
🎶 Music Songwriting
  1. James Taylor believes songwriting is more of a mysterious process that comes from within. He says that sometimes, it feels like he's just the first person to hear the songs that were already there.
  2. Performing in front of small audiences helped him grow as a musician. He values those early experiences because they allowed him to test his skills and connect with audiences.
  3. For James, music is not just a job, but a way to connect with a community. He feels that playing music creates a shared emotional experience with the audience, which can be very powerful.