Freddie deBoer • 6033 implied HN points • 20 Mar 26
- The rule "show, don’t tell" is misleading for prose because written fiction is always mediated by a narrator — descriptions, dialogue, and scenes are all forms of telling.
- Telling can be more efficient and artistically necessary than forced dramatization; great novelists use authorial commentary to deliver voice, theme, and interior life in ways scenes alone can’t.
- Turning writing maxims into dogma hurts inexperienced writers who lack the nuance to apply them, and policing "telling" in workshops can strip a work of its distinctive voice and insight.