Freddie deBoer • 7116 implied HN points • 09 Jan 26
- The idea that abolishing the police was the historic default of left politics is wrong. Treating it as settled history made the debate confused and ahistorical.
- The movement grew largely through online networks that produced many loose, ungrounded supporters who lacked political theory and organizing skills. That made it hard to form strategy, resolve disagreements, or sustain pressure.
- Nobody agreed on what “defund the police” actually meant, from modest budget reallocation to full abolition, and there were no concrete plans or strategic discipline. Without clear, actionable goals the 2020 energy couldn’t be translated into durable political change.