The Seneca Effect

The Seneca Effect explores the theme of collapse across various systems, from empires to science, emphasizing the rapidity of such collapses once a tipping point is reached. It discusses the role of modern societal, scientific, and environmental issues in potentially accelerating these collapses and reflects on historical patterns to suggest future directions.

Collapse of Complex Systems Stagnation in Science Normalization of Evil Censorship and Free Speech Decline of Empires Environmental and Ecosystem Health Financial and Social Inequality Propaganda and Societal Dementia Future Wars and Conflicts Renewable Energy Transition Political Leadership and Image Cultural and Civilizational Analysis

The hottest Substack posts of The Seneca Effect

And their main takeaways

The Seneca Effect: The Philosophy of Collapse

452 implied HN points • 21 Jan 24
  1. The Seneca Effect refers to the concept of collapse in complex systems like the Roman Empire observed by Lucius Annaeus Seneca.
  2. Complex systems tend to collapse rapidly once they reach a tipping point after evolving slowly over time.
  3. Understanding the Seneca Effect can help us navigate inevitable collapses, using them as opportunities for new beginnings.

The Most Revolutionary Idea you can Think of: Freedom from Fear and Want

255 implied HN points • 04 Feb 24
  1. Aurelio Peccei's vision focused on freedom from fear and want for global prosperity and peace.
  2. Peccei's goals were misunderstood and associated with catastrophism, which is not an accurate representation.
  3. Peccei's idea of promoting collaboration over conflict to prevent global collapse is relevant today.

The Seneca Blog is Growing

255 implied HN points • 01 Feb 24
  1. The Seneca Effect blog on Substack is seeing growth in readership and engagement.
  2. Substack's approach focuses more on direct emails than search engines.
  3. The author is considering opening the blog to paid subscriptions and potentially sharing more sensitive material behind a paywall.

Does Science have a God? Surprisingly, it does

353 implied HN points • 08 Jan 24
  1. Science can be seen as having a god-like entity called the Scientific Method.
  2. The application of the Galilean method in scientific research can be limited and flawed, leading to questionable outcomes.
  3. There is a call for a reform of science to acknowledge its limitations and avoid misuse for personal gain or political agendas.
Get a weekly roundup of the best Substack posts, by hacker news affinity:

Unexpected Consequences: 12 Factors That Could Destroy Civilization

255 implied HN points • 28 Jan 24
  1. CO2 Poisoning could have cognitive effects on humans due to rising concentrations in the atmosphere.
  2. Global Dumbing and declining IQ scores may have various causes including pollution and social media.
  3. Global Dementia, especially in the elderly, poses challenges as there is no cure and it may impact society and politics.

Science and Hyperobiects: How to See the Hidden Elephant

314 implied HN points • 14 Jan 24
  1. Understanding the complexity and vastness of systems like Earth's climate can be likened to the story of the blind men and the elephant.
  2. Models, even if not perfect, are valuable tools for grasping the workings of complex systems like the climate.
  3. Adopting a cooperative approach and embracing new paradigms, such as holobionts, may be key to avoiding catastrophic outcomes in dealing with intricate systems.

Can Anything Good Come from Gaza? How Western Science is Collapsing.

176 implied HN points • 11 Feb 24
🔬 Science Research Publication Peer Review Complex Systems
  1. The attempt to improve science by 'free-access publishing' has led to unintended consequences, like the proliferation of mediocre papers.
  2. The concentration of scientific power in a few elite institutions is not enough to drive innovation and creativity, mirroring the limitations faced by the Roman Empire.
  3. The collapse of science, exemplified by issues in scientific publishing, aligns with systemic collapses and may indicate the need for renewal through unconventional sources and unconventional ideas.

Stagnating Science and Disillusioned Scientists. A Personal Story.

452 implied HN points • 08 Dec 23
  1. Modern science is experiencing stagnation and disillusionment among scientists, leading to a decline in research quality and impact.
  2. The focus on short-term, narrowly-beneficial human-centric research in science is causing harm to the environment and the broader community of life.
  3. There is a need for a shift in scientific priorities towards more sustainable and holistic approaches that consider the well-being of the entire ecosystem.

Happy New Year with Leonardo da Vinci

314 implied HN points • 31 Dec 23
  1. The winter solstice symbolizes rebirth and the start of a new era, a concept depicted by Leonardo da Vinci in his painting 'Annunciation.'
  2. The actual location that served as the background for Leonardo's painting still exists in Florence, maintaining a connection to the past.
  3. Despite challenges over the centuries, there's always been hope for humanity's future, emphasizing the possibility of better times ahead.

The Empress of Christmas Past. A Message of Hope from Long ago

294 implied HN points • 23 Dec 23
  1. Christmas is celebrated with traditions like nativity scenes, symbolizing hope and new beginnings.
  2. Galla Placidia's life story reflects the idea of embracing change and finding unity in different cultures.
  3. The legacy of Galla Placidia teaches us the importance of hope and resilience during challenging times.

Censorship on the Web. Can Substack Beat Google?

393 implied HN points • 26 Nov 23
  1. Censorship on the web is a concerning issue affecting blogs and social media platforms.
  2. Moving to platforms like Substack can provide resilience against censorship compared to general-purpose platforms like Google's Blogger.
  3. Censorship, while important in extreme cases, can harm society's ability to evolve and adapt by limiting the diversity of opinions and hindering innovation in science.

The Normalization of Evil. It has Already Happened, it is Happening now.

432 implied HN points • 05 Nov 23
  1. Evil can become normalized through emotional numbing, where horrific images and events no longer elicit a reaction from people.
  2. Propaganda has a powerful influence on shaping beliefs and actions, often convincing entire populations to support wars or harmful ideologies.
  3. Sometimes events like wars can inadvertently lead to the extermination of large numbers of people, driven by fear, social tensions, and manipulative forces.

All Power to the Demented. Propaganda as a Senile Illness of Society

275 implied HN points • 16 Dec 23
  1. Dementia in individuals and leaders can lead to dangerous consequences, as seen in historical figures like Benito Mussolini and Franklin D. Roosevelt.
  2. Propaganda can be likened to a form of societal dementia, with characteristics like lack of empathy, rigidity, and obsessions, shaping a society's behavior.
  3. To combat the negative impacts of dementia and propaganda, maintaining diverse information sources and promoting free speech are important for building a healthy, sane society.

The Decline of the West According to Seneca

353 implied HN points • 29 Oct 23
  1. The Seneca Effect describes how systems can collapse faster than they grow due to resource depletion and pollution.
  2. During the initial stages of collapse, governance is often the first aspect to weaken and lose control.
  3. Historical patterns show that empires facing decline may transition towards centralized governance to combat corruption and stabilize society.

The Fall of Ozymandias. The Last Gasps of a Dying Empire

373 implied HN points • 11 Oct 23
  1. Empires follow a pattern of growth, conquest, and collapse due to depletion and human-made negative factors like bureaucracy and pollution.
  2. Gold played a critical role in the expansion and downfall of the Roman Empire as it fueled their growth but also led to their eventual collapse when resources ran out.
  3. The history of the Roman Empire serves as a reminder that all empires face decline and eventual collapse, despite attempts at glory and conquest.

How not to Govern the Commons. The Reasons of 50 Years of Failures

255 implied HN points • 19 Nov 23
  1. The global economy faces challenges of finite resources and continuous growth, governing the commons for shared benefit remains a struggle.
  2. Historically, attempts at macro-level interventions have largely failed due to societal resistance, industrial lobbying, and lack of effective global governance structures.
  3. Building strong, sustainable states with citizen trust and fair taxation could be key to addressing issues like pollution and climate change, with examples like China offering potential governance models to consider.

Croesus's Mistake. How Predictions on the Future of Humankind can Backfire

196 implied HN points • 04 Dec 23
  1. Predictions on the future of humankind can backfire if misunderstood, as seen with Croesus's mistake involving a prophecy misinterpretation.
  2. Negative predictions like 'peak oil' studies from the past were often ignored but had significant impacts on future actions, such as the push for shale oil production.
  3. Elite decisions on energy resources and future crises are often influenced more by qualitative intuition rather than quantitative data, leading to potential overlooks of sustainable options and reliance on harmful solutions.

On the Brink of WWIII? Estimating the Probability of a new Large Conflict

255 implied HN points • 21 Oct 23
  1. Predicting the future, especially regarding wars, is challenging because it follows a statistical 'power law,' meaning large conflicts are more probable than we might hope.
  2. Wars are not random and not periodic - they follow a pattern akin to the 'Seneca Effect,' where conflict builds up similar to a landslide causing a chain reaction.
  3. While it's challenging to pinpoint the exact triggers for wars, they are often linked to accumulated economic energy, which will eventually dissipate. Hope for peace remains despite historical cycles of conflict.

What do the Rich Have in Mind? First, Their own Survival

275 implied HN points • 07 Oct 23
  1. The rich prioritize their own survival, often preparing for future chaos and crises
  2. There is secrecy and strategic planning among the wealthy, with little transparency to the public about their intentions
  3. Historical patterns show that the rich can act to protect themselves in times of crisis, showcasing a lack of understanding or denial of impending collapse

The Only Good Trojan is a Dead Trojan. When did the Age of Exterminations Start?

255 implied HN points • 16 Oct 23
  1. Exterminations, especially ideological ones, are a modern phenomenon and were rare in classical times
  2. The start of the Age of Exterminations is linked to factors like sheer population growth, firearms, and the rise of propaganda through tools like the printing press
  3. Current trends suggest a possible increase in extermination events, but the decline in resources for war and shifts in human population dynamics may alter this trajectory

The Mind of Ozymandias: Who are our Leaders?

117 implied HN points • 12 Nov 23
  1. The rise of leaders with absolute power in history who sometimes lead to destruction and immense suffering is a recurring theme.
  2. Understanding the minds of powerful rulers throughout history can help shed light on their decision-making processes and motivations.
  3. Propaganda can have a powerful impact on shaping beliefs and actions, ultimately influencing historical events in significant ways.

The Babel Tower of Science.

176 implied HN points • 24 Sep 23
  1. Misunderstandings can arise when people speak different 'languages' in terms of risk perception and scientific understanding.
  2. Understanding complex topics like vaccine safety requires fluency in specific 'languages' such as Randomized Control Trials.
  3. Corruption and conflicts of interest can be prevalent in scientific fields where money is involved; regulations are necessary to address these issues.

The Most Amazing Graph of the 21st Century: How the Empire is Striking Back!

117 implied HN points • 16 Sep 23
  1. The US experienced an impressive rebound in oil production due to tight oil extraction, making it the largest world producer of crude oil again.
  2. The decision to invest in tight oil extraction was likely influenced by a mix of interests including the oil, aerospace, and military industries.
  3. The return of the US as a dominant player in oil production has geopolitical implications, leading to shifts in global power dynamics.

Why we Can't Change Anything Before it is Too Late.

216 implied HN points • 08 Apr 23
  1. Scientists often warn about grave problems but are demonized and ignored by society.
  2. Historically, humanity tends to take action only after it's too late to prevent a catastrophe.
  3. When addressing urgent issues, framing change as an opportunity rather than an obligation may be more effective.

The Shale Oil "Miracle" Explained. Could it be Done Again?

78 implied HN points • 19 Sep 23
  1. Shale oil was a game-changer in the oil market in the 2010s, surprisingly surpassing conventional oil production in the US.
  2. Experts often underestimate technological revolutions; they missed the significance of shale oil and currently struggle to understand the impact of photovoltaic energy.
  3. The high EROI of shale oil challenges traditional biophysical models of resource extraction, and its success begs questions about sustainability and the future of liquid fuels.

Renewables are not a cleaner caterpillar, they are a new butterfly. A Discussion with Dennis Meadows

157 implied HN points • 17 May 23
  1. Renewables are viewed as a new, transformative solution, not just a cleaner alternative to fossil fuels.
  2. Transitioning to renewables can lead to reduced energy and material consumption for a sustainable society, rather than striving to sustain current levels.
  3. Focusing on increasing resilience in society is essential, and the renewable versus fossil energy debate can sometimes divert attention from more critical aspects.

The Parallel Lives of Galileo Galilei and Sherlock Holmes

58 implied HN points • 10 Sep 23
  1. Science has played a vital role in shaping modern literature, particularly in the detective genre like Sherlock Holmes.
  2. The success of detective novels is intertwined with the rise of science as the dominant ideology in the 19th century.
  3. Despite being a powerful investigative method, the 'Galilean method' doesn't always succeed, especially in real scientific or legal contexts.

What if Lemmings had a King? Practical Uses of Monarchy

117 implied HN points • 12 May 23
  1. Kings and queens could be useful in certain circumstances, like how a King helped Italy surrender early in WWII
  2. The concept of Nash Equilibrium can trap societies in detrimental decisions, as seen in history
  3. The intervention of a King, like King Victor Emmanuel, can sometimes break a society out of harmful collective behaviors

Why did America Collapse? Mommy Knows

117 implied HN points • 28 Apr 23
  1. People often harm themselves by making choices that seem intelligent in the short term but are lethal in the long term.
  2. A lack of communication and trust can lead to societal collapse.
  3. Greed can drive individuals to prioritize short-term gains over long-term survival.

A new dichotomy: nation states vs. the "one planet" movement

98 implied HN points • 22 Apr 23
  1. A new dichotomy is emerging between nation-states and the 'one planet' movement, highlighting the clash between national competition and global solidarity.
  2. The global environmental crisis, including climate change and biodiversity loss, points towards a challenging period requiring innovative and rapid action.
  3. Nationalism presents a barrier to environmental action, but solutions may lie in a combination of national and non-national approaches, avoiding blind faith in technological fixes.

Putin Must Die! How to make sure that the war will not end soon

98 implied HN points • 20 Mar 23
  1. In military conflicts, there is a strategy of aiming for complete annihilation of the enemy rather than minimum effort, driven by beliefs of deadly threats and identity wars.
  2. Historically, there have been instances where prolonged wars were fueled by motives like business interests or ideological agendas, leading to extreme measures of destruction and extermination.
  3. Threatening total extermination or punishment of leaders in a conflict can push the opposing side to fight against all odds, illustrating the inefficiency and brutality of the anti-Seneca strategy in warfare.

The Revolution That Comes from Detroit: Car Tailfins are Back!

98 implied HN points • 01 Apr 23
  1. Detroit automakers are reintroducing tailfins in new cars for customers who prefer traditional vehicles.
  2. US oil industry supports the return of tailfins as it aligns with their current strategies for oil production.
  3. Various political figures and NATO see potential military applications for tailfins in tanks.

Is the Energy Transition Feasible? The Future as a Garden of Forking Paths

98 implied HN points • 08 May 23
  1. Models are useful for understanding the future, not predicting it.
  2. The future is a multitude of paths, not just one predetermined outcome.
  3. Transitioning to renewable energy requires adaptation, efficiency improvements, and embracing new technologies for a sustainable future.

The Rise of Elly Schlein: How a Young, Woke, and Fashionable Politician is Shaking up Politics in Italy, and Perhaps Worldwide

98 implied HN points • 05 May 23
  1. Elly Schlein's rise as a politician in Italy challenges the traditional strongman image in politics and focuses on projecting a 'woke' and fashionable persona.
  2. Schlein's PR strategy leverages public image effectively, triggering reactions that garner attention and feed into her popularity.
  3. In modern politics, the emphasis is shifting towards image and public relations rather than substantial policies or statements, indicating a broader trend in political landscapes.

When Science Fails: Surrogate endpoints and wrong conclusions

78 implied HN points • 02 May 23
  1. The scientific method, attributed to Galileo Galilei, focuses on experiments in controlled conditions to find irrefutable truths, but applying it to complex, multi-parameter systems like healthcare can be challenging.
  2. In medicine, relying on surrogate endpoints in drug testing is common due to the difficulty of quantifying health outcomes directly, but there are risks of misleading results and unforeseen consequences.
  3. Fields beyond medicine like economics and policies also face challenges in measuring outcomes accurately, leading to the use of surrogate endpoints like GDP growth, highlighting the need for dynamic models in studying complex systems.

Flattening the Curve. The Origins of a Bad Idea

78 implied HN points • 03 Apr 23
  1. Military planning and the fear of bioweapons led to the adoption of unprecedented measures in response to the Covid-19 epidemic.
  2. The concept of flattening the curve was based on models and studies inspired by military-oriented scenarios and lacked proper evaluation and verification.
  3. The misuse and misinterpretation of mathematical models, like in the case of the 'flatten the curve' approach, can lead to significant consequences and unforeseen disasters.

Another Epochal Failure of Humankind. How people are losing interest in the things that threaten them the most.

78 implied HN points • 24 Apr 23
  1. People are losing interest in environmental issues that threaten them, as shown by declining worry levels in a Gallup report.
  2. Economic difficulties and individual struggles are making it hard for people to connect their problems to larger planetary issues, leading to a decrease in concern.
  3. A negative loop is created where lack of public interest in certain topics results in media ignoring them, further reducing their significance, without much need for government intervention.

Is Science Becoming the Library of Babel?

78 implied HN points • 17 Apr 23
  1. Science is often characterized as producing a mix of nonsense and valuable knowledge that is hard to navigate and find.
  2. Individual scientists can still innovate within the constraints of the system and make meaningful contributions.
  3. The current scientific structure is prone to conflicts of interest, corruption, and self-referential debates, leading to a lack of objective and impactful outcomes.

What's Wrong With Science? Mostly, it is how we Mismanage it

78 implied HN points • 13 Apr 23
  1. Science is not just the work of individual scientists, but a large network of people, institutions, and facilities.
  2. The problem with science today lies in the mismanagement of large organizations, leading to wasted resources and inefficient structures.
  3. Encouraging good science and useful discoveries is essential, rather than settling for mediocrity and perpetuating a system resistant to change.