Musings on the Alignment Problem

Musings on the Alignment Problem explores the complexities of aligning AI systems with human intentions, discussing various methods, challenges, and theoretical aspects of AI alignment, including reinforcement learning, societal value importation, self-exfiltration risks, minimal viable products for alignment, and the necessity of inner alignment and scalable oversight in ensuring AI's beneficial trajectory.

AI Alignment Challenges Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback Societal Values in AI AI Self-Exfiltration Risks Automating Alignment Research Inner Alignment in AI Alignment Research Taxonomy Generalization and Oversight in AI Training

The hottest Substack posts of Musings on the Alignment Problem

And their main takeaways

A proposal for importing society’s values

519 implied HN points • 09 Mar 23
🕹 Technology AI Ethics Simulation Social Decision-making
  1. AI systems like ChatGPT face value-based decisions that are complex and can be polarizing, highlighting the need to align AI to individual and group preferences.
  2. A proposed process called simulated deliberative democracy aims to use large language models to simulate human deliberations on value questions, offering a scalable and transparent approach.
  3. The proposal presents pros like scalability, transparency, and potential for inclusivity, but also faces challenges such as representativeness, aggregation method complexities, and difficulties in simulating how people change their minds.

What is the alignment problem?

559 implied HN points • 29 Mar 22
🕹 Technology AI Alignment Language Models
  1. AI systems need to have both capability to perform tasks and alignment to do the tasks as intended by humans
  2. Alignment problems occur when systems do not act in accordance with human intentions, and it can be challenging to disentangle alignment problems from capability problems
  3. The 'hard problem of alignment' involves ensuring AI systems can align with tasks that are difficult for humans to evaluate, especially as AI becomes more advanced

Why I’m excited about AI-assisted human feedback

459 implied HN points • 29 Mar 22
🕹 Technology AI Feedback Machine Learning Automation Evaluation
  1. The use of reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) has been successful in aligning models with human intent like following instructions.
  2. Training AI systems on tasks that are hard for humans to evaluate may not be directly solvable with RLHF due to challenges in generalization and evaluation.
  3. AI-assisted human feedback, like recursive reward modeling (RRM), can help tackle complex tasks by involving human evaluation in aligning AI systems.
Get a weekly roundup of the best Substack posts, by hacker news affinity:

What could a solution to the alignment problem look like?

259 implied HN points • 27 Sep 22
🕹 Technology AI Systems
  1. One approach is to ensure alignment research stays ahead of AI capabilities to prevent issues, which could involve slowing down capabilities research or dedicating compute to alignment research.
  2. Finding a comprehensive once-and-for-all solution to the alignment problem is crucial for ensuring all future AI systems are aligned, but it remains uncertain if this is possible.
  3. Developing formal theories for alignment, creating processes to elicit values inclusively and fairly, and training AI systems to be fully aligned are key components that require significant effort and progress in the field.

A minimal viable product for alignment

399 implied HN points • 29 Mar 22
🕹 Technology AI Research Automation Alignment ML
  1. Progress in AI can expand the range of problems humanity can solve, addressing the limitation of human capabilities.
  2. Automating alignment research using AI systems can accelerate progress by overcoming talent bottlenecks and enabling faster evaluation and generation of solutions.
  3. An alignment MVP approach is less ambitious than solving all alignment problems but can still lead to solutions by leveraging automation and AI capabilities.

What is inner alignment?

259 implied HN points • 08 May 22
🕹 Technology Machine Learning Artificial Intelligence Neural Networks Deep Learning
  1. Inner alignment involves the alignment of optimizers learned by a model during training, separate from the optimizer used for training.
  2. In rewardless meta-RL setups, the outer policy must adjust behavior between inner episodes based on observational feedback, which can lead to inner misalignment by learning inaccurate representations of the training-time reward function.
  3. Auto-induced distributional shift can lead to inner alignment problems, where the outer policy may cause its own inner misalignment by changing the distribution of inner RL problems.

Combining weak-to-strong generalization with scalable oversight

1 HN point • 20 Dec 23
🕹 Technology AI Alignment Generalization Oversight Models
  1. The paper discusses a new method called weak-to-strong generalization (W2SG) which involves finetuning large models to generalize well from weaker supervision, eventually aiming for human supervision.
  2. Combining scalable oversight and W2SG can be used together to align superhuman models, offering flexibility and potential synergy in training techniques.
  3. Alignment techniques like task decomposition, RRM, cross-examination, and interpretability function as consistency checks to ensure models provide accurate and truthful information.