Astral Codex Ten • 18927 implied HN points • 19 Feb 26
- People often complain about “crime” when they really mean visible disorder like litter, graffiti, shoplifting, tent encampments, and loud boom boxes, and that conflation helps explain why many feel crime is getting worse even though overall crime is low.
- The hard data are mixed and locally varied: litter seems down, graffiti is unclear, shoplifting is modestly higher than its lows but below 1990s levels, and homelessness and encampments rose around 2020 but are hard to measure consistently.
- There are several reasons people might perceive a rise in disorder — a 2020 bump, comparing today to an unusually peaceful mid-20th-century low, or simply different historical kinds of squalor — so it’s more useful to focus on specific, local evidence than on blanket claims that society is collapsing.