The hottest Left politics Substack posts right now

The left's past support or tolerance of oppressive regimes was a serious mistake, but many of those choices were made within limited options and intense international pressure. Governments and movements often picked the lesser evil available at the time rather than an ideal outcome.
Political decisions should be grounded in historical context and a lesser-evil calculus instead of strict moral purity, because insisting on perfect consistency can make ideas politically irrelevant. Real-world tradeoffs matter more than intellectual self-righteousness.
What looks like a sudden return of imperialism is actually part of a long historical pattern; US, Russian, and Chinese behaviors fit into older traditions of empire, and empires were active even during the neoliberal era. Recognizing continuity helps make better strategic choices today.

There is a surprising alliance between some Western leftists and radical Islamists during the Gaza war. This partnership mixes progressive social values with support for extreme actions against perceived enemies.
Historically, left-wing groups have sometimes aligned with radical leaders like Iran's Khomeini, even when they knew his views were extreme. They thought they could control the situation and benefit from this alliance.
In the late 1970s, Khomeini was largely unknown in the West, but exposure from the media changed perceptions. People mistakenly saw him as a democratic figure, which fueled this odd alignment.

Dissent magazine is important for holding power accountable and promoting progressive change. It's not just about opposing ideas; it's about helping to create workable policies for society.
The idea of 'passing the baton' means that those who are more experienced should support newer, more left-leaning voices in politics. It's about cooperation rather than just stepping back.
In today's political climate, a strong magazine like Dissent is needed to fight against authoritarianism and ensure that diverse viewpoints are heard. It's crucial for meaningful change to keep discussions alive.

If Germany's AfD party gets banned, it could lead to serious political change, affecting not just the AfD but also the center-right CDU party.
The current political system is balanced, but if left-leaning judges gain too much power, they might push for a ban on the AfD without reason.
The CDU needs to collaborate with the AfD to stay relevant and avoid losing their influence to leftist parties in the future.

The Left is seen as weak and disorganized, lacking a clear vision or plan for the future. Instead of leading change, it often gets caught up in fighting itself.
Historical movements, like communism and anarchism, have struggled to create lasting successes and often became absorbed by the systems they aimed to challenge.
The rise of artificial intelligence might pose a threat to capitalism, but the Left is mostly unprepared and lacks a unifying strategy to address these changes.

Get a weekly roundup of the best Substack posts, by hacker news affinity:

The American left has weakened significantly over the years, losing its voice and influence in politics. This has left many people without a true leftist movement to turn to.
The rise of the so-called 'woke left' focused more on identity issues rather than traditional class politics, which diluted the message of the left and was supported by the Democratic Party.
The terms 'left' and 'right' in politics no longer make sense and can confuse discussions about current issues. There's a call for new ways to think about politics beyond these outdated labels.

The Left has become disconnected from tangible reforms and needs to focus on addressing real issues to regain popular support.
Historically, movements that blended real-world goals with abstract ideologies have been more successful in effecting change.
Modern progressive ideologies often lack concrete applications and are detached from addressing real-world problems, limiting their impact.