The hottest Identity politics Substack posts right now

And their main takeaways
Category
Top World Politics Topics

Very Weird Ideas About What It Means to Respect Someone's Political Project

Freddie deBoer • 5754 implied HN points • 24 Feb 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Social justice Identity politics Political theory Activism Cultural Commentary
  1. The term 'woke' often means caring about other people, but some feel this definition flattens complex ideas about social justice. It can sound condescending when simplified.
  2. Many people work hard to understand and advocate for social justice, and their efforts deserve more respect than just being labeled as 'nice.'
  3. Using praise that oversimplifies someone's political values can be frustrating for those deeply invested in their beliefs, making it feel dismissive rather than supportive.

Kendrick Lamar: Talented Musician, Provocative Figure, Emperor of the Whites

Freddie deBoer • 10612 implied HN points • 12 Feb 25
🎭️ Culture Music Art Social Commentary Pop culture Identity politics
  1. Kendrick Lamar has achieved great success and is highly praised, but his status as an 'underdog' feels ironic given his fame and accolades. It shows how people love to label even the most successful artists as outsiders.
  2. The way people view music is changing; taste is now tied to moral values and public opinions. It's hard for individuals to just enjoy music without it being linked to their identity or politics.
  3. Many white people embrace Kendrick Lamar's art to appear morally good, which can overshadow the true appreciation of his talent. This dynamic is complex and reflects a broader issue in how we celebrate Black artists.

NYT Essay, My Name

The Upheaval • 1844 implied HN points • 06 Jun 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political Commentary Media Critique Cultural Commentary Identity politics
  1. The author wrote an opinion piece in the New York Times explaining the managerial regime and why some people dislike it. They want to share their views with a broader audience.
  2. The author has chosen to publish under a pen name, N.S. Lyons, but revealed their real name, Nathan Levine, after feeling ignored by journalists and NGOs.
  3. They mentioned their own background, noting that although they have some Jewish ancestry, they identify as an Orthodox Christian, and they are aware of how this might attract attention online.

How to Undo Woke Programming: 2024

Holly’s Newsletter • 2122 implied HN points • 23 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Education Social Issues Identity politics Cultural critique
  1. College courses can shape how we think about ourselves and others. Some classes may focus too much on victimhood, which can lead to a negative mindset.
  2. It's important to control our reactions when faced with assumptions about ourselves. Choosing kindness instead of anger can lead to better outcomes.
  3. Cultural messages can make us doubt our abilities and feel like victims. It's crucial to challenge these beliefs and recognize our own strength.

Perhaps You Would Be a Little Touchy Too

Freddie deBoer • 16429 implied HN points • 19 Jan 25
🏥 Health & Wellness Mental health Disability Psychiatry Therapy Identity politics
  1. Bipolar disorder is often misunderstood, with many thinking mood swings happen quickly, but the truth is they usually take weeks or months. It's important to really understand how the disorder works.
  2. People are increasingly claiming new and unusual diagnoses for mental health issues, which can undermine the seriousness of established conditions. This shift creates confusion and can affect how we view our own experiences.
  3. Claiming a diagnosis can feel liberating for some, but it can also lead to challenges when others misrepresent these conditions. It's tough when what you know to be true about your own illness feels threatened.
Get a weekly roundup of the best Substack posts, by hacker news affinity:

From a former liberal lunatic

Disaffected Newsletter • 4296 implied HN points • 19 Sep 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political Beliefs Cultural Change Psychology Identity politics Political polarization
  1. People can become deeply attached to their beliefs because of strong emotions rather than logic. Emotional experiences often shape our views more than facts do.
  2. A major life crisis can sometimes lead to a change in thinking. It might take hitting 'rock bottom' for someone to reevaluate and shift their perspectives.
  3. Understanding that some people's moral compass is deeply misaligned can help you see why they hold certain beliefs. They might genuinely think they are doing the right thing.

Trump 2.0: A Survival Guide for Democrats

Common Sense with Bari Weiss • 2541 implied HN points • 04 Feb 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Elections Political parties Public Opinion Political strategy Identity politics
  1. The Democratic Party is struggling more than ever, with only a third of Americans viewing it positively. This is the lowest approval rating the party has seen since 1992.
  2. Recent leadership changes in the DNC seem out of touch with the voters, as the new chair candidates focused on discussions around identity politics rather than addressing the party's failures.
  3. Young voters, especially Gen Z, feel unheard by the Democrats. Key issues like school safety, climate change, and economic pressures need to be prioritized if the party wants to connect with them.

America doesn't really have a working class

Noahpinion • 36765 implied HN points • 19 Nov 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Identity politics Voting Trends Political Discourse
  1. Many Americans, including those with college degrees, identify as 'working class', even if they earn good money. This shows that people often see themselves based on their experiences rather than their economic status.
  2. Class politics in America is tricky because the idea of a distinct 'working class' is fading. Many jobs are now varied and fragmented, making it hard for people to feel united as one economic group.
  3. Addressing economic issues is important, but Democrats should connect with voters as fellow Americans rather than trying to spark class struggle. Simply pushing class politics may not be effective.

Shibboleths of Stupid

Erick Erickson's Confessions of a Political Junkie • 2717 implied HN points • 09 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political Ideology Power Dynamics Cultural Commentary Government Role Identity politics
  1. Every group has specific words or ideas that only insiders can understand. These 'shibboleths' help determine who belongs and who doesn't.
  2. Some people twist facts to gain power and control, often using absurd claims to rally supporters. This can happen on both sides of politics.
  3. When people prioritize political power over truth, they lose touch with reality and can end up promoting silly ideas, which can spread widely.

Difficulties with Fanon

Global Inequality and More 3.0 • 1298 implied HN points • 03 Jun 25
📖 Philosophy Political theory Critical Theory Identity politics
  1. Fanon's ideas challenge us to think about violence differently. While some celebrate violence for self-realization, it's important to question the implications this has on society.
  2. Fanon expands Marxism beyond Europe, highlighting social issues in post-colonial contexts. His approach forced people to rethink modernization and the cultural complexities within different societies.
  3. Independence changed the narrative for many African countries, allowing them to create their own history. This agency is crucial, even if challenges like inequality and poor governance remain.

The Democrats have a flag problem

The Rubesletter by Matt Ruby (of Vooza) | Sent every Tuesday • 1354 implied HN points • 10 Jun 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political issues Patriotism Protests Identity politics Nationalism
  1. The left should embrace American patriotism instead of distancing itself from it. Showing support for America can help gain more allies in their cause.
  2. It's important for the left to focus on winning and stop acting like victims. Being more positive can attract voters.
  3. The left needs strong, confident leaders who can communicate their values effectively. Having a bold presence can resonate with people and gather support.

Identity politics isn't working

Noahpinion • 36824 implied HN points • 07 Nov 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Elections Political strategy Voting Trends Identity politics Public Opinion
  1. Identity politics isn't connecting with voters. Treating people as part of a racial group rather than as individuals hasn’t worked well for Democrats.
  2. Inflation is a bigger concern for people than unemployment. Voters are more focused on rising costs than job numbers.
  3. The educated class is losing touch with regular folks. There needs to be better understanding and communication between these groups.

Judith Butler with a Pretty Damn Good Indictment of Identity Politics!

Freddie deBoer • 12623 implied HN points • 17 Dec 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Identity politics Election Analysis Political critique Social justice
  1. The election results suggest that identity politics didn't cost Democrats the vote. Voters were more concerned about issues like the economy and immigration.
  2. People get frustrated when they're talked down to, and this negativity can hurt political movements. It's important to engage people without making them feel judged.
  3. Criticism of identity politics isn't just from the right; many thinkers on the left have also raised valid concerns. There's a need for honest reflection on how these ideas have shaped recent political events.

Equity Meme, Dominance Disputes, Voter Preferences

Rob Henderson's Newsletter • 965 implied HN points • 27 May 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Elections Voter Behavior Social Issues Identity politics Public Policy
  1. Alpha male chimpanzees can become too aggressive, leading lower-ranking males to team up against them. In extreme cases, they might even kill the dominant male.
  2. In the last century, men have grown much taller and stronger than women, possibly because women prefer taller, more muscular men.
  3. Voter preferences have changed, with white voters remaining stable in their choices while nonwhite voters have increasingly leaned towards the Republican party.

The Gaslighting, and a clarification

Disaffected Newsletter • 4316 implied HN points • 02 Aug 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Media Criticism Public Opinion Identity politics Social Issues
  1. Gaslighting is a serious issue where people are made to feel crazy for their beliefs. This can happen on a large scale in society, affecting how we see and understand certain situations.
  2. Physical characteristics, like bone structure and body shape, play a role in how we perceive someone's gender. It's important to acknowledge that many people can see these traits, regardless of their beliefs.
  3. Psychological manipulation can come from various sources, including media and authority figures. It's crucial to recognize this abuse and maintain self-respect to protect ourselves.

It’s Time for the Government to Abolish ‘Race’

Common Sense with Bari Weiss • 4219 implied HN points • 03 Dec 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Race Issues Government Policy Civil Rights Identity politics
  1. The government has been categorizing people into limited racial groups since 1977, which critics argue is outdated and arbitrary.
  2. Changes to these categories are coming, with the 2030 census set to have seven defined races instead of five, but these classifications are still seen as confusing and nonsensical.
  3. Some people believe that instead of having these set racial categories, the concept of race should be completely abolished in government practices.

Anti-Jew Bigotry Will Not Be Tolerated Here

Disaffected Newsletter • 3337 implied HN points • 10 Jul 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Identity politics Free speech Social Issues Community Standards
  1. No anti-Jewish bigotry will be allowed. This means any hateful comments or discrimination against Jewish people will not be tolerated.
  2. There's a difference between discussing issues related to Jewish identities and promoting bigotry. It's important to have rational conversations without being hateful.
  3. If someone breaks these rules, they will be asked to leave. There won't be chances for explanations or discussions about it.

the real lessons find a way

bad cattitude • 224 implied HN points • 31 May 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Education Racism Identity politics Society Policy
  1. Many believe that topics like racism and inequality have become more prominent in schools, causing division rather than unity. Some argue this creates a cycle of blame without solving the actual problems.
  2. The impact of the COVID pandemic opened parents' eyes to what their children were learning in schools. This has sparked increased scrutiny and questions about education content.
  3. Young people today have faced challenging times, which has made them more resilient. Many believe these experiences are preparing them to succeed in the future compared to previous generations.

Yes, fellow gays, it's partly our fault

Disaffected Newsletter • 2497 implied HN points • 02 Jul 24
🎭️ Culture LGBTQ+ Issues Social Commentary Public Perception Identity politics Mental health
  1. Some gay individuals are denying their role in the current social issues. They blame others for the public perception of homosexuality instead of looking at their own actions.
  2. There are concerns about the sexual behaviors being displayed in public spaces that are influencing people's views on the gay community. Some friends are pulling away because they feel criticized for sharing their concerns.
  3. The behaviors that have become associated with the gay community, such as breaking social boundaries, have been ongoing for a long time. This has created an environment where other groups feel able to push boundaries too.

Notes On the Great Vibe Shift

The Ruffian • 510 implied HN points • 18 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Elections Political culture Social Change Corporate Policy Identity politics
  1. There has been a noticeable shift in company policies, with many businesses moving away from diversity and inclusion initiatives since Trump's second win. This suggests that leaders now feel free to express their true beliefs.
  2. Unlike in previous elections, Trump's return has not sparked widespread outrage or resistance, showing a possible acceptance from even his opponents. People are more willing to see him as a leader they can work with.
  3. This change in culture not only affects American workplaces but also extends internationally, with global leaders now more eager to engage with Trump than oppose him. It marks a return to more traditional values in politics and business.

Liberals Warned Me About MAGA’s Racism. I Didn’t Believe Them—Until Now.

Common Sense with Bari Weiss • 709 implied HN points • 31 Dec 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Racism Immigration Political Movements Identity politics Social Commentary
  1. The author reflects on their past disbelief regarding claims of racism in MAGA, admitting they were initially skeptical of these warnings.
  2. An experience during high school made the author realize the implications of political shifts on racial tension and identity.
  3. Seeing recent hateful comments about India and its people has opened the author's eyes to the real racism that exists, highlighting a disturbing trend in public discourse.

Defeat Racism by Heightening the Contradictions

Richard Hanania's Newsletter • 3706 implied HN points • 17 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Racism Nationalism Far-right Identity politics Social Issues
  1. There are two types of people in white nationalist groups: some are smarter and focus on ideas, while others are just angry and uneducated. This creates a conflict in their beliefs.
  2. A lot of the smart people might avoid extremist groups because they don’t want to associate with those who have more basic racist views. They care about progress and quality.
  3. Talking about these contradictions can help people see that there are better ideas out there. Engaging with their views might not win over everyone, but it can show some there's no future in extreme identity politics.

What's wrong with Pride

Disaffected Newsletter • 899 implied HN points • 12 Jul 24
🎭️ Culture LGBTQ+ Social Issues Identity politics Cultural critique
  1. Pride started as a movement for legal rights, but it also involved a lot of partying and wild behavior among gay men.
  2. The gay community naturally had a mix of ideas that made it vulnerable to more extreme views from trans and queer groups.
  3. The changes in the Pride movement weren't forced from the outside; they were expected developments within the community.

Harris is flanking Trump on white male outreach

Jeff Giesea • 738 implied HN points • 06 Aug 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Elections Campaigns Identity politics Political strategy
  1. Kamala Harris's choice of Tim Walz as her running mate shows a strategy to appeal to straight white men. This move is seen as a way to reach a demographic that typically supports Trump.
  2. There is a belief that Walz's relatable personality and image could attract swing voters who might be on the fence about their political choices. Even small changes in voting patterns could have a big impact in the election.
  3. Harris could further connect with men by addressing their issues directly, which may help her campaign. Speaking on topics relevant to modern males could challenge the narrative and attract more support.

L’affaire Dokoupil: Is Ta-Nehisi Coates deeply ignorant, a bigoted antisemite, or both?

Carolina Curmudgeon • 59 implied HN points • 12 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Media Race Conflict Public Opinion Identity politics
  1. Ta-Nehisi Coates faced criticism for his views on Israel in a recent book, which some believe are biased and factually incorrect.
  2. Tony Dokoupil, the CBS host who questioned Coates, was admonished by CBS News, sparking a debate about media standards and questioning important figures.
  3. The discussion around Coates' statements raises concerns about the portrayal of Israel, with some arguing that he presents a one-sided narrative that ignores broader context.

"If a white person said that"

Disaffected Newsletter • 2557 implied HN points • 08 Apr 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Social Issues Racism Feminism Identity politics Media Critique
  1. Some people say harsh things about white people that wouldn't be acceptable if said about others. This creates a double standard in society.
  2. Many white people agree with negative views about themselves, thinking it will make them seem better to others.
  3. The idea that white people hold all the power in society is outdated, and it's important to address current attitudes that accept harmful statements against them.

Kemi Badenoch’s Fight for the UK—and the West

Common Sense with Bari Weiss • 459 implied HN points • 12 Dec 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Leadership Identity politics Party Politics Economic Policy Immigration
  1. Kemi Badenoch made history as the first black woman to lead the UK's Conservative Party, showcasing her unique background and experiences.
  2. Growing up in Nigeria during tough economic times helped shape her views on wealth, community, and the importance of hard work to maintain society's values.
  3. Badenoch's journey to conservatism was influenced by her early jobs and educational experiences, fueling her desire to promote ambition and potential in others.

In latest effort to deny reality, leftist German word police announce that a standard colloquialism for 'ethnic German' is racist, exclusionary and antidemocratic

eugyppius: a plague chronicle • 224 implied HN points • 13 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Cultural critique Racism Political Discourse Identity politics
  1. In Germany, there's a group that decides every year on a word they find unacceptable, calling it the 'Unword of the Year.' This word is often seen as politically incorrect.
  2. The latest 'Unword' chosen is 'biodeutsch,' which means ethnic German. This term is now said to be racist, even though it was originally used to highlight distinctions in identity.
  3. 'Unwords' aim to create awareness about harmful language, but critics argue it actually limits free speech and the ability to discuss cultural identities openly.

Who is allowed to practice identity politics?

Can We Still Govern? • 805 implied HN points • 10 Nov 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Identity politics Political strategy Election Analysis Media Critique
  1. Kamala Harris did not campaign on identity politics, even though many critics claim she did. Her campaign focused more on economic issues and policies rather than solely on identity-related topics.
  2. Donald Trump did use identity politics in his campaign by targeting specific groups negatively. He often painted immigrants and other marginalized groups as threats, which resonated with certain voter bases.
  3. The media tends to label identity politics as only a left-wing issue, ignoring how right-wing politics also play on group identities, especially among white Christian nationalists.

Wang Jisi on U.S. domestic politics in Trump’s Second Term

Pekingnology • 67 implied HN points • 16 May 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Elections Populism Identity politics Foreign Policy Political parties
  1. Trump's victory in the 2024 election showed that many voters are unhappy with the current state of the country. His focus on addressing economic issues resonated with people who felt left behind.
  2. The rise of right-wing populism is reshaping American politics, but this conflict over identity and values isn’t going away anytime soon. Different groups express their concerns through varying political movements.
  3. Even with Trump in power, big reforms won't be easy due to ongoing political divisions. His goals may face strong opposition, showing that change in politics is often complicated and slow.

Exchange with Amy Wax on Immigration

Richard Hanania's Newsletter • 1341 implied HN points • 05 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Immigration Debate Public Policy Cultural Issues Identity politics
  1. High-skilled immigrants can provide huge benefits to the economy, like famous innovators who lead successful companies. Losing out on these talents could seriously harm American progress.
  2. Many immigrants are integrating well into American culture, and younger generations generally feel connected to diverse communities. There's a common misconception that immigrants don’t assimilate.
  3. Debats about immigration should focus on the potential of individuals rather than broad groups. High-skilled workers can bring positive changes, so it's a mistake to view them all negatively.

The MAGA Civil War Over H-1B Visas

Common Sense with Bari Weiss • 180 implied HN points • 30 Dec 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Immigration Political Discourse Identity politics Policy Analysis
  1. The H-1B visa program allows U.S. companies to hire skilled workers from abroad, mainly benefiting tech companies that want to pay lower wages. It has become a point of conflict within the MAGA movement.
  2. Supporters of the program argue that it helps bring in talented workers that American companies need. However, critics say it creates a system that exploits workers and harms American wages.
  3. The debate over H-1B visas has highlighted deeper divisions in the right, between those who support immigration as part of America's identity and those who view it through a lens of racism and protectionism.

Kill the Chicken to Scare the Monkey

Rob Henderson's Newsletter • 928 implied HN points • 03 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Identity politics Political strategy Cultural Issues Social movements Public Discourse
  1. Identity politics can be used to create fear and control within groups. This can lead to people feeling pressured to conform to certain beliefs.
  2. Groups often engage in public shaming or 'struggle sessions' to enforce conformity. This method makes individuals afraid to speak out or be different.
  3. Understanding these tactics can help individuals navigate social pressures better. Knowing how fear works in group dynamics can be empowering.

Enjoying Trans Women, the End of Race Science, and More

Richard Hanania's Newsletter • 950 implied HN points • 30 Dec 24
🎭️ Culture Identity politics Social Issues Media Critique Literature
  1. The writer has changed their view on using pronouns and now feels more positive about people who are trans. They still express strong feelings against trans men, naming their preferences in a hierarchy.
  2. There's a new online bot based on the writer's ideas that offers a fun way to engage with their content. They hope it will improve over time and reflect their outlook more accurately.
  3. The writer encourages fans to join a Reddit community for discussions and shares a special subscription offer, highlighting the increasing engagement with their audience.

Leftist Men Are Pussies

Default Wisdom • 244 implied HN points • 05 Dec 24
🎭️ Culture Identity politics Online Communities Political Commentary Cultural criticism Social media
  1. Many people learn about political ideas online, with platforms like Tumblr shaping modern identity politics more than traditional classrooms. This shift influenced how journalists and young adults view these topics.
  2. The conversation around political beliefs can shift quickly, especially when people explore new ideas. It's easy to get caught up in finding identity through opposing viewpoints, whether on the left or the right.
  3. Understanding differing opinions can be enlightening, even if you don't agree with them. Engaging with various perspectives helps refine your own beliefs, but it can also be uncomfortable or lead to deep personal questions.

Black Republicans and Big Man Syndrome

Richard Hanania's Newsletter • 1536 implied HN points • 09 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political theory Voting Trends Party Dynamics Identity politics
  1. Some black Republicans are seen as performing for the audience, trying to challenge leftist views. Their backgrounds and statements can lead to controversy.
  2. Republicans may actively seek out black leaders to show they aren't racist, even if those candidates have questionable traits.
  3. The term 'Big Man Syndrome' describes leaders who gain power through charisma and personal control, rather than official positions. This idea comes from studying how some societies operate around influential figures.

Goblins

Disaffected Newsletter • 3617 implied HN points • 24 Aug 23
🎭️ Culture Social Issues Mental health Identity politics Body Image Urban life
  1. There seems to be a growing visibility of individuals who challenge traditional gender norms and body sizes, leading to strong reactions from observers. This reflects a deep societal divide in understanding and acceptance.
  2. Some people feel a sense of distress when they see others who clearly struggle with their mental and physical health, leading to feelings of discomfort and resentment towards those individuals.
  3. The narrative suggests a belief that societal values around beauty and behavior are shifting, often leaving traditional views feeling out of place or invalidated in certain communities.