gender:hacked by Eliza Mondegreen

The Substack, 'gender:hacked' by Eliza Mondegreen, delves into various facets of gender identity, including public perceptions, medical practices, and societal norms. It critically examines the complexities within gender medicine, the impact of sociopolitical debates, and the representation of gender issues in media, offering insights into the evolving understanding and discourse around gender identity.

Gender Identity Medical Practices in Gender Medicine Sociopolitical Debates on Gender Media Representation of Gender Issues Historical Perspectives on Gender Public Health Critiques of Ideological Standpoints Book Reviews and Recommendations

The hottest Substack posts of gender:hacked by Eliza Mondegreen

And their main takeaways

Top reads of the week

257 implied HN points • 02 Nov 24
🎭️ Culture Art Literature Music Fashion Media
  1. Check out the top reads of the week for interesting content. It's a great way to discover new ideas and topics.
  2. A 7-day free trial is available for accessing more posts and archives. You can explore a lot without any initial cost.
  3. You can subscribe to stay updated and keep reading more in-depth articles. Staying connected helps you learn new things.

WPATH, part II: The gist

1924 implied HN points • 30 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Healthcare policy Social justice Gender identity Medical Ethics Transgender Issues
  1. The World Professional Association for Transgender Health is now calling itself 'evidence-based', but some parts of their research have been held back, which affects their practice.
  2. They are aware of problems in their field, like overly simplistic assessment tools, but are trying to move towards more inclusive and open-ended questions.
  3. There are concerns about patients, especially young people, wanting to revert their gender decisions, which highlights the importance of supporting individual choices.

WPATH, part I: "The dignity of risk and the right to regret"

1884 implied HN points • 28 Oct 24
🏥 Health Politics Medical Ethics Patient rights Gender Issues Public Health Policy Debate
  1. Teenagers have the right to make decisions, even if they might regret them later. This is part of growing up and learning about themselves.
  2. Medical decisions, especially about serious treatments like hormone therapy, require careful consideration. They aren't just like normal teenage risks of dating or making silly choices.
  3. Clinicians must take responsibility for their actions and the potential harm they can cause. It's important to really think about the safety and effectiveness of medical interventions for young people.

Wishful thinking and bullshit-laundering

1607 implied HN points • 23 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Social Issues LGBTQ Rights Gender identity
  1. Trans communities might comfort young people about their fears regarding transition, but this can lead to unrealistic expectations about the outcomes.
  2. Young people often focus on details of their bodies in their transition journey, but they might overlook the bigger picture of biological differences that exist.
  3. There is a risk of young people blaming themselves or others for not achieving their goals in sports or transition, rather than recognizing the challenges they face.

The underside narrative surfaces

2956 implied HN points • 16 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Trans rights Legal issues Mental health Social justice Disability Rights
  1. Gavin Grimm faced a lot of bullying and rejection after coming out as transgender, which made life very difficult for him. His transition didn't solve all his problems and instead brought new challenges that he had to deal with.
  2. Grimm's story highlights the serious mental health issues that can arise, like PTSD, after being bullied and misunderstood. Even with support from friends and some family, the pain of being rejected really affected his well-being.
  3. There are questions about how well the medical community takes into account the unique struggles of transgender people, especially in cases like Grimm's. Just transitioning doesn't guarantee a happy future, and many still face tough realities.
Get a weekly roundup of the best Substack posts, by hacker news affinity:

Lisbon and Porto

1329 implied HN points • 20 Oct 24
🏝 Travel Destinations Culture Photography Experiences Events
  1. Lisbon is a beautiful city that some people fall in love with on their first visit. It has a unique charm and vibrant atmosphere that draws people back.
  2. Porto offers a different vibe, with its own lovely sights and experiences. Spending time there can be just as enjoyable as in Lisbon.
  3. Attending conferences in different cities like Lisbon can provide opportunities to explore and enjoy the local culture during free time.

Rebel Girls

1190 implied HN points • 21 Oct 24
🎭️ Culture Feminism Gender Issues Youth culture Identity Media influence
  1. Young girls today face new challenges that weren't present in the past, like social media pressures and unrealistic beauty standards. These factors can harm their self-esteem and mental health.
  2. There's a growing concern about the lack of safe spaces for girls and women to express themselves freely. Many fear speaking out due to potential backlash or judgment.
  3. It's important for girls to learn to love their bodies and build confidence. Staying active, making real-life connections, and enjoying their freedom can help them navigate their identities and lives better.

Top reads of the week

277 implied HN points • 26 Oct 24
📚 Literature Fiction Non-fiction Poetry Essays Criticism
  1. The week features a selection of interesting articles to read. It's a great way to catch up on new ideas and perspectives.
  2. There's an option for a 7-day free trial to access more content. This lets people explore more without any initial cost.
  3. You can easily share the top reads with friends. Sharing is a good way to discuss things you find valuable or thought-provoking.

"I'm actually quite alarmed/scared of how fast this is increasing from day to day."

1567 implied HN points • 09 Oct 24
🎭️ Culture Gender identity Mental health Social Issues Lifestyle Personal Stories
  1. Some people feel overwhelmed by their thoughts about gender transition. It can take over their daily lives and make it hard to focus on other things.
  2. Others struggle with their transition not meeting their expectations. They may feel like they're not passing as they hoped, leading to sadness and frustration.
  3. There are various opinions about what being a woman means, and it can be confusing. Each person's understanding of womanhood can be different based on their experiences.

An autogynephile walks into a reality check

1031 implied HN points • 14 Oct 24
🎭️ Culture Gender identity Social Dynamics Mental health Self-discovery
  1. A person may experience a sudden realization about their gender identity that challenges their current life situation. This can feel like a midlife crisis as they ponder big changes.
  2. Seeking different viewpoints about these feelings can lead to confusion. It might seem like a search for answers, but often it just adds to the uncertainty.
  3. Joining supportive communities can feel comforting, but sometimes it may lead to unrealistic expectations about one's identity and create pressure rather than relief.

ICYMI: Trans thought experiments

1170 implied HN points • 07 Oct 24
🎭️ Culture Identity Gender Philosophy Literature Community
  1. Thought experiments can help people think about their gender identity, like imagining a magical button that changes your sex. If you'd push that button, it might mean you feel trans.
  2. Imagining transformation doesn't change real-life limits and challenges of transitioning. It can be more complex than just wishing for change.
  3. The journey of transformation can have unexpected outcomes. It's not just about the physical changes, but also dealing with inner feelings and realities.

Top reads of the week

297 implied HN points • 19 Oct 24
📚 Literature Fiction Poetry Essays Criticism Reviews
  1. You can find a list of popular articles to read each week. It's a great way to discover new topics and ideas.
  2. There’s an option to subscribe for a free trial to access more articles. This allows you to see if you like the content before committing.
  3. The site has a focus on specific interests, making it easier to find related information you care about. It's like having a personalized reading list.

Top reads of the week

277 implied HN points • 12 Oct 24
🎭️ Culture Art Literature Media Entertainment History
  1. Reading weekly highlights can help you discover new ideas and topics of interest.
  2. Keeping up with trending articles allows you to stay informed and engaged with current discussions.
  3. Subscribing to newsletters or content can offer deeper insights and access to exclusive material.

Top reads of the week

238 implied HN points • 05 Oct 24
🎭️ Culture Literature Art Music Fashion Philosophy
  1. There are top reads each week that can keep you informed and entertained. It's a great way to discover new content that interests you.
  2. You can subscribe to get a free trial and access more in-depth posts. This is a good option if you want to explore more topics.
  3. The featured artwork, like 'Houses by the Sea', adds a visual appeal to the reading experience. Art can enhance our understanding of different subjects.

Pathological body projects in the pages of Teen Vogue

2241 implied HN points • 22 Jan 24
  1. Teen Vogue features nonbinary actress Liv Hewson discussing struggles with gender dysphoria and anorexia.
  2. Liv Hewson challenges misconceptions about gender-affirming surgeries and emphasizes body autonomy.
  3. The interview highlights the importance of self-acceptance and the positive impact of top surgery on Liv Hewson's life.

Very human problems in the field of gender medicine

2162 implied HN points • 08 Jan 24
  1. Gender clinicians in the field of gender medicine may start out with good intentions but could end up causing harm due to indoctrination into harmful practices.
  2. There is emotional pressure and ideological influence within the field that can make clinicians compromise their critical thinking skills.
  3. The human level of gender-affirming care discussions often gets lost in debates between affirmation and transphobia, showing the complexity of the field beyond just good or bad actors.

Have Americans had their fill of gender?

2063 implied HN points • 10 Jan 24
  1. Debates over gender are dominating state legislatures in the US.
  2. Public support for certain transgender agenda items is decreasing due to concerns about safety and fairness.
  3. Common sense may eventually prevail over unreasonable demands related to gender.

Strict orthodoxy sinks late night

1805 implied HN points • 29 Jan 24
  1. Strict orthodoxy can be harmful for comedians.
  2. It's important for comedians to avoid being too rigid in their beliefs.
  3. Comedy evolves with the times and needs to adapt to changing societal norms.

The New York Times ventures beyond the "complexities" of gender-affirming care

1547 implied HN points • 08 Feb 24
  1. The New York Times has explored the complexities of gender-affirming care.
  2. There are concerns raised about how clinicians handle patient self-identification in gender-affirming care.
  3. The reporting delves into the challenges and controversies in the field of gender medicine.

Guest review of Ånger: Ett reportage inifrån transvården

1388 implied HN points • 05 Feb 24
  1. The book provides an insightful look into the state of youth gender medicine in Sweden.
  2. It highlights cases of detransitioners and the complexities of gender identity in children and adolescents.
  3. The book exposes controversies and challenges within the field of gender-affirming care, raising questions about evidence-based practices and ideological motivations.

We've always been at war with Byzantine transmisogyny

1468 implied HN points • 24 Jan 24
  1. The concept of gender identity and transgender identities is relatively new, emerging from new medical technologies and ways of thinking about identity.
  2. Trans activists are criticized for imposing contemporary ideologies on historical figures, instead of acknowledging the novelty and uniqueness of the concepts they champion.
  3. There is controversy around changing historical figures' identities to fit modern perspectives, with calls for greater recognition and protection of new ways of being.

Just for fun: Havana

1408 implied HN points • 14 Jan 24
  1. The post shares photos from a trip to Havana taken four years ago.
  2. The author expresses a desire for warmth and color in contrast to the current cold and gray weather.
  3. There are multiple images embedded in the post, showcasing the vibrant and colorful scenes of Havana.

What kids are looking for—and finding—online

1051 implied HN points • 17 Jan 24
  1. The post discusses what young people are searching for and discovering regarding gender online.
  2. It includes findings and hypotheses presented to a parent group in the US.
  3. Readers can access more information by starting a 7-day free trial on the gender:hacked newsletter.

The SPLC and the no good very bad white Christian nationalist but also just unpopular anti-LGBTQ+ pseudoscience network

1130 implied HN points • 04 Jan 24
  1. The Southern Poverty Law Center (SPLC) published a report on an anti-LGBTQ+ pseudoscience network linked with white Christian nationalist ideology.
  2. The report aims to discredit pushback against youth gender transition and gender self-ID policies by labeling opponents with derogatory terms.
  3. The SPLC report accuses the network of promoting pseudoscience while using unverifiable concepts as unquestionable scientific facts.

Sadists and masochists

714 implied HN points • 31 Jan 24
  1. The author reflects on leaving the public health world and highlights the negative aspects like groupthink and guilt.
  2. The article discusses the sorry state of public health and how some individuals interpret it in a different light.
  3. There's mention of accountability pods, white fragility, and other societal issues in the context of public health.

The Vital Spark

575 implied HN points • 07 Feb 24
  1. The Vital Spark encourages women to embrace qualities like shrewdness and authority
  2. Neglecting our true desires and qualities can lead to negative consequences like depression or anxiety
  3. Exploring and reclaiming our unlived possibilities can lead to a more fulfilling and rejuvenated life

Top reads of the week

575 implied HN points • 03 Feb 24
  1. Eliza Mondegreen offers top reads of the week on Substack.
  2. Readers can subscribe to gender:hacked for a 7-day free trial and access to full post archives.
  3. Paid subscribers can sign in to access more content.

Top reads of the week

495 implied HN points • 10 Feb 24
  1. The post features the top reads of the week from Eliza Mondegreen's Substack newsletter.
  2. To continue reading the full post and access the archives, there's a 7-day free trial available for new subscribers.
  3. Existing paid subscribers can sign in to access the content.

Top reads of the week

535 implied HN points • 20 Jan 24
  1. The post is promoting the top reads of the week on Eliza Mondegreen's Substack.
  2. The post mentions a 7-day free trial for readers to access the full post archives.
  3. To continue reading, users are encouraged to subscribe to Eliza Mondegreen's Substack.

Top reads of the week

555 implied HN points • 13 Jan 24
  1. Eliza Mondegreen offers top reads of the week in their Substack newsletter.
  2. To access full post archives, readers can start a 7-day free trial of gender:hacked by Eliza Mondegreen.
  3. Paid subscribers can sign in for full access to the content.

Top reads of the week and book club scheduling

456 implied HN points • 06 Jan 24
  1. Top reads of the week are highlighted in this post
  2. The book club is reading Suzanne O'Sullivan's 'Sleeping Beauties'
  3. Access to the full post archives with a 7-day free trial subscription

Top reads of the week + the next book-club read

376 implied HN points • 27 Jan 24
  1. Top reads of the week and upcoming book club read are featured in the post.
  2. The next book club read is 'Trouble with Gender' by Alex Byrne, with a Doodle poll behind the paywall to vote for the date/time.
  3. Readers can access a 7-day free trial to subscribe and continue enjoying the content.