The hottest Trans rights Substack posts right now

And their main takeaways
Category
Top U.S. Politics Topics

The underside narrative surfaces

gender:hacked by Eliza Mondegreen • 2956 implied HN points • 16 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Trans rights Legal issues Mental health Social justice Disability Rights
  1. Gavin Grimm faced a lot of bullying and rejection after coming out as transgender, which made life very difficult for him. His transition didn't solve all his problems and instead brought new challenges that he had to deal with.
  2. Grimm's story highlights the serious mental health issues that can arise, like PTSD, after being bullied and misunderstood. Even with support from friends and some family, the pain of being rejected really affected his well-being.
  3. There are questions about how well the medical community takes into account the unique struggles of transgender people, especially in cases like Grimm's. Just transitioning doesn't guarantee a happy future, and many still face tough realities.

The Daily Mail proves my point

Men Yell at Me • 235 implied HN points • 24 May 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Equality Trans rights Sports Media Culture
  1. Trans girls do not threaten cis girls; they are actually the ones facing threats. Everyone, including all children, deserves to compete in sports and be treated with love and protection.
  2. There's research that shows trans girls do not have an unfair advantage in sports. It’s important to focus on facts rather than fear.
  3. The response from major publications can reflect broader societal attitudes. The fact that a national paper spent time on a niche topic shows the ongoing normalization of transphobia in culture.

What The Detransitioner Clementine Breen’s Gender “Therapy” Looked Like

Singal-Minded • 1083 implied HN points • 28 Dec 24
🏥 Health Politics Gender Issues Mental health Activism Medical Ethics Trans rights
  1. Clementine Breen, a UCLA student, is suing her doctor for care she received during her transition. She feels that the treatments led her to regret her decisions.
  2. Breen's therapy involved close connections between her therapist and the medical staff, which raises concerns about impartiality. This makes it important to have independent support in such sensitive situations.
  3. There were signs that Breen's gender identity questions came about due to recent family trauma, suggesting that therapists should explore underlying issues before making treatment decisions.

Ex-prison inmate, Frances, tells her story of living with a trans-identifying male (a man) in an NZ women’s jail

A B’Old Woman • 899 implied HN points • 17 Jun 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Prison System Gender identity Women's Rights Criminal Justice Trans rights
  1. Frances shares her experience of living in a women's jail alongside a trans-identifying male who was involved in an assault against her. It highlights her struggle and feelings of vulnerability in that situation.
  2. After living with this man in the self-care unit, Frances had to negotiate living arrangements and ensure safety while also trying to keep the peace, indicating complex dynamics in prison life.
  3. Corrections NZ policies on housing trans-identifying males with women have changed over time, but Frances emphasizes that these men are still fundamentally men, impacting how women feel in these environments.
Get a weekly roundup of the best Substack posts, by hacker news affinity:

ScienceVs: Trans Kids Health Care: Are We Getting It Wrong? (II)

Carolina Curmudgeon • 39 implied HN points • 12 Oct 24
🏥 Health Politics Trans rights Medical Ethics Child Health Mental health Public Policy
  1. 1. The podcast only featured experts who support gender-affirming care, not those who might question its effectiveness. This creates a one-sided view of a complicated issue.
  2. 2. The discussion did not challenge any ideas about gender identity or question the idea that being trans is just as normal as being cisgender. This could limit understanding of the topic.
  3. 3. A study noted that using a preferred name can significantly reduce suicidal thoughts in gender dysphoric kids. However, instead of pushing for medical treatments, maybe simple name changes and support could be a better first step.

Twenty years a target of the trans cabal

Julie Bindel's podcasts and writing • 1886 implied HN points • 08 Feb 24
🌍 World Politics Feminism Trans rights Activism Gender Ideology LGBTQ Rights
  1. The author has been targeted by trans activists for 20 years, facing protests, threats, and being de-platformed.
  2. The rise of gender ideology and the inclusion of trans rights have challenged traditional feminist views and sparked debates.
  3. Despite backlash, the author remains committed to advocating for women's rights and challenging bigotry.

Women and girls have lost control of our spaces to men. Not all men will support this, but some will revel in it.

A B’Old Woman • 899 implied HN points • 14 Mar 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Gender Issues Trans rights Public Policy Social justice Women's Rights
  1. Women and girls are losing control over their own spaces, which should be designated for them alone. This is a big concern because it affects their safety and privacy.
  2. Allowing any man who claims to be a woman into women's spaces can lead to potential risks. There’s fear that it could put women and girls in uncomfortable or dangerous situations.
  3. Many people dismiss the concerns about men in women's spaces, but it's important to recognize that no woman or girl should feel unsafe or worried about who might be in those spaces with them.

Ex-Corrections NZ prison officer, Josie, shares her experience of dealing with trans-identifying-males (men) in women’s prisons.

A B’Old Woman • 619 implied HN points • 02 Apr 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Gender Issues Prison Reform Trans rights Policy Debate Workplace Safety
  1. A former prison officer discussed the challenges of working with trans-identifying males in women's prisons. She highlighted the lack of proper training for staff on how to handle such situations.
  2. She mentioned how the system seems to prioritize the needs of trans-identifying males without considering the feelings and safety of the female inmates and staff. This led to uncomfortable situations for female officers.
  3. The officer expressed her personal struggles and discomfort resulting from having to conduct strip searches on these individuals, illustrating the broader impact this type of policy can have on female staff in corrections.

To NYT’s Peter Baker, Acknowledging Trans People’s Existence Is “Activism,” Openly Advocating for Perpetual U.S. Occupation of Afghanistan Isn’t

The Column • 963 implied HN points • 22 Feb 23
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Activism Journalism Bias Trans rights
  1. The definition of 'activism' can vary depending on the political stance.
  2. Elite reporters struggle to define the line between journalism and activism, relying on a vague 'vibe' instead of clear principles.
  3. Despite claiming impartiality, some journalists display clear ideological bias in their reporting.

"Dear Lee, thank you for standing up for women, when none of the women did."

A B’Old Woman • 599 implied HN points • 28 Sep 23
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Gender Issues Trans rights Feminism Social justice Political Debate
  1. Men who identify as women can pose a risk to women in single-sex spaces, and it's important to keep those spaces safe.
  2. Some arguments about determining who is a woman, like inspecting genitals, are not practical and ignore our ability to recognize gender clues.
  3. It's concerning when women's rights are compromised for the sake of accommodating men who identify as women, and there's a need for balance.

Disinformation aplenty from the aptly named Disinformation Project.

A B’Old Woman • 639 implied HN points • 04 May 23
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Disinformation Trans rights Hate Speech Public Policy Social Issues
  1. There is growing online hate towards trans people, especially after certain events that sparked this backlash. This highlights ongoing tensions in discussions around trans rights.
  2. The argument that there is 'no evidence' of trans people being violent is seen as misleading. Critics say that this overlooks the need for better data collection on the impacts of trans policies.
  3. Some believe that allowing trans women into women's spaces increases risk to women and girls. This viewpoint stresses the need for careful consideration around policies involving gender identity.

NZ's Women's Rights Party receives a (no surprises) anti-trans slur from "proudly non-partisan" Policy.nz

A B’Old Woman • 359 implied HN points • 10 Sep 23
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Women's Rights Trans rights Political parties Human Rights
  1. The Women's Rights Party in New Zealand focuses on protecting women's rights and feels they are being silenced in discussions about their concerns.
  2. They believe that their rights should not be defined by their stance on trans issues and wish to express their views on women's issues without being labeled negatively.
  3. The party claims that assessments by Policy.nz are biased and unfair, suggesting that this reflects a broader misunderstanding of women's rights.

The judgement is out for Sall Grover’s ‘Tickle v Giggle’ court case, and it means that Australian women have NO female-only sanctuaries anymore.

A B’Old Woman • 3 HN points • 23 Aug 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Gender Rights Legal issues Judiciary Women's Rights Trans rights
  1. A court ruling in Australia has decided that women can no longer have private spaces just for them. This means any man can say he's a woman and enter those spaces.
  2. The judge in this case ruled that a person's legal paperwork can change their identified sex, even if their physical traits do not match. This has raised concerns about how this affects the safety and rights of women.
  3. There are ongoing debates about gender rights and safety for women. Some argue that this ruling could set a precedent for similar laws in other countries, prompting calls for action to protect women's rights.

I can’t help but notice the difference in what people are doing …..

A B’Old Woman • 219 implied HN points • 17 Feb 23
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Activism Disasters Public response Trans rights Social Issues
  1. Cyclone Gabrielle has caused severe damage in New Zealand, leaving many people homeless and without basic necessities like water and power.
  2. While the community suffers from this disaster, some activists are choosing to focus on events far away, which seems out of touch with the local needs.
  3. There is a call for people to prioritize local help and support for those affected by the cyclone rather than holding protests and vigils for distant events.

When Kellie-Jay Keen comes to New Zealand, we women will be looking out for each other.

A B’Old Woman • 219 implied HN points • 05 Feb 23
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Trans rights Women's Rights Activism Social Issues Public Policy
  1. Kellie-Jay Keen is coming to New Zealand for her 'Let Women Speak' tour, and women plan to support each other during the events. It's important to be united and look out for one another.
  2. There have been incidents of harassment from activists during similar events in other countries, which raises concerns about safety. Women, especially the elderly and disabled, need protection from intimidation.
  3. Past experiences show that activisting groups can be aggressive, making it crucial for women to be prepared and aware of each other when attending such events. Safety in numbers and awareness can help prevent harassment.

Did Jacinda Ardern inspect David Seymour’s genitals before calling him “an arrogant prick”?

A B’Old Woman • 199 implied HN points • 15 Dec 22
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Gender Issues Political Satire Trans rights Cultural Commentary Public Figures
  1. Using the word 'prick' is traditionally aimed at men, and it raises questions about assumptions made about gender. The author humorously suggests that if someone might not present as male, should we be cautious about our language?
  2. The idea of needing to inspect someone's genitals to determine their gender is highlighted as absurd. Many believe we can recognize gender based on social cues and experiences.
  3. There’s a conflict in how society views gender and language, especially when it comes to terms that might seem offensive or outdated. The piece stresses that understanding gender requires more than just looking at physical traits.

Why now?

Links I Would Gchat You If We Were Friends • 0 implied HN points • 01 Jul 22
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Social media Congress Far-right Trans rights
  1. The toxic mass delusion known as 'Q' has resurfaced and is causing concerning impacts in society, including misinformation and seditious behavior.
  2. Various interesting articles have been shared, covering topics like transphobia, period trackers, ADHD communities, neuroscience breakthroughs, and underground party scenes.
  3. In the tech and media world, worker-owned platforms, unique internet content, diaspora community accounts, and the impact of online platforms on society are discussed.