Marcus on AI

Marcus on AI critically explores the advancements, limitations, ethical considerations, and societal implications of artificial intelligence technologies. Through detailed analysis, it discusses issues like AI's understanding of math, transparency in AI development, AI risks, copyright infringement by AI, and the potential misuse of AI in various sectors.

AI Advancements and Limitations Ethics and AI AI in Society AI and Law AI for Military Strategy Environmental Impact of AI AI in Healthcare AI and Education AI and Jobs AI Policy and Regulation

The hottest Substack posts of Marcus on AI

And their main takeaways

Karen Bakker, 1971-2023

3517 implied HN points • 07 Sep 23
🎨 Art & Illustration Tribute Obituary Inspiration
  1. Karen Bakker was a visionary with broad interests and expertise
  2. She was a successful academic, global adventurer, and political leader
  3. Karen Bakker's work focused on using AI to improve animal communication and addressing environmental dilemmas
Get a weekly roundup of the best Substack posts, by hacker news affinity:

Happy 1st Birthday, GPT-4

1383 implied HN points • 16 Mar 24
🕹 Technology AI Ethics Applications Progress Competition
  1. There seems to be a possible plateau in GPT-4's capability, with no one decisively beating it yet.
  2. Despite challenges, there has been progress in discovering applications and putting GPT-4 type models into practice.
  3. Companies are finding putting Large Language Models into real-world use challenging, with many initial expectations proving unrealistic.

OpenAI’s “Own Goal”

98 HN points • 06 Mar 24
🕹 Technology AI Ethics Copyright Racism Innovation
  1. OpenAI's mission of being open-source and collaborative has shifted over the years, leading to concerns about transparency and integrity.
  2. Email communications between OpenAI and Elon Musk raised doubts about the organization's commitment to its stated mission of open-sourcing technology.
  3. Recent incidents of covert racism, copyright infringements, and violent content generated by OpenAI's technology have raised questions about the ethical impact of their work.

OpenAI’s Lies and Half-Truths

76 HN points • 15 Mar 24
🕹 Technology Artificial Intelligence Transparency Regulation Data Training Corporate ethics
  1. OpenAI has been accused of not being completely candid in their communications and responses to questions.
  2. There have been instances where OpenAI's statements may not accurately reflect their true intentions or actions.
  3. Concerns have been raised about OpenAI's transparency regarding their data training sources, financial matters, regulation views, and future plans.

Seven reasons why the world should say No to Sam Altman

61 HN points • 10 Feb 24
🕹 Technology AI Energy Economics Financial risk Human Capital
  1. Investing $7 trillion in AI infrastructure would have significant energy and climate implications, possibly leading to heavy environmental costs.
  2. $7 trillion for AI exceeds the economic resources allocated to critical areas like education or ending world hunger, highlighting potential opportunity costs.
  3. Such a massive financial risk of a $7 trillion project could have severe consequences on the world economy, similar to the impact of the 2007-2008 financial crisis.

An Open Letter to Sam Altman

31 HN points • 11 Feb 24
🕹 Technology AI Technology Ethics Artificial Intelligence
  1. The author questions the investment in Large Language Models (LLMs) as a means to secure our future, raising concerns about potential negative impacts on content creators, women, the environment, democracy, and jobs.
  2. There is skepticism about the $7 trillion investment in LLMs and their infrastructure, wondering if it will truly benefit humanity or if it might lead to unintended consequences.
  3. The letter suggests a cautious approach, highlighting the importance of not rushing into technological advancements and making premature commitments that could have long-term negative effects.

The last two weeks at OpenAI

20 HN points • 29 Feb 24
🕹 Technology AI Research Startups Lawsuits Partnerships
  1. OpenAI has faced challenges like Sora demo issues, departing researchers, and ChatGPT malfunctions recently.
  2. Competitors like Google and Mistral are catching up with GPT-4, raising concerns about robustness in AI development.
  3. Legal challenges in the form of lawsuits, including a copyright case and a broader class action, are surfacing against OpenAI.

Sora’s Surreal Physics

5 HN points • 16 Feb 24
🕹 Technology AI Generative AI
  1. The quality of the video produced by OpenAI's latest text-video synthesizer is impressive, almost indistinguishable from reality at a glance.
  2. OpenAI's lack of transparency on training models raises concerns about potential misuse for disinformation and propaganda, especially in upcoming events like the 2024 elections.
  3. Sora's unrealistic physics glitches indicate limitations in generative AI systems like Sora, demonstrating issues in understanding space, time, and causality crucial for building true AGI capabilities.

No, RAG is probably not going to rescue the current situation

3 HN points • 23 Feb 24
🕹 Technology Artificial Intelligence Machine Learning Tech industry AI Ethics Research
  1. In Silicon Valley, accountability for promises is often lacking, especially with over $100 billion invested in areas like the driverless car industry with little to show for it.
  2. Retrieval Augmentation Generation (RAG) is a new hope for enhancing Large Language Models (LLMs), but it's still in its early stages and not a guaranteed solution yet.
  3. RAG may help reduce errors in LLMs, but achieving reliable artificial intelligence output is a complex challenge that won't be easily solved with quick fixes or current technology.

The ROI on GenAI might not be so great, after all

1 HN point • 12 Mar 24
🕹 Technology AI Generative AI Microsoft ROI
  1. The ROI for Generative AI might not be as expected, with reports of underwhelming outcomes for tools like Microsoft Copilot.
  2. There are signs of the hype around Generative AI being dialed back, as expectations are being tempered by industry experts and users.
  3. Despite the uncertainty in ROI, there are still massive investments in Generative AI, highlighting differing opinions on its potential benefits.

Statistics versus Understanding: The Essence of What Ails Generative AI

1 HN point • 13 Feb 24
🕹 Technology AI Generative AI Statistics Understanding
  1. Generative AI often relies on statistics as a shortcut for true understanding, leading to shaky foundations and errors.
  2. Challenges arise when generative AI systems fail to grasp complex concepts or contexts beyond statistical relationships.
  3. Examples in various domains show the struggle between statistical frequency and genuine comprehension in generative AI.