Richard Hanania's Newsletter $10 / month

Richard Hanania's Newsletter focuses on foreign policy, American politics, and social science through a critical lens, examining themes such as personal growth, societal issues, the impact of ideology on culture and education, the dynamics of American political movements, and the implications of technology and capitalism. It challenges current narratives, offering insights on a wide range of topics from the abortion debate to the nature of intellectual engagement.

Personal Development Societal and Cultural Issues American Politics Foreign Policy Education and Ideology Technology and Politics Capitalism and Market Forces Health and Lifestyle

The hottest Substack posts of Richard Hanania's Newsletter

And their main takeaways

Exchange with Amy Wax on Immigration

1194 implied HN points • 05 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Immigration Debate Public Policy Cultural Issues Identity politics
  1. High-skilled immigrants can provide huge benefits to the economy, like famous innovators who lead successful companies. Losing out on these talents could seriously harm American progress.
  2. Many immigrants are integrating well into American culture, and younger generations generally feel connected to diverse communities. There's a common misconception that immigrants don’t assimilate.
  3. Debats about immigration should focus on the potential of individuals rather than broad groups. High-skilled workers can bring positive changes, so it's a mistake to view them all negatively.

2024 Was the Year I Didn't Change Much

2560 implied HN points • 27 Dec 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political Commentary Elections Cultural critique Immigration Policy
  1. The writer feels more confident that mainstream political science accurately describes society, as there's no sign of a democracy in crisis and the economy is growing well.
  2. The writer has become disillusioned with the Tech Right, observing that talented individuals in right-wing circles can start falling for misinformation and conspiracy theories.
  3. Despite facing criticism, the writer values intellectual honesty over maintaining friendships, believing it’s essential to prioritize truth and integrity in discussions about politics and social issues.

Enjoying Trans Women, the End of Race Science, and More

902 implied HN points • 30 Dec 24
🎭️ Culture Identity politics Social Issues Media Critique Literature
  1. The writer has changed their view on using pronouns and now feels more positive about people who are trans. They still express strong feelings against trans men, naming their preferences in a hierarchy.
  2. There's a new online bot based on the writer's ideas that offers a fun way to engage with their content. They hope it will improve over time and reflect their outlook more accurately.
  3. The writer encourages fans to join a Reddit community for discussions and shares a special subscription offer, highlighting the increasing engagement with their audience.

Boy, Girl, Boy

7509 implied HN points • 07 Dec 24
  1. The author finds it funny and interesting to refer to his son simply as 'Boy,' emphasizing a laid-back approach to parenting. He believes kids shouldn’t be put on a pedestal and recognizes the importance of letting them be who they are.
  2. He sees his son as unique and smart, showing early signs of great intellectual curiosity in things like math and geography. The author hopes to foster this curiosity while also worrying about his son's tendency to follow others and his emotional sensitivity.
  3. With the arrival of his daughter, he notes her carefree and confident personality, contrasting with her brother's delicacy. He appreciates her independence and humor, highlighting the differences in how his children interact with the world.

Bioaccelerationism Is a No-Brainer

2682 implied HN points • 20 Dec 24
🕹 Technology Biotech AI Innovation Health Ethics
  1. Bioaccelerationism focuses on advancing biotechnology that improves reproduction, making it easier for couples to have children. New methods are coming out that can help reduce the stress and difficulty associated with traditional fertility treatments like IVF.
  2. Unlike some technologies that can quickly change the world, biotechnology develops slowly, giving society time to understand its effects. This means we can monitor and ensure safety as new methods emerge over time.
  3. The goals of biotech often align with the needs of parents and society. Developing health, intelligence, and beauty can benefit everyone, and the risks are generally limited to individuals or families rather than posing a threat to society as a whole.
Get a weekly roundup of the best Substack posts, by hacker news affinity:

The Origins of Elite Human Capital Institutions and Communities

1779 implied HN points • 23 Dec 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political theory Institutions Governance Elites Authoritarianism Cultural norms
  1. Elite Human Capital institutions emerge when smart and idealistic people come together, seeking truth and shared values over just making money. These communities form naturally as individuals find others like themselves.
  2. Wealth-maximizers and meaning-maximizers represent two paths that people can take in these communities. While some focus on financial success, others prioritize making meaningful contributions to society.
  3. Authoritarian regimes often suppress elite human capital because educated people pose a threat to their power. When these institutions are stifled, it can hinder a country's overall progress and development.

Uncle Sam as the Hegelian Hammer

4071 implied HN points • 09 Dec 24
🌍 World Politics Middle East Civil War U.S. foreign policy Terrorism
  1. The Assad regime in Syria collapsed after years of civil war, leading to uncertainty about the country's future. There are concerns that power vacuums can cause chaos and that extremist groups might still pursue their goals.
  2. Bashar al-Assad's rule was marked by hereditary leadership and lack of legitimacy, which led to his government's reliance on fear and violence to maintain control. This situation was not sustainable in the long run.
  3. Despite the difficulties ahead, the fall of the Assad regime allows for the possibility of new governance. The U.S. can play a role in guiding Syria towards better prospects by applying pressure on illiberal forces.

Donald Trump and the Decivilizing of the Right

1975 implied HN points • 17 Dec 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Conservatism Political culture Election Analysis Trumpism
  1. American conservatism is changing in a way that some people compare to third world movements. This shift involves less focus on traditional values.
  2. The concept of 'Elite Human Capital' is about understanding who is crucial for maintaining strong institutions, not just about being smart. It suggests that even those who aren’t traditionally regarded as intelligent can still be valuable in certain roles.
  3. The flaws in the Trump movement highlight the importance of character and truth in political movements. When a political group idolizes someone who goes against these values, it signals a deeper issue within the movement.

Non-Leftist Media and the Michael Shellenberger Problem

5583 implied HN points • 18 Nov 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political Analysis Media Critique Public Opinion
  1. Repeating the same complaints without real analysis doesn't help understand politics. It's not enough to just say what's wrong without explaining why it matters.
  2. Some commentators give reasons to support their political views, but they often ignore important issues. If someone only blames 'elites' without discussing specific actions, it shows a lack of real engagement.
  3. Many people seem interested in hearing simple, repetitive messages rather than deep understanding of current events. This undermines learning and can make people less informed about actual politics.

Politics is Full of Bad People Who Do Good Things

4779 implied HN points • 11 Nov 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political Ideology Conservatism Education & Policy Governance
  1. Sometimes, people who support bad ideas can still create good outcomes. It's important to recognize that even if someone has questionable morals, their actions can still benefit society.
  2. In politics, it can be necessary to form alliances with those we don't agree with. Supporting a cause we believe in might require working with people whose values we find unappealing.
  3. Political strategies often need to adapt to reality. It's crucial to prioritize practical wins for individual freedoms, even if it means partnering with groups that don't fully align with our principles.

I Am Paying Reparations to the Shrimp

4096 implied HN points • 15 Nov 24
📖 Philosophy Ethics Animal Rights Utilitarianism Debate Charity
  1. It's important to think about the impact of our food choices on animals, like shrimp, and consider ethical options.
  2. Donating to animal welfare projects can help make a positive change and relieve some guilt about eating certain foods.
  3. Finding a balance between personal enjoyment and ethical responsibility can be tough, but small actions, like donating money, can make a difference.

Somewhere in America...

5583 implied HN points • 02 Nov 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Public Opinion Voting behavior Political parties Electoral process Democracy
  1. People's experiences shape their political beliefs. Different backgrounds can lead individuals to align with either party based on personal stories and values.
  2. Public opinion matters in a democracy. Even if many people have extreme views, elections remind them that they are part of a larger society with diverse opinions.
  3. The process of voting and engaging in politics can feel fragmented and chaotic, but it reveals who will ultimately hold power, making it an interesting and important spectacle.

Indifference to Woke Isn't Enough

3950 implied HN points • 12 Nov 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political trends Party Dynamics Election Strategies Activism
  1. Democrats need to actively confront woke activists, not just ignore them, to gain people's trust on social issues. Simply being indifferent won't work.
  2. Many voters are concerned about wokeness impacting Democratic policies, especially around identity issues like sports and affirmative action. This shows that people connect these views with the party as a whole.
  3. Political parties are made up of different groups, and changing one leader's image won't change the party's values overnight. The overall coalition matters more in the long run.

Announcing: Book on Elite Human Capital

2145 implied HN points • 25 Nov 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political theory Election Analysis Human Capital Trump administration Cultural Issues
  1. The author is working on a book about Elite Human Capital, which aims to explore the differences in leadership and capabilities between groups with high and low human capital.
  2. The book will consist of both revised previous work and new content, with a focus on explaining why understanding human capital is important in today's polarized society.
  3. Current political events tie into the book's themes, highlighting how low human capital can influence leadership choices and decisions in government.

AI Progress, Racism and the Election, Trump Picks, and More

1267 implied HN points • 30 Nov 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Elections Populism Racism Cultural criticism
  1. Ecuador is facing serious gang violence that is affecting its stability. The situation is so bad that the government may need to act more like it's in wartime to regain control.
  2. Polling methods can vary in accuracy. Asking who neighbors plan to vote for might give better predictions, though it's been hit or miss in the past.
  3. Populism can have its benefits in certain situations, like in Argentina, but often it leads to anti-liberal and statist policies. It's important to see the good and the bad aspects of populism.

Time to Retire "Demographics is Destiny"

2535 implied HN points • 06 Nov 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Elections Voting Demographics Political theory Political parties
  1. People's political views often don't come from their backgrounds but from emotions and cultural connections. This means demographics alone don't predict how someone will vote.
  2. Political appeal can change over time, as seen in shifts in how different groups vote. Issues like personality and presentation can matter more than policies.
  3. Instead of focusing on demographics, it's more effective to convince influential people and share ideas. The masses are often influenced by trends and marketing rather than deep understanding.

Is Trump America-Pilling the Left?

2730 implied HN points • 03 Nov 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political strategy Election Dynamics Public Opinion
  1. Wokeness comes and goes in cycles. People and institutions eventually realize that extreme wokeness doesn’t work, leading to a decline in its popularity over time.
  2. Liberals are learning from past electoral losses and shifting their strategies. They're picking candidates who appeal to a broader base rather than sticking strictly to progressive views.
  3. Trump's actions have shifted the focus from racism to concerns about democracy. As fear of his anti-democratic tendencies grows, liberals may become more patriotic and moderate in their responses.

Why Americans Should Die for Ukraine

3876 implied HN points • 14 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political narratives Liberalism Populism Foreign Policy Social Issues
  1. People often look for simple stories in politics that have clear heroes and villains. This need for an enemy helps people feel motivated and gives their beliefs more meaning.
  2. Many popular political narratives are misleading or even completely wrong. Instead of focusing on the truth, these narratives promote false ideas that can create division and conflict.
  3. To feel fulfilled, people need meaningful narratives that often include a common enemy. Focusing on foreign threats can unify people at home and help them find purpose beyond internal conflicts.

Rightists as Low Decouplers: Examples from the Comments

3096 implied HN points • 23 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political Ideology Conservatism Democracy Online Discourse
  1. High decoupling means focusing on individual issues without being influenced by group biases. This helps in having more productive debates and understanding complex situations better.
  2. People on the right often struggle to decouple their opinions from their political identity. This makes it harder for them to acknowledge facts or engage in meaningful discussions about events like Trump's coup attempt.
  3. Conspiracy theories often go hand-in-hand with low decoupling. When people can't separate facts from their beliefs, it leads to stubbornness and a lack of productive dialogue.

Conservatives Are Lying on Immigrant Crime

3657 implied HN points • 07 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Immigration Policy Crime Rates Public Discourse Political Rhetoric Data Analysis
  1. Many people incorrectly believe that immigration leads to higher crime rates. In reality, data shows that most immigrants, especially legal ones, tend to commit less crime than native-born citizens.
  2. Some politicians use scary language about immigrants increasing crime to push their agenda. This can create a false narrative that makes the public fearful and misinformed about the actual impact of immigration.
  3. Immigrants often face more crime themselves and can actually help reduce crime rates in communities by starting businesses and contributing to the economy. So, they can serve as a buffer against crime rather than a cause of it.

The Catturd to Silicon Valley Billionaire Pipeline Must Be Broken

2218 implied HN points • 28 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political parties Elections Media influence Public Discourse Political Ideology
  1. The rise of the Tech Right was seen as a positive at first, but it has led to smart people spreading misinformation. It shows that even intelligent individuals can be misled in the wrong environment.
  2. Silicon Valley billionaires have aligned more closely with the Republican party and have become major donors. This shift has changed the political landscape in unexpected ways.
  3. It's important to understand that our surroundings greatly influence how we think. If the environment is full of false information, even rational people can fall for it.

Catholic Integralists Versus America

2608 implied HN points • 21 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political theory Nationalism Historical Analysis Cultural Identity
  1. America was founded on Enlightenment values that emphasized individual liberty and the separation of church and state, rather than being strictly a Christian nation, especially not a Catholic one.
  2. Recent Catholic nationalism contrasts sharply with historical American anti-Catholic sentiment, as many of today’s Catholic conservatives prioritize state intervention over individual freedoms.
  3. The rise of Catholic integralists in modern conservatism reflects a shift towards collectivist ideas that some believe could threaten the core values of American society.

My Highly Decoupled Election

2755 implied HN points • 18 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political Analysis Election Strategies Party Dynamics
  1. In politics, some people see their side as both morally and intellectually superior, while others recognize flaws in their own group. Those who can see both sides more realistically might have an edge in understanding what's really happening.
  2. Political ads can sometimes focus on negative stereotypes rather than real issues, showing how some campaigns manipulate fears to gain support. This reflects a deeper issue within the political messaging from both major parties.
  3. The outcome of the election may not bring significant change, as either group represents a mix of flawed people and policies. Regardless of who wins, there's an opportunity to hope that either negative behavior or bad policies won't prevail.

Do We Need Sports Betting to Get to Mars? Maybe

2340 implied HN points • 22 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Policy Debate Government Regulation Personal freedom Economic Impact Cultural values
  1. Sports betting is a hot topic right now, with some saying it harms society. But people should have the freedom to spend their money how they want, as long as they understand the risks.
  2. Banning things just because they might be bad can lead to more restrictions on our freedoms. If we start with sports betting, what's next? Watching sports?
  3. Allowing sports betting could actually help us learn more about other areas, like political betting. It's important to protect individual choices even if some people make poor decisions.

17 Thoughts on the Election

1536 implied HN points • 04 Nov 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Elections Political trends Party Dynamics Public Opinion
  1. Trump has a unique appeal that other Republicans struggle to replicate. His strong support shows he stands out in the party.
  2. Abortion might be a key issue in the election, especially for women voters. Depending on the outcome, it could change how politics handles abortion going forward.
  3. Trump may redirect blame for abortion issues to pro-life supporters if things don't go well for him, which might shift their influence in the GOP.

Are the Polls too Close to Be Trusted?

1755 implied HN points • 27 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Polling Elections Voter Behavior Political Analysis Statistical Methods
  1. Polls can often show very similar results, especially in tight races. This might indicate that pollsters are playing it safe and not reporting outlier results.
  2. There is a concern called 'herding' where polling companies avoid reporting unusual findings to not seem wrong. This can lead to less information available to the public.
  3. The lack of variation in polls today is unusual and might mean real voter sentiment is being missed, setting the stage for a surprise outcome in elections.

How Catturd Made Me a Better Person

2267 implied HN points • 16 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political Commentary Social influence Public Perception Cultural critique
  1. People can learn from both positive and negative role models. It's important to focus on the ideas of others rather than their personal traits.
  2. Our behavior can be shaped by how others behave, so it's good to admire the right people and reject the wrong ones.
  3. Having a strong value system helps us choose who to look up to and who to avoid in our lives.

Black Republicans and Big Man Syndrome

1536 implied HN points • 09 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political theory Voting Trends Party Dynamics Identity politics
  1. Some black Republicans are seen as performing for the audience, trying to challenge leftist views. Their backgrounds and statements can lead to controversy.
  2. Republicans may actively seek out black leaders to show they aren't racist, even if those candidates have questionable traits.
  3. The term 'Big Man Syndrome' describes leaders who gain power through charisma and personal control, rather than official positions. This idea comes from studying how some societies operate around influential figures.

Democrats Are Still Getting Rolled by Their Interest Groups

1462 implied HN points • 11 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Elections Political parties Political strategy Labor relations
  1. Interest groups have a strong influence on the Democratic party, often guiding their decisions and actions.
  2. Political strategies focusing on character and rhetoric might overlook the importance of representing wider coalitions.
  3. Recent labor strikes, like the one involving longshoremen, highlight the challenges Democrats face when balancing interest group demands with broader voter concerns.

On Enjoying Election Year Halloween

755 implied HN points • 31 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Elections Political Commentary Political History Political culture Public Opinion
  1. Halloween is often overlooked during election years, and it's important to still enjoy it. Taking a break from serious politics can help people relax and have fun.
  2. Political discussions can sometimes be intense and stressful, but it's good to remember that elections are just one part of the bigger picture. People should engage in debates but not take everything so seriously.
  3. There's a noticeable audience demographic that engages with politicians differently, often balancing mainstream views with personal desires. This group can significantly influence future political trends.

Safe Bets, Lotto Tickets, and Vibes

1097 implied HN points • 08 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Elections Campaigns Political Analysis Prediction Markets Betting
  1. Prediction markets help people place bets on political outcomes, including election results. It's a way to predict what might happen based on the money people are willing to gamble.
  2. There are different types of bets: safe bets on likely outcomes, long-shot bets on unlikely events, and those based on gut feelings or 'vibes.' Each type can be a strategy for making money in these markets.
  3. Overall, despite the uncertainty in politics, the belief is that democracy will continue to function and elections will still be certified. Even in the face of chaos, the systems in place are expected to hold.

Shut up About Race and IQ

5144 implied HN points • 19 Feb 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Race Ideology Policy Social Issues Political Movements
  1. Discussions about race and IQ often lead to the clash between differing ideologies, with individuals having strong motivations underlying their beliefs and interpretations.
  2. Accepting group differences doesn't rigidly determine an individual's political views; people can have diverse perspectives, even if they agree on certain facts.
  3. Implementing ideological changes in society often involves motivating individuals based on a larger vision or political agenda, rather than directly debating opposing beliefs.

America Has Black Nationalism, Not Balkanization

4023 implied HN points • 12 Mar 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Race relations Demographics Government Policy Political Ideologies
  1. American racial politics should be understood as primarily about Black Nationalism versus everyone else, rather than just whites versus minorities.
  2. The power and impact of America's assimilation capacity and focus on black issues in politics are significant and have defied demographic changes.
  3. Fighting to eliminate racial classifications and recognition for non-black minorities may be more important than battling Black Nationalism directly, as black-centered politics tend to remain irrespective of external influences.

Taylor Swift Democrats

4584 implied HN points • 30 Jan 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Party Dynamics Cultural influence
  1. Conservatives are losing appeal among wealthier and educated Americans, impacting their electoral success
  2. Taylor Swift Democrats prefer normalcy and traditional roles, not extreme ideologies
  3. The left and right have different strategies in portraying their opponents, influencing public perception

The Autism Horseshoe

4242 implied HN points • 05 Feb 24
🏥 Health & Wellness Mental health Self-Improvement Social Skills Emotional Intelligence Personal Growth
  1. Asperger's symptoms can manifest in various ways, impacting social interactions, communication, and behavior.
  2. Those with Aspie traits may have a passion for specific topics in life and exhibit emotional distance from others.
  3. Individuals on the autism spectrum can leverage their unique perspectives and interests to turn weaknesses into strengths, leading to success in different areas.

Avoiding Epistemological Nihilism

3657 implied HN points • 12 Feb 24
🔬 Science Research Data Analysis
  1. Social scientists often resort to statistical relationships when randomized experiments are not feasible, which can lead to flawed conclusions due to selection effects and confounding variables.
  2. Flawed data is often worse than having no data at all, as it can mislead individuals into making decisions based on inaccurate information.
  3. To form reasonable opinions on social, political, and economic issues, it is essential to prioritize well-grounded ideas backed by theoretical reasoning and empirical data over blindly following data from flawed social science research.

Putin as the Patron Saint of Right Wing Misanthropy

3072 implied HN points • 16 Feb 24
🌍 World Politics Russia Conservatism Democracy Foreign Policy
  1. Hatred of America in right-wing circles can sometimes reflect a deeper misanthropy that values different societal aspects than standard measurements of success.
  2. The anti-American right's hostility to democracy and liberalism can stem from a disdain for what most people desire and choose.
  3. Some in the conservative movement prioritize a pro-Putin stance over rational arguments against America's Ukraine policy, complicating efforts for peace and strategic negotiation.

Why Palestine Can't Deliver Peace

3096 implied HN points • 26 Jan 24
🌍 World Politics Middle East Conflict Peace Extremism Diplomacy
  1. Most Palestinians hold extreme views on the conflict with Israel, hindering the possibility of peace.
  2. For peace to be achievable, Palestinian society needs to be less hostile towards Jews and able to prevent extremists from derailing negotiations.
  3. Israel must be confident in the stability of a new Palestinian state and its ability to address internal opposition to ensure lasting peace.