Reports showed discrepancies between Jonathan Scott's claims and the actual evidence presented by organizations like Citizen Lab and Amnesty International.
The shutdown of Hacking Team was misrepresented in Jonathan Scott's report.
Claims made by Scott about spyware on mobile devices were deemed exaggerated.
Jonathan Scott's review of Citizen Lab's CatalanGate report raises questions about the accuracy of Citizen Lab's findings.
Scott's statements regarding his own credentials and the timeline of events in the report have been found to be misleading or false.
There are discrepancies noted in Scott's critique of Citizen Lab's methods and tools, such as the MVT-Tool and the identification of compromised indicators.
Citizen Lab's CatalanGate report stated that individuals in Spain were targeted with spyware, suspected to be connected to Spanish authorities.
José Javier Olivas-Osuna's review of the report criticized Citizen Lab's work and requested an independent investigation from the University of Toronto.
Olivas-Osuna made claims in his review that were proven false by fact-checking, such as misrepresenting the number of victims and allegations of bias in Citizen Lab's report.