A User's Guide to History

A User's Guide to History examines the interplay between history and contemporary issues, offering insights on how historical events and figures shape present viewpoints and vice versa. It explores leadership challenges, legal and political interpretations, societal changes, and the significance of acknowledging historical complexity in understanding current affairs.

Leadership and Decision-making Legal and Political Systems Societal Changes and Social Movements Historical Interpretation and Memory Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion Impeachment and Presidential Challenges Constitutional Interpretation Territorial Expansion and Conflict Election Processes and Democracy Partisanship and Political Ideologies

The hottest Substack posts of A User's Guide to History

And their main takeaways

A most fortunate defeat

334 implied HN points • 05 Feb 24
💾 History War America Canada
  1. In 1812, the United States declared war on Britain but faced opposition from various groups in Canada.
  2. The resistance from Canadian groups prevented American conquest and avoided potential political and military threats.
  3. The failed attempt at annexing Canada turned out to be a fortunate defeat for the United States, averting a possible civil war scenario.

Washington finds his calling

255 implied HN points • 10 Feb 24
💾 History Military Leaders Battles Colonialism Biography
  1. George Washington showed early signs of leadership and military skill when he led a small militia group to victory in battle.
  2. Washington had a natural inclination for soldiering, always feeling alive in moments of danger and battle.
  3. Throughout his life, Washington maintained his courage and charm even in the face of enemy fire, showing his leadership qualities and bravery.

Taking the fun out of history

353 implied HN points • 22 Jan 24
💾 History Analysis Heroes
  1. Seeking heroes in history often leads to disillusionment
  2. People are more likely to read fiction for entertainment than history
  3. Heroes in history can provide hope and a sense of closure
Get a weekly roundup of the best Substack posts, by hacker news affinity:

No country for old men?

235 implied HN points • 11 Feb 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Presidents Aging Decision-making Campaigns
  1. Presidents have strengths and weaknesses, and age can impact their performance, but wisdom often outweighs age-related challenges
  2. Health issues can affect a president's ability to govern effectively, as seen with Wilson's stroke during the ratification of the Versailles treaty
  3. Age alone should not be a disqualifying factor for a presidential candidate; what truly matters is their ability to make sound decisions

Exit gracefully

294 implied HN points • 26 Jan 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics American history
  1. As we age, our capabilities decline, and teaching others becomes valuable.
  2. Succession planning in leadership positions is crucial for long-term success.
  3. Exiting gracefully from positions of power can set a positive example for others.

Is America the greatest nation in history?

235 implied HN points • 29 Jan 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Politics History
  1. Conservatives often believe America is the greatest country because they prefer the status quo.
  2. Progressives might not think America is great due to its history of shortcomings.
  3. The question of whether America is the greatest nation is complex and comparative, emphasizing the need for both pride and improvement.

Seeking part-time heroes

294 implied HN points • 13 Jan 24
💾 History Heroes Monuments Philosophy Criticism
  1. Statues and monuments often commemorate individuals for their positive contributions to society, but can become problematic when their less-positive actions are later emphasized.
  2. Critics today expect full-time heroes on pedestals, but individuals have imperfections that may not align with this ideal.
  3. Adopting a part-time hero model like David Bowie's philosophy can help us appreciate individuals' good deeds while acknowledging their flaws, and encourage us to strive for heroism in our own lives.

Oh the equity!

294 implied HN points • 10 Jan 24
🚌 Education DEI History
  1. DEI - diversity, equity, inclusion is a battleground in public affairs.
  2. Equity has a historical foundation in English and American law.
  3. The DEI movement aims to bring about equitable outcomes amidst differing opinions.

Bring back the bosses!

255 implied HN points • 19 Jan 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Government Corruption Reform Services
  1. Politicians in the past like Plunkitt mixed philanthropy with smart politics to gain support.
  2. The approach of providing needed services in exchange for votes persisted for decades in American cities.
  3. A more practical approach to politics, focused on problem-solving and bettering lives, could be beneficial in modern public affairs.

Diss at your peril

176 implied HN points • 08 Feb 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Populism Democratic Party Working Class Presidential elections
  1. Historical populism was driven not just by economic distress but also by status anxiety and feelings of disdain from urban elites.
  2. The alienation of different demographic groups from the Democratic party led to a shift in political affiliations.
  3. Political participation is not just about policy but also about belonging and feeling respected within a party.

What's a prez to do? Polk and Mexico

275 implied HN points • 09 Jan 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics History Government Foreign Relations Military
  1. James Polk was a president focused on territorial expansion and was successful in acquiring Texas and Oregon from Mexico.
  2. Polk used strategic military maneuvers to provoke Mexico into a war, ultimately leading to the acquisition of California and New Mexico.
  3. The Mexican-American War, despite facing criticism for its motives, resulted in significant territorial gains for the United States.

Nevermore

255 implied HN points • 08 Jan 24
📚 Literature Biography Legacy Literary Criticism Short Stories Poetry
  1. Edgar Allan Poe faced many struggles in his life but his writing talent shined through.
  2. The mysterious circumstances of Poe's death added to his dark and macabre reputation.
  3. Despite attempts to tarnish Poe's legacy, his work continues to be celebrated while his detractors are forgotten.

Imperial shuffle

216 implied HN points • 11 Jan 24
💾 History American Revolution Migration Colonization Slavery Wars
  1. Historians of Canada include American Loyalists in their story, as it significantly impacted the country's history
  2. Resettling American Loyalists in Canada doubled the country's population and altered the balance of French and British influence
  3. Black Loyalists faced challenges in Canada, leading to tensions and eventual migration to other regions like Sierra Leone and the British West Indies

What’s a prez to do? Taylor and third-partyism

196 implied HN points • 12 Jan 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Election Presidency
  1. In the 1848 election, James Polk's pledge not to run led to a complicated decision for the country.
  2. The emergence of third parties, like the Free Soil party, has impacted American presidential history.
  3. Zachary Taylor's lack of political baggage helped him benefit from the rift among the Democrats and win the presidency.