The hottest Political History Substack posts right now

And their main takeaways
Category
Top U.S. Politics Topics

In a Perfect World, Powell Would Not Be Fed Chairman and Trump Would Be President

Peter Navarro's Taking Back Trump's America • 2397 implied HN points • 08 Mar 23
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political History
  1. In a perfect world, Peter Navarro believes Jerome Powell wouldn't be the Fed Chairman and Trump would still be the President.
  2. Navarro discusses how Mnuchin convinced Trump to appoint Powell, who in turn negatively impacted the economy.
  3. Navarro criticizes Powell's policies and highlights the challenges of dealing with stagflation and the Federal Reserve's limitations.

February 21, 2026

Letters from an American • 25 implied HN points • 22 Feb 26
💾 History Political History
  1. Republicans rushed to admit western territories as new states to gain senators and Electoral College votes, splitting territories and fast-tracking statehood to tilt national power in their favor.
  2. That strategy didn’t secure long-term control because economic troubles, unpopular tariff policies, and scandals helped Democrats and Populists win big gains in the 1890 midterms and elect Grover Cleveland in 1892.
  3. Critics argued these actions distorted democratic representation—tiny new states got outsized Senate power, and officials sometimes manipulated votes and the census for partisan advantage.

I Can’t Believe Calling Him Hitler Didn’t Work

Rob Henderson's Newsletter • 4091 implied HN points • 06 Nov 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political History
  1. People are surprised that calling someone 'Hitler' doesn't always change opinions. This shows that extreme labeling may not impact how others vote or think.
  2. Some fear that Americans might elect a controversial or criminal figure as president. This reflects concerns about the current political climate and choices.
  3. The situation highlights a deeper debate about political tactics and their effectiveness. Some tactics may backfire or become less relatable in real-life decision-making.

MLK Jr. and Hegel; Tooze Agonistes; America's ‘Homeland Empire’

Unpopular Front • 74 implied HN points • 18 Jan 26
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political History
  1. Martin Luther King Jr. drew on Hegel’s master–slave dialectic to shape his idea of nonviolent resistance: it’s a willing risk of life that asserts dignity without trying to dominate others. Nonviolence aims for a synthesis that overcomes humiliation and creates mutual recognition rather than coerced submission.
  2. Historian Adam Tooze’s deep empiricism and skepticism make him reluctant to call contemporary figures “fascist,” preferring detailed distinctions and historical caution. That caution can become a blind spot when patterns of authoritarianism are emerging.
  3. The fascism analogy, while contested, has been a useful and predictive framework for some observers who warned about escalations like January 6. Treating the analogy as a working research program helps identify and anticipate authoritarian tendencies before they fully consolidate.

February 14, 2026

Letters from an American • 32 implied HN points • 15 Feb 26
💾 History Political History
  1. On February 14, 1884 he lost both his wife and his mother within hours and marked the day with a heavy black X in his diary.
  2. Both deaths were tied to diseases caused by city filth and crowding—like typhoid and infections—showing how poor sanitation and crowded tenements endangered people's lives.
  3. Devastated, he went to a Dakota ranch and remade himself as a rugged cowboy, gaining new political credibility. He then returned to politics, rose to the presidency, and pushed urban sanitation and labor reforms as part of the Progressive agenda.
Get a weekly roundup of the best Substack posts, by hacker news affinity:

The AI Story Will Roll On in Trump’s Second Term

Big Technology • 3502 implied HN points • 08 Nov 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political History
  1. AI technology is becoming increasingly important and cannot be overlooked, especially with key figures in tech having connections to the political landscape. This means the AI story will remain a big topic as politics unfold.
  2. Trump's new presidency will likely influence AI regulations and policies, particularly around open-source AI and tariffs. This could impact major tech companies and their strategies moving forward.
  3. The evolution of generative AI has just begun, and it's becoming crucial for businesses. However, many AI startups are still struggling financially, which could shape the future of the industry.

How Australia excised its British soul

Kvetch • 53 implied HN points • 01 Feb 26
💾 History Political History
  1. For over a century many Australians thought of themselves as essentially British and kept hoping Britain would look out for them, even after repeated disappointments.
  2. Britain’s turn to Europe in 1973 broke the idea of a shared imperial future and forced Australia to rethink its identity, leading to moves like a distinct citizenship and a new national anthem.
  3. When Australians chose 'Advance Australia Fair' in 1977 they picked a song rooted in British-flavoured patriotism but cut the stanza about a 'British soul', signaling a tendency to downplay or hide that inherited identity while still struggling to find a clear replacement.

The Donald Trumped

Diane Francis • 839 implied HN points • 22 Feb 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political History
  1. Donald Trump was ordered to pay $355 million for lying to financial institutions, highlighting that even powerful people can face consequences for their actions.
  2. New York's strict financial laws help maintain its reputation as a leading financial center, protecting investors from fraud.
  3. Trump compared his legal troubles to the struggles faced by political prisoners, while there are concerns he may be under foreign influence regarding his debts.

Radicals Have Burned California Before

Common Sense with Bari Weiss • 2327 implied HN points • 05 Feb 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political History
  1. California's progressive policies have often led to unintended disasters, like wildfires. Good intentions don't always result in good outcomes.
  2. Environmental activism can sometimes slow down crucial safety projects. In this case, protecting a rare plant delayed fire safety improvements.
  3. The struggle between environmental concerns and safety measures is an ongoing issue. It's important to find a balance to prevent disasters while protecting nature.

After the Last David Graeber Post; or, Once Again Unto the Breach...

Brad DeLong's Grasping Reality • 184 implied HN points • 09 Dec 25
💾 History Political History
  1. Big, sweeping historical stories or speculative nonfiction that aren’t firmly grounded in facts can mislead readers and create attractive but unstable arguments.
  2. Ideas matter but don’t determine outcomes by themselves; material forces like production, distribution, coercion, and communication set the boundaries within which ideas compete.
  3. Careful, evidence-based and materialist thinking is needed to draw lessons from history, because isolated counterexamples or imaginative reconstructions don’t overturn broad patterns shaped by long-term constraints.

To J.D. Vance, His Family, & His Staff, Hannukah Is a Subset of Christmas

Brad DeLong's Grasping Reality • 184 implied HN points • 06 Dec 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political History
  1. Some political leaders treat Hanukkah as a subset of Christmas and promote a public identity centered on Christianity rather than equal recognition of Jewish traditions.
  2. U.S. civil religion has long swung between broader "Abrahamic" or "Judeo-Christian" frames, and some actors are now trying to narrow it further toward ethnic or Christian nationalism.
  3. A more inclusive civic celebration would recognize many winter festivals from different cultures instead of reducing diverse traditions to a single Christian narrative.

No Kings

Points And Figures • 1065 implied HN points • 16 Jun 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political History
  1. Fringe Democrats showed anger on Flag Day instead of celebrating the Army's anniversary and the American value of having no kings. Celebrating independence is a big deal in July, but they missed the point.
  2. There are long-serving politicians in both parties, but more in the Democratic party. If people want no kings, they should support term limits and new blood in politics.
  3. Legacy politicians, like those whose families have held power for generations, look a lot like royalty. It's worth questioning why this continues in a democracy.

February 9, 2026

Letters from an American • 33 implied HN points • 10 Feb 26
💾 History Political History
  1. Bad Bunny’s Super Bowl halftime show drew record viewers and used Puerto Rican symbols and history to push back at critics who said he isn’t American, framing Puerto Ricans and Latin America as part of 'America.'
  2. Puerto Rico’s unequal relationship with the United States was shaped by late‑19th‑century economic interests—especially the sugar industry—and by racial politics after the Spanish‑American War.
  3. Legal decisions created a long political limbo: early rulings made Puerto Ricans 'noncitizen nationals' and citizenship came in 1917, but residents still cannot vote for president from the island and have only limited congressional representation.

Alexei Navalny RIP

Castalia • 759 implied HN points • 18 Feb 24
🌍 World Politics Political History
  1. Alexei Navalny was a brave opposition leader in Russia who stood up against Putin's regime. Despite facing imprisonment and even being poisoned, he returned to Russia to show his strength and courage.
  2. He represented a connection to a time of hope in the 1990s when many Russians wanted change. His death marks a significant point in the decline of political dissent in Russia.
  3. Navalny believed in the power of truth and courage over fear. He thought that standing up for what is right was worth the risk, even if it seemed like nothing would change.

Best of The Free Press: Don’t Lie

Common Sense with Bari Weiss • 2448 implied HN points • 24 Dec 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political History
  1. Honesty is crucial in journalism, and it helps build trust. People prefer straightforward reporting over being misled or given spin.
  2. There has been a dangerous trend where some journalists prioritize their agendas over truth. This shift has hurt the credibility of the media.
  3. Understanding and sticking to the truth matters now more than ever. Good journalism can counteract the lies and misinformation that spread in society.

Revolution in Iran : Now and Then

Comment is Freed • 78 implied HN points • 16 Jan 26
🌍 World Politics Political History
  1. Mass protests in Iran mirror the 1979 revolution, with widespread anger at a repressive, corrupt leadership and calls for the clerical rulers to step down.
  2. The current regime is more determined and willing to use violent repression than the Shah’s was, so the outcome of the uprising is uncertain and expectations should be cautious.
  3. Economic chaos and mismanagement are a key vulnerability for the regime that could make it more fragile despite its greater repressive capacity.

The New Vertigo Years

Novum Newsletter • 983 implied HN points • 23 Jun 25
💾 History Political History
  1. The early 20th century felt a lot like today, full of anxiety from rapid changes in society and technology. People were unsure about the future and how to adapt to modern life.
  2. Many in both past and present times struggled with feelings of exhaustion and a fragmented sense of self, leading to mental health issues. In both eras, people looked for new ways to start over as they faced overwhelming changes.
  3. Information overload has been a common challenge, then and now, where rapid access to news can cause confusion and anxiety. The rise of mass media in the past parallels today’s digital information explosion, both stirring public emotions and sometimes spreading falsehoods.

February 8, 2026

Letters from an American • 30 implied HN points • 09 Feb 26
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political History
  1. McCarthy and others used fear, loud accusations, and selective leaks to grab headlines and gain political power, staying ahead of fact‑checking until the public finally turned against them.
  2. The belief that elites or outsiders are destroying the nation evolved into the Great Replacement idea, rooted in older racist and eugenic thought and fueling white‑supremacist movements and violence.
  3. Recent political leaders and advisers have revived and weaponized anti‑immigrant and racist narratives to block compromise and push exclusionary policies, repeating tactics that trade truth for power.

Why did White Australia end?

Kvetch • 55 implied HN points • 17 Jan 26
💾 History Political History
  1. White Australia was a foundational, widely supported policy aimed at preserving a predominantly British, racially homogeneous nation. Political leaders defended it as essential to national character and self‑preservation.
  2. The policy was dismantled gradually and somewhat muddled from the postwar period into the late 1960s, driven by decolonisation, international pressure, growing ties with Asia, and changing Western (especially American) racial norms. Reforms opened the door to more non‑European immigration even as governments insisted newcomers must assimilate and that a multiracial society was not the goal.
  3. Ending White Australia left an identity gap that successive leaders struggled to fill coherently; efforts to pivot toward Asia and promote language study didn’t produce a clear new national story, and other identity currents—like increased focus on Indigenous identity—grew to occupy that space.

After Assad

Common Sense with Bari Weiss • 1984 implied HN points • 09 Dec 24
🌍 World Politics Political History
  1. Bashar al-Assad has fled Syria, marking a significant change in the Middle East. This could reshape alliances and power dynamics in the region.
  2. There's excitement about the potential for change, with people celebrating in the streets. Yet, there are concerns that the future may bring harsh rule or further conflict instead of a peaceful democracy.
  3. Western countries are preparing for various outcomes in Syria, including military actions to counter any threats that arise after Assad's departure.

Eternal 1942

Castalia • 479 implied HN points • 05 Mar 24
💾 History Political History
  1. The research and writing process can feel like stepping into another time, as the author immersed himself in 1942 to better understand that historical period. This experience helped him connect with his characters and the events they were navigating.
  2. In 1942, many believed that fascism showed efficiency and strength compared to liberal democracies, but by the end of the year, perspectives shifted as victories by the Allies began to change the tide of World War II.
  3. The legacy of understanding Nazism as a unique evil has shaped modern politics, leading to a focus on identifying and combatting extremism, something that continues to influence current political discussions.

Book Review: 22 Cells In Nuremberg A Psychiatrist Examines the Nazi Criminals

Who is Robert Malone • 12 implied HN points • 23 Feb 26
💾 History Political History
  1. Ordinary people with ambition, weak morals, and a willingness to exploit fear can commit mass crimes when conditions let them; atrocities don’t require monstrous psychopathy.
  2. Authoritarian politics work by stirring emotion, manufacturing enemies, and shutting down critical thought, and those tactics can appear in any democracy, especially during crises.
  3. Preventing authoritarianism depends on strong civic habits: broad voting access and participation, resisting divisive demagogues, robust institutions, and education that promotes critical thinking.

Jimmy Carter, President and Citizen.

Breaking the News • 1603 implied HN points • 31 Dec 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political History
  1. Jimmy Carter was very skilled at connecting with people from all walks of life. His ability to communicate and listen helped him build strong relationships during his presidency.
  2. Carter's foreign policy achievements are often seen in a better light than they originally appeared. He made significant contributions, even if they weren't always recognized at the time.
  3. The importance of storytelling in politics is crucial. Like Jimmy Carter, sharing our experiences and truths helps unite people and address common concerns for a better future.

February 4, 2026

Letters from an American • 27 implied HN points • 05 Feb 26
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political History
  1. Prominent GOP leaders are pushing claims that undocumented immigrants are stealing elections and calling for federal control of voting, despite decades of investigations showing virtually no evidence of widespread noncitizen voting.
  2. Declaring opponents’ votes illegitimate and threatening to override results is not new — it echoes a long history of white supremacist and anti‑democratic tactics used to suppress and overturn elections.
  3. A recent Democratic upset in a Texas state senate district, driven by Latino and suburban voters, suggests GOP assumptions about voter loyalties and the durability of gerrymanders are weakening ahead of 2026.

Trump’s Populism Isn’t a Sideshow. It’s as American as Apple Pie.

Common Sense with Bari Weiss • 1395 implied HN points • 22 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political History
  1. Populism is a strong feeling in America that often pits ordinary people against the powerful elite. It's more about emotions and attitudes than strict political plans.
  2. Trump's approach to politics echoes past leaders like Andrew Jackson, who also promised to challenge the established order and 'drain the swamp.' This shows how deeply rooted populism is in American history.
  3. Populism can lead to big changes in government, where people express their frustration with the ruling class and demand action. It can shake things up and even remove those in power.

TLP's 2024 Swing-State Project: Pennsylvania (Part One)

The Liberal Patriot • 589 implied HN points • 21 Jan 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political History
  1. Pennsylvania is a crucial swing state that has been competitive in recent elections, with voter preferences changing over time.
  2. The state's demographic diversity and political landscape make it a microcosm of the country, with key areas like Philadelphia suburbs playing a significant role in elections.
  3. Voter registration trends show a narrowing gap between Democrats and Republicans in Pennsylvania, with party affiliations shifting in recent years.

(Largely) HOISTED FROM THE ARCHIVES: “West”, “North Atlantic”, or “Dover Circle”?

Brad DeLong's Grasping Reality • 61 implied HN points • 03 Jan 26
💾 History Political History
  1. Labels like “the West” or “Global North” are too vague, and a more useful term is “Dover Circle‑Plus” — the set of societies in, settled from, or that copied the economic and institutional model that emerged after 1500 around the Dover area of England.
  2. That model depended on specific institutional and social features — church rules that broadened trust, legal systems that bound rulers, competitive proto‑nation states, self‑governing cities that empowered merchants, and fragmented elites — which together created social flexibility and room for experimentation and growth.
  3. Telling history as a continuous ‘Western Civilization’ torch is misleading: the Dover Circle’s rise was gradual and contingent, not an ancient unbroken lineage, and its global dominance was secured only over centuries through both hard power and cultural influence.

Clapping for Stalin

The Watch • 1298 implied HN points • 20 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political History
  1. People often feel pressured to show support, even if they don't really believe in it. This can lead to a situation where everyone claps just to fit in.
  2. Some individuals may hesitate to stop applauding because of fear of consequences, showing how group dynamics can create a sense of obligation.
  3. In extreme situations, a single person's choice can change the entire group’s behavior, like stopping applause, which can reveal who is truly independent and who is not.

A Brief History of the Global Economy: 1908–2026

European Straits • 25 implied HN points • 26 Jan 26
💾 History Political History
  1. Technological revolutions reshape how goods are made and how economies grow. The shift to oil, automobiles, and mass production—centered on Ford-style assembly lines—gave the US industrial dominance and sustained productivity gains.
  2. After WWII the US built a new international economic order using Bretton Woods, the dollar, the IMF, and the Marshall Plan to stabilize currencies, rebuild allies, and anchor global trade. This American-led framework helped spread the mass-production model across Western Europe and Japan.
  3. A postwar compact between big firms, organized labor, and governments fueled a ‘Golden Age’ of rising productivity, higher wages, and broad middle-class growth. The 1971 Nixon Shock ended the dollar–gold peg and moved the world toward a fiat dollar system that enabled the rise of global value chains.

The Engineer-Dictator Temptation: Lawrence Dennis, the Great Depression, & the Fascist Road Not Taken

Brad DeLong's Grasping Reality • 422 implied HN points • 30 Jul 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political History
  1. Lawrence Dennis believed that during the Great Depression, liberal capitalism was failing and suggested a need for a strong, centralized government to maintain order. He thought only authoritarian solutions could address economic chaos effectively.
  2. Dennis warned that without meaningful reform, America might face either fascism, communism, or chaos. His views reflected fears held by many during that time about the future of democracy.
  3. He predicted that if elites didn't adapt to the changing economic landscape, a violent upheaval could occur. Dennis saw the rise of strong leaders as a potential solution to guide the country through crisis.

From Yan'an to Mar-a-Lago

ChinaTalk • 652 implied HN points • 27 May 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political History
  1. Mao Zedong and Donald Trump share some psychological traits, especially when it comes to their relationships with their fathers, which influenced their leadership styles. Both faced difficult upbringings, with adversarial relationships shaping who they became.
  2. Both leaders have used chaos as a means to consolidate power. Mao's Cultural Revolution and Trump's actions against the government bureaucracy show a similar desire to disrupt established systems they see as threats.
  3. The trauma from Mao's era still affects Chinese society today, reflecting how historical traumas can linger across generations. This concept of inherited trauma can also be observed in how political dynamics play out in current leadership styles.

Links for November

By Reason Alone • 114 implied HN points • 30 Nov 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political History
  1. Hosting a public conversation about science funding and peer review can open up important discussions about how science is evaluated and funded. It's a chance to explore the role of philanthropy in the scientific landscape.
  2. Encouraging a culture of giving through student donation matching can help support effective charities like the Against Malaria Foundation. This initiative could inspire similar efforts in other countries.
  3. Working as a researcher in a library can significantly enhance productivity compared to traditional open-plan offices. A shorter commute and quiet study environments can lead to better focus and more accomplishments.

January 23, 2026

Letters from an American • 33 implied HN points • 24 Jan 26
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political History
  1. Tens of thousands protested the federal occupation of Minneapolis–St. Paul, saying ICE and CBP actions are trampling constitutional rights like free speech, equal protection, and protection from unreasonable searches.
  2. The administration is using visa revocations, secret memos authorizing warrantless home entries, and an expanded 'domestic terrorism' label to silence and criminalize dissent.
  3. This push is part of a broader effort to redefine America around racialized 'blood-and-soil' ideas, while many point to the Founders and Lincoln to argue that defending equality and the rule of law is the true conservative stance.

Top Links 809 About that dam in Tibet. Supermarketisation. The history of political arithmetic & China's "Five Major Homes".

Chartbook • 400 implied HN points • 24 Jul 25
🌍 World Politics Political History
  1. The post discusses a dam in Tibet, highlighting its significance and impact. It's an interesting look at how such projects can shape regions and communities.
  2. It mentions supermarketisation, which refers to the trend of making goods and services more widely available and accessible. This can change how people shop and interact with local businesses.
  3. The history of political arithmetic in China and its concept of 'Five Major Homes' is explored. This can help us understand China's governance and economic strategies better.

The Monarch of Mar-a-Lago

Common Sense with Bari Weiss • 1112 implied HN points • 08 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political History
  1. Trump's power peaks before he takes office, showing how the moment of being sworn in changes the dynamics of his influence.
  2. The story of Rip Van Winkle highlights how dramatic changes can occur in society, even in just a couple of decades.
  3. Modern political identities can be confusing and overwhelming, as seen in Rip's struggle to understand new party affiliations.

Xi Zhongxun: China Book of the Year

ChinaTalk • 459 implied HN points • 22 Jun 25
🌍 World Politics Political History
  1. Xi Zhongxun's life shows how suffering can lead to a strong commitment to a cause. For him, the struggles he faced made him passionate about communism and the Party.
  2. The book highlights that Xi Zhongxun was more complex than just a 'reformer.' He had conflicting views about individualism and Party demands, and his actions were sometimes driven by what the Party needed.
  3. It’s important to recognize that labels like 'good' and 'bad' don’t always fit. Xi Zhongxun's story reminds us that everyone in the Party had moments of both virtue and wrongdoing.

Chartbook 328 An economics Nobel for Biden's neocon moment. On AJR's "Whig" philosophy of history.

Chartbook • 1473 implied HN points • 19 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political History
  1. The recent Nobel Prize in economics was awarded to three economists who stressed the importance of societal institutions in achieving economic prosperity. Their work highlights how fairness and rights can drive economic growth.
  2. The Biden administration supports this view, aligning their economic strategies with the theories of these Nobel winners. They believe government policies can help bridge gaps like inequality and support innovation.
  3. The traditional ideas of free-market economics are becoming less popular, and the current trend leans towards more government intervention in the economy. This shift reflects a broader skepticism about past economic policies.

January 9, 2026

Letters from an American • 43 implied HN points • 10 Jan 26
💾 History Political History
  1. Fascism is rule by a small elite that seizes control of political, economic, social, and cultural life, suppresses civil liberties, and uses force, racism, and warlike propaganda to stay in power.
  2. Fascists rise by dividing people through hate campaigns, pitting religious, racial, and economic groups against one another, promoting extreme nationalism, and labeling opponents as enemies while dressing their message in patriotic language.
  3. Preventing fascism means being alert and active in defending democracy: protect everyone's rights, fight indifference and ignorance, make democratic institutions work, and support international cooperation.

Does Politics Turn on a Message? Or a Messenger?

Breaking the News • 1013 implied HN points • 11 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political History
  1. Jimmy Carter once seemed fresh and vibrant to voters, but many today only see him as an elder statesman. It's a reminder of his early energy when he first became president.
  2. There are challenges for the Democrats in expanding their base and rethinking their policies. Ideas are already being discussed to help working-class people and strengthen the party.
  3. An important point is that mere policy might not be enough for the Democrats. They may need to consider a broader approach to connect with voters effectively.

My Social Journey Toward the Right

In My Tribe • 1245 implied HN points • 15 Nov 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political History
  1. Beliefs are influenced by the people we trust. For example, trusting certain professors or colleagues can shape your view on politics.
  2. Life experiences, like working in different environments, can also change your political stance. Being around business-minded people can lead you to adopt more right-leaning views.
  3. Understanding complex issues, such as economics and evolution, can lead to a more nuanced perspective on human behavior and society, making one appreciate different political ideologies.