The hottest Justice Substack posts right now

And their main takeaways
Category
Top U.S. Politics Topics

Suiting up, making the case, and guess who’s coming to dinner

The Pillar • 805 implied HN points • 29 Sep 23
⛪ Faith & Spirituality Church Events Justice History
  1. Pope Francis is creating new cardinals in a consistory this weekend, and it's a tradition full of pomp and pageantry in Rome.
  2. Wearing fancy uniforms and titles like 'cardinal' signify belonging to a greater purpose and celebration of collective work.
  3. The Pontifical Commission for the Protection of Minors is urging Church leaders to prioritize reforms for abuse survivors during upcoming events like the Synod of Bishops.

Canadian Patriot Podcast with Randy Hillier: The Un-constitutionality of Emergencies Act

Matt Ehret's Insights • 412 implied HN points • 30 Jan 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Law Government Justice Freedom Activism
  1. Former MP Randy Hillier discusses the unconstitutionality of the Emergencies Act in a recent Canadian Patriot Podcast.
  2. The Federal Court ruling on Jan 26 declared the Trudeau-Freeland Emergencies Act as unconstitutional, impacting Canadians and sparking discussions on a COVID crimes inquiry.
  3. Resources provided for becoming an informed organizer on related topics like history, documentaries, and critical analysis.
Get a weekly roundup of the best Substack posts, by hacker news affinity:

Perverted Incentives

Holly’s Newsletter • 1587 implied HN points • 16 Apr 23
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Justice Crime Law Children Abuse
  1. Proposed Florida law for death penalty for child sex crimes may have unintended consequences like removing incentives for perpetrators to keep victims alive.
  2. Trauma reactions to child sexual abuse are complex and reporting may be deterred due to consequences for families and communities.
  3. Suggests life without parole as fitting punishment for these crimes, highlighting the need to consider the complexity and unintended outcomes of changing laws around child sexual abuse.

January 10, 2025

Letters from an American • 17 implied HN points • 11 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Elections Legislation Policy Economy Justice
  1. Under Biden, the U.S. economy created 16.6 million jobs and had the lowest unemployment rate in 50 years. It shows the economy bounced back better than expected after the pandemic.
  2. Trump continues to spread false claims about Democrats and various issues, and his supporters rally around these narratives. This makes it hard for them to accept reality.
  3. Biden's administration is actively looking out for immigrants and combating climate change, while Trump proposes controversial actions that many Americans may not support.

Sororal Treachery

Disaffected Newsletter • 759 implied HN points • 10 Sep 23
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Feminism Child abuse Education Justice Social Issues
  1. A mommy vlogger was arrested for serious child abuse after her son sought help from a neighbor. This shows that sometimes people appear perfect online but may hide troubling realities.
  2. Some feminists are criticizing a sorority for accepting a transgender woman as a member, claiming it's a betrayal to women. This highlights ongoing debates about gender identity and women's rights.
  3. Important issues like car theft, children's education, and legal actions against popular figures are currently being discussed in society. These examples show the complexity of legal and social justice in our communities.

The Justice of Bukele?

Bet On It • 674 implied HN points • 12 Feb 24
🌍 World Politics Law Justice Authoritarianism Human Rights Corruption
  1. Nayib Bukele's policies in El Salvador have significantly reduced the murder rate, but come at a cost of widespread jailing and lack of fair trials.
  2. The debate on Bukele's justice system involves utilitarian calculations which weigh saving lives against infringing on rights, highlighting moral pluralism.
  3. The emphasis on the importance of trials in a justice system is viewed primarily from an epistemic standpoint, weighing the trade-offs of accuracy and potential errors.

He Hunted al-Qaeda. Now He Hunts Neo-Nazis

Common Sense with Bari Weiss • 626 implied HN points • 28 Feb 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Extremism Security Military Terrorism Justice
  1. Kristofer Goldsmith founded Task Force Butler to combat neo-Nazi terrorism in the US, facing credible threats and dangerous situations as a former Army sergeant.
  2. Task Force Butler infiltrates and monitors online Nazi groups, providing legal evidence that has led to convictions and lawsuits against extremist organizations.
  3. Goldsmith's personal journey, from Army veteran suffering from undiagnosed PTSD to leading an effort to dismantle white supremacist groups, highlights his resilience and dedication to fighting against hate.

Trump's Indictment is Good for America

OLD GOATS with Jonathan Alter • 550 implied HN points • 01 Apr 23
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Corruption Justice Elections Racism Constitution
  1. Trump's indictment is seen as beneficial for American democracy to hold corrupt politicians accountable.
  2. The size of Trump's support may be overestimated, as his fundraising is comparatively low for politics.
  3. The efforts to prosecute Trump are necessary to prevent presidents from being above the law, even if he is acquitted in the end.

Reflections on AHM v. FDA

Adam's Legal Newsletter • 679 implied HN points • 22 Apr 23
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Legal Judiciary Government Justice Policy
  1. The Supreme Court's order in AHM v. FDA indicates the FDA will likely prevail; legal arguments have been thoroughly aired and further briefing is not expected to change the outcome.
  2. The litigation in AHM v. FDA will continue, with the Fifth Circuit hearing oral arguments next; the Supreme Court may reverse a Fifth Circuit decision if needed.
  3. Proposals to prevent similar situations include eliminating single-judge divisions to avoid forum shopping and improve the administration of justice without needing broader, unwarranted changes.

Sitting In at The Daniel Penny Trial

Autonomy • 23 implied HN points • 23 Dec 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Law Justice Trials Legal system
  1. In a courtroom, both sides work hard to present their case, highlighting the competition between the defense and prosecution. This can lead to intense moments where one side tries to catch the other off guard.
  2. Even judges are part of this competitive environment. They have to be careful with their instructions because any mistakes can lead to major troubles, like a mistrial.
  3. Competition is everywhere in life, not just in courts. It drives us to improve and set higher standards for ourselves, like how we strive to play music better by observing professionals.

Essay Club: The Humanitarian Theory of Punishment by C. S. Lewis

Mind & Mythos • 339 implied HN points • 02 Dec 23
📖 Philosophy Ethics Justice Humanism Legal theory Literary Criticism
  1. C. S. Lewis argues that punishment should be based on what a person deserves, rather than just trying to deter others or cure the criminal. This is important for justice to exist.
  2. When punishment is only about deterrence or cure, it can lead to abusing people as mere tools for society's goals, rather than treating them as individuals with rights.
  3. Lewis warns that a system focused just on helping or fixing people can end up being very oppressive, especially if those in power ignore the concept of what someone deserves for their actions.

Thinking Harder About Justice: Rawls vs. Cohen vs. Marx (UNLOCKED)

Philosophy for the People w/Ben Burgis • 758 implied HN points • 08 Jan 23
📖 Philosophy Political Philosophy Socialism Marxism Justice Inequality
  1. Marxist philosopher G.A. Cohen criticizes John Rawls's theory of justice from the left
  2. Cohen's idea of 'socialist equality of opportunity' aims to correct inequalities linked to factors beyond an individual's control
  3. Rawls and Cohen may be in a semantic dispute about the term 'justice', but both their perspectives are important in highlighting existing injustices and guiding future progress

What We Talk About When We Talk About Inequality

Philosophy for the People w/Ben Burgis • 339 implied HN points • 14 May 23
📖 Philosophy Equality Socialism Justice
  1. The post discusses G.A. Cohen's luck egalitarianism, a dialogue with socialist philosopher Christine Sypnowich, and the focus of egalitarians on what to equalize.
  2. A forum in _Boston Review_ titled "Is Equal Opportunity Enough?" features a discussion on justice led by Christine Sypnowich.
  3. The post is for paid subscribers only, prompting a subscription to access the content.

Imprisoning innocent people is bad

Adam's Legal Newsletter • 319 implied HN points • 02 Jul 23
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Policy Justice Legislation Reform Courts
  1. Imprisoning innocent people is bad. It's crucial to ensure that those who were wrongfully convicted are not kept in prison.
  2. The rules on post-conviction challenges for prisoners need to be fixed. The current system can prevent innocent prisoners from proving their innocence.
  3. Congress should amend Section 2255 to allow prisoners to bring successive challenges when new Supreme Court decisions establish their innocence. This fix is important to rectify an unfair system.

The Facts, the Law, and Lincoln

steveinskeep • 294 implied HN points • 29 Jun 23
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Justice Discrimination Equality Race Constitution
  1. Supreme Court opinions can have sharp exchanges, with justices revising and sharpening their arguments while responding to each other.
  2. Justice Thomas argues against considering race in admissions, emphasizing the importance of individual evaluation and the equal treatment mandated by the Fourteenth Amendment.
  3. Justice Jackson, on the other hand, focuses on historical racial disparities and advocates for holistic admissions programs that address inequality and consider race along with other aspects of identity.

How Much of a Courtier Is Walter Isaacson Þese Days?

Brad DeLong's Grasping Reality • 507 implied HN points • 04 Sep 23
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Authors Media Ethics Analysis Justice
  1. Reading journalism written by a courtier can be frustrating because the true meaning might not be clear.
  2. It's important to critically analyze claims and information presented in articles, especially those involving high-profile figures.
  3. Having more background knowledge can help in decoding underlying messages in journalistic pieces.

Embodying the Good

Humanities in Revolt • 219 implied HN points • 21 Jun 23
📖 Philosophy Meaning of life Ethics Human Values Justice Existentialism
  1. The peace movement highlighted the importance of embodying intrinsic values, such as truth, justice, autonomy, and integrity, above achieving immediate results.
  2. Recognizing and enacting self-justifying values allows us to find meaning and purpose in the face of life's futility.
  3. Activists in the peace movement worked to promote human dignity, freedom, and justice, rejecting defeatism and continuing to embody their principles despite facing challenges and setbacks.

On Justices

Doc Hammer's Anvil • 216 implied HN points • 09 Mar 23
📖 Philosophy Justice Virtue Ethics Moral Philosophy Social Interaction
  1. Many fundamental moral and philosophical concepts have been lost in modern times, requiring a rediscovery and clarification of ideas.
  2. Justice is a crucial virtue that allows for moral compulsion through force, and it is important to differentiate between Commutative Justice (CJ) and Distributive Justice (DJ).
  3. Commutative Justice (CJ) involves actions that can be enforced through coercion without violating the perception of justice in the eyes of others, while Distributive Justice (DJ) focuses on the becoming use of what is our own and involves a constant debate on what is considered good.

How to Be a Leftist Without Being a Utilitarian or a Free Will Skeptic (UNLOCKED)

Philosophy for the People w/Ben Burgis • 259 implied HN points • 02 Apr 23
📖 Philosophy Ethics Free will Justice Meritocracy Utilitarianism
  1. Rejecting free will or embracing utilitarianism is like burning down your house to kill a fly.
  2. Meritocracy doesn't justify extreme inequality; our society isn't a true meritocracy.
  3. Belief in moral rights maintains dignity and autonomy and challenges market-worshippers for a fairer society.

Supervisor Hillary Ronen asked a judge to release Mission gang member from probation

Gotham by Susan Dyer Reynolds • 196 implied HN points • 01 Mar 23
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Law Crime Government Activism Justice
  1. Supervisor Hillary Ronen tried to help a gang member get off probation despite knowing his criminal activities.
  2. Fernando Madrigal, a youth activist turned gang member, was involved in a murder case and pleaded guilty to racketeering.
  3. Ronen's actions raise questions about ethics and her support of Madrigal, who was connected to violent crimes.

Some Notes on Political Apology

Going Awol • 119 implied HN points • 06 Jan 24
📖 Philosophy Ethics Apology Responsibility Morality Justice
  1. Voters often demand political apologies but don't always accept them, leading to a paradox. Despite this, there are valid reasons for demanding apologies even when acceptance is unlikely.
  2. Conditional apologies, though controversial, can still be considered genuine apologies as they reflect an acceptance of facts, remorse, a desire for improvement, and a commitment to change.
  3. Politicians sometimes apologize for historical events they weren't personally involved in to acknowledge narrative connections and prevent the risk of causing expressive harm by remaining silent.

Tim Pool, Sam Seder, and Thanos: Is Lesser-Evil Voting Like Pushing People Onto Trolley Tracks? (UNLOCKED)

Philosophy for the People w/Ben Burgis • 239 implied HN points • 26 Mar 23
📖 Philosophy Ethics Consequentialism Free will Justice
  1. Tim Pool's comparison of lesser-evil voting to the Trolley Problem and Thanos lacked depth and accuracy in understanding consequentialism and deontology.
  2. It's important to consider moral complexities beyond simple consequentialism when debating electoral strategies like third-party voting versus lesser-evil voting.
  3. The debate between deontology and consequentialism in voting ethics can lead to deeper discussions on philosophical principles and their application in political decision-making.

Luigi Mangione's "manifesto"

Unreported Truths • 56 implied HN points • 11 Dec 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Crime Media Public interest Political Commentary Justice
  1. Luigi Mangione wrote a note claiming he acted alone in a violent incident, expressing his frustrations with powerful companies exploiting the healthcare system.
  2. He believes that the U.S. has a big problem with healthcare costs and life expectancy, suggesting that many are aware of the issue but no real change has happened.
  3. Mangione's note was made public by a journalist, raising concerns about how some media outlets might not share important information with the public.

Links to Consider, 2/16

In My Tribe • 288 implied HN points • 16 Feb 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Policy Justice Media
  1. Specialization and trade have changed how we interact with others over time, leading to less local solidarity but more wealth.
  2. Publication selection bias impacts different fields like economics and psychology, affecting the presence of certain effects.
  3. Being critical of documentaries and trusting experts with verified beliefs are important in forming opinions on controversial issues.

Is Gladiator Stoic?

Caleb’s Newsletter • 137 implied HN points • 18 Nov 23
📖 Philosophy Stoicism Justice Afterlife Heroism
  1. The movie Gladiator raises the question of whether it embodies Stoic principles.
  2. Maximus's pursuit of revenge in Gladiator is seen as being non-Stoic due to his intense passion and anger.
  3. The character of Maximus in Gladiator eventually evolves to embody more Stoic values, moving from a place of rage to fulfilling his duty.