Castalia

Castalia is an intellectual journal featuring essays, reflections, and stories focused on themes like authenticity in writing, the impact of digital platforms, cultural critiques, and free speech. It emphasizes individuality, creativity over market-driven content, and ongoing debates about modern societal shifts.

Writing and Authenticity Digital Platforms Cultural Critiques Free Speech Modern Societal Shifts

The hottest Substack posts of Castalia

And their main takeaways

Commentator

359 implied HN points • 06 May 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Protests Elections Political parties Foreign Relations Social movements
  1. There's a growing divide within the Democratic Party between liberals and progressives, especially around the Israel/Palestine conflict. This split is becoming more visible as protests on campuses reflect differing worldviews.
  2. Protests are showing strong anti-Israel sentiments and are affecting US politics. These movements could add unexpected pressure on the current administration, similar to how unrest shaped past elections.
  3. Internationally, the situation in the Sahel is worsening as countries there are turning away from US partnerships and looking to Russia for support. This reflects a larger shift in global power dynamics.

To Whom It May Concern

1238 implied HN points • 28 Nov 23
📚 Literature Writing Poetry Fiction Literary Criticism Creative Nonfiction
  1. The recommendation letters highlight unusual and quirky characteristics of applicants, showing diverse and challenging backgrounds.
  2. Each candidate has distinct creative projects they are working on, ranging from deep personal struggles to dark humor.
  3. Despite their various issues, the letters suggest that these individuals could bring unique perspectives and contributions to a workshop setting.

New Year's Wishes for Substack

979 implied HN points • 02 Jan 24
📚 Literature Writing Publishing Creative Expression Community Innovation
  1. Substack should focus on great writing. The platform needs more individual voices and unique styles, rather than just advice and shortcuts among writers.
  2. People need to realize that publishing isn't the only measure of quality. A lot of interesting writing is happening outside traditional outlets, and more folks should engage with that.
  3. It's important for Substack to keep supporting free speech. This allows for a more open and creative environment where writers can express themselves freely without unnecessary moderation.

Democracy Dies In...Daylight?

379 implied HN points • 13 Apr 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Infrastructure Inequality Government Trust Public Discourse Political corruption
  1. The American infrastructure is falling apart and needs serious repairs. It's frustrating that other countries can build modern systems while the U.S. struggles.
  2. Trust in the government has been damaged, especially due to the recent political climate. This affects how people view leadership and policy.
  3. Inequality is rising in the U.S. despite the idea that anyone can achieve success. There’s a need for change to address wealth gaps and improve people's lives.

Who Was The German Resistance?

419 implied HN points • 01 Apr 24
💾 History World War II Resistance Movements Historical Figures
  1. There was a German resistance against Hitler that started as early as 1938, surprising many after the war. They actively tried to kill him and faced many challenges.
  2. Key figures like Henning von Tresckow and Admiral Wilhelm Canaris played important roles in the resistance. They took great risks and attempted several assassination plots.
  3. Their failure to kill Hitler and the skepticism from the Allies about their intentions limited their impact. Despite their courage, history could have been very different if they had succeeded.
Get a weekly roundup of the best Substack posts, by hacker news affinity:

New(ish) Books

299 implied HN points • 04 May 24
📚 Literature Book Reviews Author analysis Cultural Commentary Historical context
  1. Yanis Varoufakis argues that capitalism is fading and being replaced by a new system called 'technofeudalism,' where tech companies control online spaces and extract rent from users.
  2. Henry Wallace was a progressive political figure in the US, who came close to the presidency but was overshadowed by Truman. His ideals could have led America in a different direction after World War II.
  3. The analysis of Wallace's potential presidency raises questions about whether the US could have taken a more progressive path in its foreign and domestic policies.

A Spy Among Friends

339 implied HN points • 21 Apr 24
💾 History Cold War Espionage Intelligence Biographies Conspiracies
  1. The series _A Spy Among Friends_ explores the relationship between Kim Philby and Nicholas Elliott, highlighting their deep friendship and how it complicated the betrayal Philby committed against British intelligence.
  2. There is a debate about why Philby became a spy for the Soviets. Some think it was ideological, while others believe it was more about seeking elite social status or personal connections.
  3. The idea of intelligence sharing among spies suggests that they may have operated more like a close partnership rather than strict adversaries, raising questions about loyalty and the nature of espionage.

Curator

399 implied HN points • 04 Apr 24
🎭️ Culture AI Impact Cultural Trends Philosophy International relations
  1. AI is changing the way we work and create, making many jobs redundant while offering new opportunities for creativity. It's important to think about how we value work and identity in this new landscape.
  2. There is a shift happening in culture where algorithms and commercial success often overshadow true artistic expression. For high culture to survive, artists need to step away from these pressures and create in their own space.
  3. The idea of progress isn't always straight or guaranteed. Examining different historical world orders, especially non-European ones, can give us new ideas about what is possible for our future.

Commentator

339 implied HN points • 18 Apr 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Geopolitics War Strategy International relations Elections
  1. Israel and Iran are in a tense situation, but neither seems eager for a full-blown war. Both countries are more focused on saving face rather than escalating the conflict.
  2. The war in Ukraine is dragging on, with Ukrainian troops feeling exhausted and struggling for resources. The leaders need to rethink their strategies before it's too late.
  3. Trump's upcoming court trial could significantly impact the election season, as he will be tied up in the courtroom. It creates a unique situation that could shape the political landscape in America.

Eternal 1942

479 implied HN points • 05 Mar 24
💾 History World War II Military History Political History Cultural History Geopolitics
  1. The research and writing process can feel like stepping into another time, as the author immersed himself in 1942 to better understand that historical period. This experience helped him connect with his characters and the events they were navigating.
  2. In 1942, many believed that fascism showed efficiency and strength compared to liberal democracies, but by the end of the year, perspectives shifted as victories by the Allies began to change the tide of World War II.
  3. The legacy of understanding Nazism as a unique evil has shaped modern politics, leading to a focus on identifying and combatting extremism, something that continues to influence current political discussions.

It's The End of the Media As We Know It

599 implied HN points • 05 Feb 24
🎭️ Culture Media Journalism Communication Society History
  1. Many traditional media outlets are struggling or shutting down, marking a significant change in how we consume news and entertainment. This shift is linked to the rise of digital media and changing audience preferences.
  2. The old media model relied on a single, large audience with homogenous interests, but now people can connect with niche communities online. This is leading to a more diverse and fragmented public.
  3. Writers are now finding their voices outside of big institutions, allowing them to create authentic content for smaller, like-minded audiences. This could change what it means to be a journalist in today's world.

What's Beyond Neoliberalism?

799 implied HN points • 23 Dec 23
🎭️ Culture Art Philosophy Economics Society Politics
  1. Neoliberalism has shaped our world in a way that many people don't fully understand, but it connects security and markets to help economies work well globally.
  2. There are areas of life, like art and community, where the values of neoliberalism don’t fit, and we can find better worth and meaning outside of market measures.
  3. It's possible for individuals and creatives to live fulfilling lives without being just parts of the market, focusing on personal value and authentic expression instead.

The Case for Centrism

299 implied HN points • 24 Apr 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political theory Governance Electoral Politics Political Extremism Party Dynamics
  1. Centrism is a political approach that aims to find a balance between different views. It's about governing from the middle ground rather than extreme positions.
  2. Understanding the center of politics is crucial for effective governance. Good leaders can also shift the center to align with the needs of the people.
  3. Recent politics show a strong divide between extremes, which makes centrist policies more important. A focus on the middle can lead to real progress on important issues.

Curator

379 implied HN points • 30 Mar 24
🎭️ Culture Gender Issues Sexuality Psychedelics Social Dynamics Identity politics
  1. There's a big debate about trans issues and choices, especially about children and medical decisions like puberty blockers. Some people stress the importance of granting freedoms, while others worry about the consequences of those choices on young lives.
  2. The idea of polyamory suggests that relationships can be built on open communication and shared experiences instead of traditional monogamous norms. While some people admire this approach, others see it as complicated and challenging to manage.
  3. Psychedelics have become popular for their potential benefits, but there's a growing concern about unrealistic expectations and their safe use. People are starting to question whether these substances can really bring about lasting change in society.

Let The Espresso Martinis Speak!

619 implied HN points • 27 Jan 24
📚 Literature Writing Fiction Storytelling Expression Creativity
  1. Writing is about taking risks and pushing your limits. It's more meaningful when you explore ideas outside your comfort zone, even if it feels hard and messy.
  2. Every piece of writing starts with an initial idea or feeling. It's important to stay connected to that idea, as it shapes the entire work.
  3. Writing should come from intuition rather than overthinking. It helps to let your subconscious guide you, similar to how a performer relies on instinct during a show.

What I Wish I Knew When I Was In College

879 implied HN points • 02 Dec 23
🚌 Education Writing Tips Personal Growth Life lessons
  1. Everything around you is interesting. If you want to be a writer or creative, take notes on your life and thoughts because they can inspire your work later.
  2. You are enough just as you are. It's important to love yourself for who you are now, not who you hope to become.
  3. Success often comes from confidence. People are attracted to positive energy, so believe in yourself and keep pushing through challenges.

Where Writing Comes From

679 implied HN points • 11 Jan 24
📚 Literature Writing process Creative Writing Literary theory Personal Experience
  1. Writing comes from different sources like imagination, memory, and research. Each source gives a unique flavor to the writing.
  2. Writing can also be reactive or projected, where emotions or empathy shape what we create. These types can feel very honest but may lack depth over time.
  3. To improve our writing, we should tap into our imagination more. By exploring different sources and types of writing, we can express ourselves in richer ways.

Do I Like Ike?

479 implied HN points • 27 Feb 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Presidential History Political Leadership Civil Rights Cold War Political parties
  1. Eisenhower's leadership style was gentle and focused on teamwork. He aimed to create a positive political atmosphere and avoid conflict.
  2. He was criticized for not taking a strong stance on key issues like desegregation. Some people felt he should have shown more moral leadership during his presidency.
  3. Despite being popular in his time, Eisenhower's legacy is often overlooked today. Many aspects of his presidency, like budget balance and civility, are worth reflecting on as they contrast with today's politics.

Poor Things and Past Lives

399 implied HN points • 16 Mar 24
🎭️ Culture Film Literature Arts Society Criticism
  1. The movie 'Poor Things' explores female sexuality in a bold and open way. It shows the journey of a woman named Bella as she navigates her desires and experiences self-discovery through various relationships.
  2. In contrast, 'Past Lives' is seen as a less engaging film. It presents a story about characters who struggle to make meaningful connections, feeling lost in their choices and societal expectations.
  3. Both films address the complexities of relationships, but 'Poor Things' does so with more depth, highlighting the challenges women face in their journey, while 'Past Lives' feels flat and fails to invoke much emotion.

Match the Classic Work of Literature to the Pitch Proposal!

359 implied HN points • 25 Mar 24
📚 Literature Critique Analysis Creative Writing Humor
  1. Some literary proposals describe books with bizarre plots and characters. These unique stories can make it hard to match them with classic literature.
  2. Many proposals have strange themes, like a poem talking to a penis or characters stuck in a horse for years. They show how creative writers can be.
  3. Some pitches mix humor and serious topics, such as a story about a ruthless moneylender who also speaks beautifully. This blend often leads to unexpected twists.

RIP Richard Lewis

399 implied HN points • 11 Mar 24
🎭️ Culture Television Comedy Media Entertainment Society
  1. Richard Lewis brought a unique, quirky energy to 'Curb Your Enthusiasm,' standing out with his odd style and humor. His character provided a fun contrast to Larry David's more serious nature.
  2. The show uses clever storytelling, intertwining multiple plotlines that come together in unexpected ways. This structure keeps viewers engaged and makes every episode entertaining.
  3. Despite cultural shifts, 'Curb' remained popular by addressing everyday annoyances and experiences relatable to many. It skillfully balanced humor with observations about life, ensuring it stayed relevant over the years.

Zone of Interest and Anatomy of a Fall

359 implied HN points • 22 Mar 24
🎭️ Culture Film Literature Theater Art Media
  1. The film 'The Zone of Interest' explores the mundane lives of a Nazi family but reminds viewers of the horrors they are involved in. It struggles between showing normality and hinting at the evil actions taking place nearby.
  2. In 'Anatomy of a Fall', the story focuses on a couple's troubled relationship and the complexities of love, blame, and domestic life. It questions if challenges in marriage can lead to tragic outcomes.
  3. Both films touch on broader themes about humanity and morality. They suggest that ordinary lives can hide deep frustrations and darkness that, if unchecked, can spiral into serious issues.

Does Opinion Have A Point?

439 implied HN points • 22 Feb 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Media Trends Public Discourse Political Commentary
  1. Opinions in media are becoming more common, replacing traditional news reporting. This shift has made journalism feel more like a noisy argument rather than a calm exchange of facts.
  2. There are different ways to view opinion writing: as a policy statement, a persuasive tool, or a personal expression. Each approach serves its own purpose and can impact how people think.
  3. It's okay for opinions to be more casual and conversational. They don't always have to aim for a specific conclusion or action, allowing for a more relaxed way of sharing ideas.

218: A Thanksgiving Story

779 implied HN points • 24 Nov 23
🎭️ Culture Mental health Veterans Storytelling Documentary Personal narrative
  1. Many veterans face difficult lives filled with trauma, and often struggle to adjust to life after service. Places like Ft. Endurance provide support, but the road to recovery can be very tough.
  2. Scott's journey illustrates the deep emotional and physical pain veterans can endure, alongside their desire for connection and healing. Even small acts, like talking to a horse, can bring a sense of peace.
  3. Mental health struggles are real and ongoing for many veterans, and support from friends and family is crucial. It's important to check in on loved ones and encourage them to seek help.

Substack Tenets (and viva Sarah Fay!)

979 implied HN points • 03 Sep 23
📚 Literature Writing Publishing Self-Expression Creativity Communication
  1. Writing helps us deal with the feeling of being alone. It's surprising that more people don't use writing to fill their time instead of playing games on their phones.
  2. Writing allows people to express themselves without any restrictions from publishers or institutions. It gives a sense of freedom and responsibility in what you say.
  3. Writing can be a personal journey for self-discovery. It lets you explore who you are and find a purpose beyond just making money.

Commentator

339 implied HN points • 20 Mar 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Foreign Policy National Security International relations Legislation Political Analysis
  1. The relationship between the US and Israel is strained, especially over the situation in Rafah. Netanyahu seems more focused on his political survival than on international alliances.
  2. The CIA has had deep involvement in Ukraine long before the full-scale invasion, which changes how we understand the war. Ukraine was actively seeking US support and sharing intelligence to strengthen its position against Russia.
  3. There's a new push in the US to ban TikTok due to national security concerns. This reflects a shift toward more government control over technology and the internet, especially regarding threats posed by foreign entities like China.

Does The Week Exist?

459 implied HN points • 10 Feb 24
🎭️ Culture Cultural Studies Philosophy Sociology Meditation
  1. Each day of the week feels different, and these feelings can be shaped by culture and personal experiences. For example, many people love Fridays for the weekend vibes, while Tuesdays might feel a bit dull.
  2. The seven-day week is quite arbitrary compared to other time units like days and months, yet it influences our energy and routines. There are also ideas that our ancestors connected these days to the planets, giving them unique qualities.
  3. Modern life, filled with screens and remote work, changes how we experience time. This makes it easier to blend work and leisure, allowing for a lifestyle where we can pursue what we enjoy more consistently.

Can Great Power Politics Be Ethical?

299 implied HN points • 27 Mar 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Foreign Policy International relations Political theory Political Ethics Military Strategy
  1. Great power politics often involves tough choices where states prioritize their own interests. This leads to conflicts and a belief that violence can sometimes be necessary to maintain power.
  2. Realism, a key theory in international relations, suggests that international laws and good intentions often don't work. Instead, powerful nations will act according to their own interests, regardless of fairness.
  3. Despite hopes for a more cooperative international system, powerful states rarely act differently than weaker ones, and this creates a cycle of conflict driven by the pursuit of power.

Commentator

459 implied HN points • 31 Jan 24
🌍 World Politics Middle East US Foreign Policy Ukraine war
  1. The conflict between Israel and Hamas is now viewed as a proxy war between the U.S. and Iran, with rising tensions and escalating military actions on both sides. The focus is shifting towards political solutions as military options reach their limits.
  2. In Ukraine, there's a growing sentiment of 'Ukraine Fatigue' among Western supporters, but it's crucial to continue support because the war is tied to Ukraine's identity and survival as a nation against Russian aggression.
  3. There's a significant challenge in achieving a stable future for Gaza, where military leadership remains intact, and the humanitarian crisis continues. Any resolution will need to balance military actions with realistic political agreements.

Commentator

379 implied HN points • 21 Feb 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Foreign Policy Military conflict Elections Political Commentary International relations
  1. It's really hard to talk about the Israel-Gaza conflict because people have strong feelings and different views. It's important to recognize Israel's right to defend itself, but many innocent people in Gaza are suffering too.
  2. Alexei Navalny showed great courage by returning to Russia despite knowing the risks. He represents the idea of standing firm on one's principles, and his legacy challenges us to think about bravery in the face of tyranny.
  3. The current political situation in the U.S. has lots of people worried about Biden's age and electability. There's a growing discussion about whether it's time for the Democratic Party to find a new candidate who could energize voters and win the upcoming election.

Does The Past Exist?

579 implied HN points • 19 Dec 23
📖 Philosophy Existence Literature History Critique Rationalism Aesthetics
  1. Some people believe that the past doesn't matter as much because they think progress leads to better results today. They argue that everything improves over time, like athletes breaking records.
  2. However, the author argues that past achievements in areas like literature and chess have their own unique value and should not be dismissed. The past has lessons and beauty that are still relevant today.
  3. It's important to respect the past and recognize its significance. It shouldn't just be seen as a stepping stone for the present.

New(ish) Books

419 implied HN points • 03 Feb 24
📚 Literature Book Reviews Fiction Non-fiction Publishing Cultural critique
  1. Labatut's book 'The MANIAC' explores the dangerous implications of artificial intelligence and how certain brilliant figures, like John von Neumann, led to a shift in human consciousness towards a more logic-driven existence.
  2. Nocera and McLean's 'The Big Fail' argues that the pandemic revealed serious flaws in America's systems, especially in public health, and critiques the profit-driven mindset that worsened the crisis.
  3. The authors emphasize the importance of trust in government and public health responses during the pandemic, highlighting that a lack of open dialogue and transparency led to deep societal divisions.

KG: Fending off Selena Gomez in Bishkek

459 implied HN points • 21 Jan 24
🏝 Travel Travel Writing Cultural Exploration Personal essays Adventure
  1. Kyrgyzstan is a place that can feel both lonely and welcoming at the same time. The author experienced both isolation and a sense of community during their visits.
  2. Bishkek has changed over the years, becoming safer and more modern. The author's past experiences of danger have shifted to more everyday issues like taxi rides and music choices.
  3. Life in Kyrgyzstan is quite affordable and functional. People seem to get by, and while it may not have rich resources, there’s a sense of contentment in the everyday life.

Barbie and Killers of the Flower Moon

399 implied HN points • 19 Jan 24
🎭️ Culture Film Aesthetics Feminism History Criticism
  1. The movie 'Barbie' is all about world-building and creativity. It mixes different genres and offers a fun view on feminism, showing that it's not just about power, but also understanding emotions and relationships.
  2. In contrast, 'Killers of the Flower Moon' focuses on the dark side of American history. It tells a sad story about greed and racism, showcasing how these forces affected the Osage people and their lives.
  3. Both films represent different styles of storytelling. 'Barbie' uses imagination and humor, while 'Killers of the Flower Moon' highlights serious historical themes, inviting viewers to think deeply about America’s past.

New(ish) Books

259 implied HN points • 14 Mar 24
📚 Literature Book Reviews Cultural critique Historical context Political Analysis Personal narratives
  1. Rashid Khalidi's book highlights the ongoing struggle of the Palestinian people, presenting their history as a long struggle against colonialism and displacement. It's important to understand the deep historical roots of the conflict to grasp the current situation.
  2. Nathan Thrall's book depicts everyday life in Palestine, showcasing the struggles and frustrations faced by ordinary people. It focuses less on direct violence and more on the daily humiliations and systemic issues that affect Palestinian life.
  3. Both books encourage readers to look beyond simple narratives and consider the complexities of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Engaging with these stories helps build a broader perspective on the suffering and aspirations of both peoples.

Commentator

419 implied HN points • 08 Jan 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political Analysis Political Commentary Current Events Elections Civil Rights
  1. Different opinions exist about Claudine Gay's resignation from Harvard, with some seeing it as a failure of liberal institutions and others blaming the focus on diversity and inclusion efforts.
  2. The 14th Amendment's potential use to disqualify Trump raises concerns about political crises, with many believing that fair elections should resolve political disputes instead.
  3. In the Israel-Gaza conflict, concerns about potential ethnic cleansing indicate a troubling direction for Israel's policies, while the U.S. is increasingly pushed to reconsider its support for Netanyahu's government.

Karma Police

159 implied HN points • 01 May 24
📚 Literature Fiction Short Stories Narrative Character Study Artistic expression
  1. Growing up in a middle-class family can shape how you view money and success. The main character, Jon, learned about budgeting and finances from his parents, which influenced his choices later in life.
  2. Artistic ambition can sometimes clash with practical family expectations. Jon's desire to be a painter conflicted with his parents' focus on traditional stability and financial security.
  3. Karma can play a role in personal journeys. Jon feels that through his success, he's also fulfilling a legacy linked to his past and the painter who lived in the family loft before him.

Liberals v. Progressives

599 implied HN points • 31 Oct 23
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Liberalism Progressivism Political theory Social justice Israel-Palestine
  1. Liberals believe the world has room for improvement but is mostly okay, while progressives feel everything is terrible and getting worse.
  2. Liberals see violence as an anomaly to be handled through legal systems, while progressives view it as a result of power imbalances that need moral commitment to fix.
  3. Liberals think progress is slow but happening, while progressives focus solely on social justice and need major changes to address past wrongs.

Match The Advice Column To The Famous Writer!

479 implied HN points • 08 Dec 23
📚 Literature Writing advice Literary Analysis Cultural critique Essay
  1. Be careful when trying wild stunts, especially if you're not in the best shape. Always practice safe actions, and remember to write down your experiences.
  2. There are many ways to show loyalty without resorting to extreme actions. It's important to find safer and healthier alternatives to prove your commitments.
  3. Having a solid writing routine can help you be consistent. Try to make it as easy as possible so you can stick to it daily.

Israel's 9/11

619 implied HN points • 14 Oct 23
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Middle East Global Affairs Security Issues Policy Analysis Historical comparisons
  1. The attack on Israel is being compared to 9/11, marking a significant and tragic shift in the region's dynamics. This event signals a move away from a long-term cease-fire and the hopes for better relations in the Middle East.
  2. As a result of the attack, there is a global understanding that the world might be entering a new era of chaos, where traditional power structures are challenged. Countries are reacting to events like these in ways that break from established norms.
  3. It’s important for Israel to handle the aftermath wisely, avoiding the mistakes made by the U.S. after 9/11. Maintaining perspective and understanding the complexity of politics will be key in navigating this new reality.