The hottest Media Criticism Substack posts right now

And their main takeaways
Category
Top U.S. Politics Topics

Trump is Trolling the AP

TK News by Matt Taibbi • 11641 implied HN points • 19 Feb 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political Commentary Media Criticism Censorship Trump Era Journalism
  1. The Associated Press claims the White House is telling them how to report, which some see as censorship. This seems ironic since the AP has always had strict rules about language in their articles.
  2. People are discussing how Trump is mocking the AP's situation, pointing out the contradiction in their messages about free speech.
  3. There's a lot of debate about what it means for the government and the media to control language and how it affects honest reporting.

CBS Loses Its Mind

TK News by Matt Taibbi • 15007 implied HN points • 17 Feb 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Media Criticism Political speech International relations Government Accountability
  1. J.D. Vance gave a powerful speech in Europe defending free speech and democracy, warning that the U.S. may not support Europe if it continues to jail people for speech.
  2. CBS responded to Vance's address by airing a segment that appeared to compare defending free speech with dangerous historical events, which sparked a lot of discussion.
  3. The coverage from CBS seemed more like a political statement rather than a straightforward news report, raising questions about media bias.

Victor Davis Hanson: Can Trump Troll His Way to a Peace Deal in Ukraine?

Common Sense with Bari Weiss • 3130 implied HN points • 21 Feb 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political Debate International relations Conflict analysis Media Criticism Historical context
  1. There is a debate among conservatives about Trump's comments on Ukraine and its president, Zelensky. Some believe Trump's words were inappropriate, while others argue the historical situation is different.
  2. Niall Ferguson criticized Trump's approach by referencing George H.W. Bush's strong response to Iraq's invasion of Kuwait. Ferguson felt Trump should not have called Zelensky a dictator.
  3. J.D. Vance defended Trump by saying that the situations facing Trump and Bush were not the same. He suggested that entering a war against a nuclear power is more complicated than dealing with Iraq's weaker military.

The Garbage Comment

Erick Erickson's Confessions of a Political Junkie • 1318 implied HN points • 30 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political Commentary Election Analysis Public Opinion Media Criticism Political strategy
  1. Biden called Trump supporters 'garbage', which upset many people and created a bit of chaos in the White House.
  2. A lot of voters, only 28%, think the country is going in the right direction, which is low for an incumbent party.
  3. Instead of sharing their plans to improve things, Biden and some of Harris's supporters are focusing on negative comments about Trump supporters.

If Paul Krugman Didn't Have Enough Juice at the New York Times, Who Could?

Freddie deBoer • 9560 implied HN points • 17 Feb 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Media Criticism Journalism Public Opinion
  1. Heavy editing can take away a writer's unique voice. It's important for writers to maintain their style even when being edited.
  2. Big organizations may see their employees as replaceable, which can affect morale and creativity. This can lead to a competition where everyone fears losing their job.
  3. The pressures of being in an elite institution can change how content is produced. Writers may face strict guidelines that limit creative freedom.
Get a weekly roundup of the best Substack posts, by hacker news affinity:

No, Mr. President, It Was Russia that Started the War

Common Sense with Bari Weiss • 1150 implied HN points • 20 Feb 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political Discourse Historical revisionism International relations War Studies Media Criticism
  1. People are sometimes dishonest about the past, especially in the context of wars. This can make it hard to understand the truth of what happened.
  2. Russia is being called the aggressor in the conflict, and it's important for leaders to acknowledge that fact. Ignoring this can affect peace efforts.
  3. Some leaders, like the former president, may spread misleading information about who started a conflict, which can confuse public opinion on important issues.

Wired’s Scicomm Writer Emily Mullin Attacks Independent Research, Because of Course

The DisInformation Chronicle • 565 implied HN points • 11 Feb 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Media Criticism COVID Policy Political narratives Science communication Public Health
  1. The article critiques a piece by Emily Mullin that is critical of a new science journal, saying it contains many errors and misleading statements. It argues that journalists can sometimes promote their own biases instead of focusing on factual reporting.
  2. It highlights a term called 'dial-a-quote,' where writers seek quotes from people they know will support their narrative, instead of looking for a balanced perspective. This practice can skew the way information is presented to readers.
  3. The discussion raises concerns about the credibility of some researchers who contribute to science writing. It points out how certain quotes and opinions may align with existing narratives rather than presenting objective scientific information.

Trump: Free the Hostages or ‘All Hell Will Break Out.’ Plus...

Common Sense with Bari Weiss • 2142 implied HN points • 11 Feb 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political News Government Policy Public Opinion Elections Media Criticism
  1. Trump has issued a strong warning to Hamas, saying they must release all hostages by a certain deadline or there will be severe consequences. This has raised tensions in an already fragile ceasefire situation.
  2. The conversation around cancel culture is changing, with some claiming it's over and discussing what might come next. People are concerned about where this shift could lead us in terms of public discourse.
  3. There's a debate about whether Kanye West may need a conservatorship due to his troubling behavior. Some believe it's important to ensure he gets the help he needs while balancing concerns about autonomy and mental health.

Everybody hates Andrew Tate

Of Boys and Men • 286 implied HN points • 01 Mar 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political Commentary Public Opinion Media Criticism Gender Issues Right-wing
  1. Andrew Tate is widely criticized for his controversial views on gender roles, often referring to women in derogatory terms.
  2. Even conservative figures, like Ron DeSantis and Ben Shapiro, are speaking out against Tate, showing a rare unity in disapproval across the political spectrum.
  3. Despite some minor support from fringe groups, the general consensus is that most people do not want Andrew Tate in the U.S. due to his alleged criminal background.

The Musklash

Read Max • 9221 implied HN points • 17 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political Analysis Public Figures Media Criticism Social Commentary
  1. Elon Musk has faced backlash from the gaming community after failing at a game he claimed to be good at. Gamers are calling out his dishonesty about his gaming skills.
  2. Musk's controversial comments on immigration and his partnership with nationalist groups have made some of his previous supporters uneasy. This shows a growing divide in the political groups that used to back him.
  3. Despite losing support from various communities, Musk's wealth still protects him from serious consequences. However, the criticism he receives might affect his need for approval and popularity.

The New York Times Comments Section is Hilarious and Depraved

TK News by Matt Taibbi • 12326 implied HN points • 08 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Free speech Media Criticism Censorship Social media Public Opinion
  1. Less censorship on social media could lead to a wider spread of misinformation. Some people are worried about what this means for public discourse.
  2. The New York Times comments section shows a divide among readers on the issue of free speech, with many expressing fear over less content moderation.
  3. Critics of social media platforms often focus on their role in political events, showing how media coverage can shape public opinion about these companies.

Begin the Deprogramming: There Was No "Pandemic of the Unvaccinated"

TK News by Matt Taibbi • 18799 implied HN points • 08 Nov 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Public Health Vaccination Government Policy Media Criticism Public Opinion
  1. The vaccines didn't work as well as promised, and it's important to look at how the public was informed about them. Many people might have been misled about their effectiveness.
  2. There was a lot of pressure from officials to follow strict guidelines, but some of these recommendations may not have been based on solid research.
  3. The narrative that there was a 'pandemic of the unvaccinated' was likely part of a larger campaign, aimed at stirring emotions and turning the public against each other.

None Of These War Criminals Will Face Justice While The US Empire Exists

Caitlin’s Newsletter • 2463 implied HN points • 17 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics War Crimes Justice Government Accountability International Law Media Criticism
  1. Many officials involved in war crimes don't face justice because powerful countries protect them. They often continue their careers without consequences.
  2. Questions about war crimes can lead to disrespectful treatment, even removal from press conferences. The focus is more on the questions being asked than the issues raised.
  3. Real change and justice seem impossible as long as the current power structures exist. The cycle of violence and impunity will continue unless there's a shift in global power.

The Gaslighting, and a clarification

Disaffected Newsletter • 4316 implied HN points • 02 Aug 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Media Criticism Public Opinion Identity politics Social Issues
  1. Gaslighting is a serious issue where people are made to feel crazy for their beliefs. This can happen on a large scale in society, affecting how we see and understand certain situations.
  2. Physical characteristics, like bone structure and body shape, play a role in how we perceive someone's gender. It's important to acknowledge that many people can see these traits, regardless of their beliefs.
  3. Psychological manipulation can come from various sources, including media and authority figures. It's crucial to recognize this abuse and maintain self-respect to protect ourselves.

8 signs that Donald Trump has a progressive form of dementia

Marcus on AI • 7390 implied HN points • 02 Nov 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Media Criticism Public Opinion Election Commentary
  1. There are signs that suggest Donald Trump may have a form of dementia, including issues with memory and inappropriate behaviors.
  2. The media is not fully addressing Trump's mental health concerns, even as they report individual incidents that raise alarm.
  3. Experts and caregivers should speak out about Trump's condition to ensure the public understands the potential risks for the future of the presidency.

Niall Ferguson: The Rot In Britain—and the Remedy

Common Sense with Bari Weiss • 3941 implied HN points • 05 Dec 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political Discourse Freedom of Speech Media Criticism International relations
  1. There is a growing concern about the state of debate and free speech in Britain, especially highlighted by an incident at the Oxford Union. People are feeling that open discussions are being stifled.
  2. During a recent debate, the crowd showed hostility towards pro-Israel speakers, indicating a divide in opinions and a lack of respect for differing viewpoints. This suggests there may be an atmosphere that discourages diverse opinions.
  3. Overall, the situation raises questions about national identity and the importance of preserving traditional values in the face of modern challenges. People are worried about losing what makes their country special.

‘Globalize the Intifada’ Comes to New Orleans

Common Sense with Bari Weiss • 1595 implied HN points • 06 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Terrorism Public Safety Civil Rights Media Criticism Political Commentary
  1. A recent attack in New Orleans involved a terrorist act that killed multiple people and showed how global trends of violence can impact local communities.
  2. Witnesses reported seeing an ISIS flag with the attacker, highlighting the connection between local violence and international extremists.
  3. A corporate leader responded to the tragedy by talking about positivity and acceptance, which some found inappropriate given the severity of the situation.

A Mostly Fire-Free LA

Life Since the Baby Boom • 1152 implied HN points • 13 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Media Criticism Political Coverage Public Perception
  1. Not all of LA is burning. In fact, only a small part of the area is affected by fires, and most residents are safe.
  2. News often focuses on dramatic stories, like fires or violence, because they attract more viewers. Good news doesn't get as much attention.
  3. Despite big headlines, the majority of people in LA are not under evacuation orders, showing that the situation isn't as dire for everyone.

Bluesky is the Last Thing America Needs

I Might Be Wrong • 14 implied HN points • 26 Feb 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political Discourse Social media Progressivism Media Criticism Cultural Commentary
  1. Bluesky, a social media platform, is gaining users from Twitter, especially among left-leaning people. But some think it isn't a good alternative for healthy political discussion.
  2. The platform is criticized for being overwhelming with progressive views, comparing it to being on a wild drug trip. This suggests that it might not be beneficial to political discourse.
  3. The future of social media is uncertain, especially for Twitter, as people keep searching for better platforms. However, Bluesky might not be the answer many are looking for.

More Misleading News

David Friedman’s Substack • 260 implied HN points • 11 Feb 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political News Media Criticism Government Action Political Rhetoric
  1. Disney is changing its approach to diversity programs. It might just be quieter about them rather than completely cutting them out.
  2. Trump's comments about journalists at his rally were controversial. He wasn't saying he wanted someone to shoot them, but rather that he wouldn't mind dying if it happened during a confrontation.
  3. Some news articles can exaggerate facts. For example, a machine was called indispensable in a story, but there are actually many similar machines, and the headline misled readers.

They Lied About Gaza, And They're Lying About Syria

Caitlin’s Newsletter • 2989 implied HN points • 01 Dec 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Foreign Policy Media Criticism Government Accountability
  1. The situation in Syria involves complex political maneuvers, and the U.S. has played a role in fostering chaos there. It's important to question the official narratives about conflicts instead of accepting them at face value.
  2. Many people see through lies about one conflict, like Gaza, but still believe the stories told about another, like Syria. It's vital to maintain curiosity and seek the truth across all situations.
  3. The way homelessness is treated reflects larger societal issues. Instead of hiding homelessness from view, we should confront the underlying problems and injustices that cause it.

Jake Tapper's Unoriginal Sin

Unreported Truths • 61 implied HN points • 04 Jun 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Journalism Government Elections Public Policy Media Criticism
  1. Jake Tapper and Alex Thompson's book 'Original Sin' lacks new and important information about Joe Biden's mental decline. It mostly restates what many already knew.
  2. The media has praised the book as groundbreaking, but it does not address its own failures in covering Biden's issues during his presidency.
  3. Good journalism should question authority and seek the truth, rather than just echoing popular opinions or the status quo.

What's the Point of The New York Times?

JoeWrote • 196 implied HN points • 11 Feb 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Media Criticism Press freedom Political Reporting Public Trust Journalism Ethics
  1. Many people don't trust traditional media like The New York Times anymore. They are turning to other sources like podcasts and blogs for news.
  2. Legacy media companies have lost readers because they often prioritize profits and sensational stories over accurate reporting.
  3. Even big newspapers can make mistakes, and if they don't admit them or improve their practices, they risk losing even more readers.

Don't Buy Into Phony Anti-Establishment Schtick

Caitlin’s Newsletter • 1723 implied HN points • 04 Dec 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Media Criticism Political Messaging Populism Corruption
  1. Many people believe the media is corrupt, and that's true. But just because some leaders point this out doesn't mean they are offering real solutions.
  2. It's important to be careful about which political movements we support. Some anti-establishment figures might actually be leading us back to the same problems we want to escape.
  3. Real change requires looking beyond mainstream party politics. We need to seek genuine revolutionary ideas, not just those packaged as 'populist' by political leaders.

Congratulations On Your Independent, Alternative Media, You Disgruntled Consumers

Singal-Minded • 1263 implied HN points • 09 Dec 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Media Criticism Consumer Protection Political Commentary Financial Institutions Public Discourse
  1. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) is meant to protect consumers from unfair practices by financial institutions. It focuses on preventing issues like misleading loans and discrimination.
  2. Marc Andreessen made false claims about the CFPB, saying it helps banks to 'debank' individuals based on their political views. In reality, the CFPB actually fights against discrimination and debanking.
  3. Joe Rogan often doesn't push back on controversial claims made by his guests, which can lead to misinformation being spread without proper fact-checking.

What Happened When I Asked Michael Shellenberger To Defend His Journalism

Singal-Minded • 1628 implied HN points • 12 Nov 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political Commentary Media Criticism Election Law Public Discourse Censorship
  1. Michael Shellenberger, known for his views on free speech, called for the government to revoke NBC's broadcasting license, which raises questions about his journalistic integrity.
  2. His claims about NBC breaking election laws were based on misinterpretations and lacked solid evidence, showing a drift into conspiracy thinking.
  3. The situation highlights how personal politics can distort professional standards, making it hard to trust someone's reporting if they confuse facts and emotions.

NY Times Opinion Page is a Fact-Challenged Disaster

The DisInformation Chronicle • 840 implied HN points • 09 Dec 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Media Criticism Political Ideology Fact-checking Opinion Pieces
  1. The New York Times' opinion page is facing criticism for not sticking to strong journalism standards anymore. Many believe it prioritizes narratives over facts.
  2. Recent articles in the Times show a lack of thorough fact-checking and reliance on questionable information. This has led to misleading claims being widely shared.
  3. There are growing concerns about the connections between writers at the Times and big industries, especially in how they report on issues like healthcare and the opioid crisis.

Legacy Media Still Lying, Calls Atlas, Bhattacharya, Makary 'COVID Deniers'

Unmasked • 67 implied HN points • 14 Feb 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Media Criticism COVID Policy Public Health Political Accountability Misinformation
  1. Legacy media continues to blame others for their mistakes during the COVID-19 pandemic, refusing to acknowledge their own errors.
  2. There is a pattern of the elite using their influence to enforce unreasonable rules on the public, then blaming people for not following them.
  3. Articles in mainstream publications often contain misinformation and inaccuracies, causing frustration for those looking for truthful reporting.

Putin's Tucker

Diane Francis • 5635 implied HN points • 12 Feb 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Media Criticism Political Commentary International relations War reporting
  1. Tucker Carlson acted more like a fan than a journalist during his interview with Putin, not challenging his claims at all. This left viewers without important facts about the war in Ukraine.
  2. Carlson framed his journey to interview Putin as brave journalism, but many real journalists wanted the chance and were denied. He was picked for his support of Russian viewpoints.
  3. The interview played into Putin's hands by spreading his false narratives. This undermined support for Ukraine at a critical time when the U.S. was debating military aid.

Michael Shellenberger Mixed Up Two Guys With Sorta Similar Names And Falsely Told His Readers — And Congress — One Of Them Might Be A Spy As A Result

Singal-Minded • 1046 implied HN points • 13 Nov 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Media Criticism Censorship Misinformation
  1. Michael Shellenberger mistakenly mixed up two people with similar names, leading to false claims about one of them possibly being a spy. This is a serious error for a journalist.
  2. Critics have pointed out that Shellenberger has often published misleading information about people he disagrees with politically, which raises questions about his journalistic standards.
  3. After realizing the mistake, Shellenberger corrected the information but did not make a big announcement about the error, which is concerning for public trust in his work.

ESPN: The Worldwide Leader in Shit

Personality Disorder • 118 implied HN points • 03 Oct 24
🎾 Sports Broadcasting Baseball Media Criticism Fan Experience Sports culture
  1. The quality of sports broadcasts, especially the Mets' broadcasts, can really enhance the viewing experience. Good announcers and production can make a big difference.
  2. ESPN isn't focused on the game itself but more on entertainment, often ignoring the intense moments fans care about. This can make watching their broadcasts frustrating for dedicated fans.
  3. In-game interviews and distracting graphics during critical moments take away from the excitement. Fans want to see the game, not be bombarded with ads or pointless interviews.

The Price Of Orthodoxies

The Weekly Dish • 186 implied HN points • 10 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political Discourse Social Issues Media Criticism Cultural critique Justice System
  1. Orthodoxies can make us ignore hard truths and the suffering of others. They create blind spots that can hide serious issues.
  2. When we stick too closely to a certain belief or idea, we might miss out on understanding the full picture of what's really happening.
  3. It's important to challenge our beliefs and stay open to new information, so we can see and address injustices.

War on Gaza (w/ Joe Sacco) | The Chris Hedges Report

The Chris Hedges Report • 111 implied HN points • 22 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Civil Rights Foreign Relations Media Criticism Censorship
  1. Joe Sacco uses graphic journalism to share stories from war zones, bringing a unique perspective that traditional media often misses. His work combines drawings and humor to convey tough realities.
  2. Sacco raises important questions about how we define aggression and self-defense, especially in context of the violence in Gaza. He suggests we need new terms to describe the complex nature of these conflicts.
  3. The discussion highlights the moral dilemmas faced in voting and supporting policies that contribute to violence, questioning how citizens can remain complicit while wanting change.

'That's just a conspiracy theory'

Disaffected Newsletter • 2338 implied HN points • 28 Mar 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Conspiracy Theories Political Identity Media Criticism Mental health Activism
  1. It's common to dismiss conspiracy theories out of fear and emotional investment in our beliefs. This can make people react angrily when others challenge those ideas.
  2. Many people find that as they grow older, they start to question everything they thought they knew, including their political beliefs and the nature of truth.
  3. In today's world, it’s easy to feel uncertain and fearful due to the unpredictable nature of government actions, making it reasonable to consider alternative explanations for events instead of just accepting official narratives.

"The Chinese Government Will Lie to You!" said the U.S. Government the Day It Was Caught Lying to Us.

JoeWrote • 165 implied HN points • 16 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Media Criticism Foreign Policy Social media Public Opinion
  1. The ceasefire in Gaza shows what really happened during the conflict. Now that fighting has stopped, more people can report the true impact on civilians.
  2. The U.S. government and media have misled the public about the reasons behind the ceasefire and the crisis in Gaza. Many now see this as part of a larger pattern of dishonesty.
  3. Concerns over apps like TikTok highlight a divide in perception about security and media control. Some people believe manipulation is happening on both sides, questioning why they should fear one over the other.

January 6th was Successful

Unpopular Front • 114 implied HN points • 06 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political strategy Constitutional Law Media Criticism Party Dynamics Political polarization
  1. The January 6th attack on the Capitol was seen as a political success for Trump. Even after the chaos, he managed to rally support among his followers.
  2. Trump's approach has shifted the political landscape, making opposition seem less credible. Some critics are now viewed as supportive of him, whether they realize it or not.
  3. There is a sense that Trump's actions have broken the systems of law and norms, leading to a more raw and partisan political environment, where traditional standards no longer apply.

The part of my quote Piers Morgan doesn't want you to see

Taylor Lorenz's Newsletter • 1313 implied HN points • 12 Dec 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Media Criticism Political Commentary Public Opinion Social justice
  1. Media often simplifies and twists comments to create drama. This can lead to misunderstandings about what people really mean.
  2. People may feel joy or relief about systemic issues being highlighted, not about individual tragedies. It's important to focus on the bigger picture.
  3. The public should question the media's motives and not just react to headlines. It's crucial to think critically about narratives pushed by powerful figures.

Dingus of the Week: Everyone except Bishop Mariann Edgar Budde

Men Yell at Me • 729 implied HN points • 24 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political Humor Government Action Media Criticism Political Commentary
  1. Trump's recent actions and decisions seem reckless and disconnected from reality, drawing strange comparisons to the past.
  2. Bishop Mariann Edgar Budde's plea for compassion during a recent prayer service highlights the importance of kindness to vulnerable people, despite backlash from conservative commentators.
  3. There is a growing sentiment that the established political rules are no longer effective, and new, bold strategies are needed to create positive change.

leaving in a huff

bad cattitude • 327 implied HN points • 18 Nov 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political Discourse Social media Media Criticism Identity politics Public Opinion
  1. Some people are leaving social media platforms because they can't handle disagreements about their ideas. Instead of debating, they prefer to retreat to spaces where only their views are accepted.
  2. When someone sees their beliefs challenged, it can feel like a personal attack. This can lead to a strong reaction, making them defensive and unwilling to explore other viewpoints.
  3. The focus on consensus can lead to a false sense of security. People may feel more comfortable in like-minded groups, but this limits healthy discussions and the chance to grow through different opinions.