The hottest Cultural critique Substack posts right now

And their main takeaways
Category
Top Art & Illustration Topics

First draft of a maxim

Disaffected Newsletter • 939 implied HN points • 20 Oct 23
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Social Issues Identity politics Cultural critique Philosophy Public Discourse
  1. It's important to clarify definitions before discussing disagreements. Often, people think they're disagreeing when they are just using different meanings for the same words.
  2. The author challenges the common views on 'isms' like homophobia and racism. They argue that not all criticisms labeled as these are actually rooted in hate or irrational fear.
  3. Many claims of 'ism' are seen as tools to silence opposing viewpoints, rather than genuine expressions of prejudice. The author believes these claims are often untrue or exaggerated.

I'm not going where you're going

Disaffected Newsletter • 1958 implied HN points • 05 Apr 23
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political Views Social Issues Cultural critique Personal Reflection
  1. Losing friends can happen when your views change. When someone undergoes personal growth or changes their beliefs, it can strain relationships.
  2. Some people choose to ignore harsh realities. It's hard to stay friends with those who refuse to see or accept truths you believe are important.
  3. Living in denial affects trust. When friends refuse to acknowledge issues, it can lead to a breakdown in trust and a feeling that you can't stay in the same space anymore.

New(ish) Books

Castalia • 419 implied HN points • 03 Feb 24
📚 Literature Book Reviews Fiction Non-fiction Publishing Cultural critique
  1. Labatut's book 'The MANIAC' explores the dangerous implications of artificial intelligence and how certain brilliant figures, like John von Neumann, led to a shift in human consciousness towards a more logic-driven existence.
  2. Nocera and McLean's 'The Big Fail' argues that the pandemic revealed serious flaws in America's systems, especially in public health, and critiques the profit-driven mindset that worsened the crisis.
  3. The authors emphasize the importance of trust in government and public health responses during the pandemic, highlighting that a lack of open dialogue and transparency led to deep societal divisions.
Get a weekly roundup of the best Substack posts, by hacker news affinity:

This is Cluster B on Substack

Disaffected Newsletter • 1578 implied HN points • 20 Apr 23
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Social Issues Activism Identity politics Cultural critique
  1. Some people use their past trauma to gain sympathy and make accusations against others. This can sometimes be manipulative, as they may not show the whole story.
  2. There's a group of people who want strict moderation of online speech, but platforms like Substack don’t follow those same rules as Twitter does.
  3. When some individuals who are used to getting their way face pushback for the first time, it can be surprising and almost entertaining for others to witness.

Links to Consider, 10/31/2024

In My Tribe • 318 implied HN points • 31 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Education Gender Issues Energy Policy Cultural critique
  1. There are concerns about universities becoming less helpful and more like madrassas, which could harm scientific progress. Some people think we need to seriously rethink how universities operate.
  2. A new app called SocialAI lets users interact with AI-generated comments, creating a fake social network experience. This raises concerns about loneliness and real connections in our increasingly digital lives.
  3. Many men today feel that dating is harder and that their identities are being criticized. Surveys show that while people support gender equality, some men are feeling unwanted and frustrated.

New(ish) Books

Castalia • 259 implied HN points • 14 Mar 24
📚 Literature Book Reviews Cultural critique Historical context Political Analysis Personal narratives
  1. Rashid Khalidi's book highlights the ongoing struggle of the Palestinian people, presenting their history as a long struggle against colonialism and displacement. It's important to understand the deep historical roots of the conflict to grasp the current situation.
  2. Nathan Thrall's book depicts everyday life in Palestine, showcasing the struggles and frustrations faced by ordinary people. It focuses less on direct violence and more on the daily humiliations and systemic issues that affect Palestinian life.
  3. Both books encourage readers to look beyond simple narratives and consider the complexities of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Engaging with these stories helps build a broader perspective on the suffering and aspirations of both peoples.

Match The Advice Column To The Famous Writer!

Castalia • 479 implied HN points • 08 Dec 23
📚 Literature Writing advice Literary Analysis Cultural critique Essay
  1. Be careful when trying wild stunts, especially if you're not in the best shape. Always practice safe actions, and remember to write down your experiences.
  2. There are many ways to show loyalty without resorting to extreme actions. It's important to find safer and healthier alternatives to prove your commitments.
  3. Having a solid writing routine can help you be consistent. Try to make it as easy as possible so you can stick to it daily.

A Night at the Garden

Unpopular Front • 67 implied HN points • 29 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political Events Populism Media influence Cultural critique
  1. Trump's public persona is a lot like a pro wrestler. He swings between being a hero and a villain, and this theatrical style draws people in.
  2. There's a connection between Trump's political events and wrestling shows. Both aim to entertain and provoke strong reactions from the audience.
  3. The idea of justice in wrestling often relies on breaking rules for a satisfying outcome. Similarly, Trump's approach to politics breaks norms, appealing to those who feel overlooked or humiliated.

Us feminists really did kill marriage

Sex and the State • 30 implied HN points • 12 Dec 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Feminism Marriage Family Social Issues Cultural critique
  1. Marriage rates are going down in many countries, and it's important to understand why this is happening. Some people think it's due to modern influences, but the reasons are more complex.
  2. Conservatives sometimes blame feminists for this decline, and while they might have a point, it's important to understand the full picture. Feminists often criticize marriage and family structures as outdated or oppressive.
  3. Some feminists actually support the idea of abolishing marriage altogether. This has led to different views on relationships and family, impacting how society sees them today.

Environ-Mental!

Disaffected Newsletter • 719 implied HN points • 30 Jul 23
😂 Humor Social Commentary Environmental Issues Cultural critique Everyday life
  1. Some extreme environmentalists want to take drastic actions, like shutting down airports and banning wood burning, claiming it's for future generations.
  2. There is a mention of frustrations in everyday scenarios, like dealing with angry employees at Dunkin Donuts.
  3. Traffic behavior is highlighted, showing how many drivers ignore rules, leading to chaos on the roads.

Is everything racist? A book recommendation

Disaffected Newsletter • 899 implied HN points • 30 May 23
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Race Issues Meritocracy Wokeness Cultural critique
  1. The book 'When Race Trumps Merit' by Heather MacDonald discusses how feelings about race impact various aspects of society. It argues that these emotions are hurting our institutions and relationships.
  2. MacDonald points out that classical music is currently facing challenges because of politically charged decisions. Some believe they need to change the way they operate to survive.
  3. The issues raised in the book extend beyond music to areas like medicine and science, showing how extreme views can disrupt many important fields. It's an eye-opening look at a serious problem.

A Disturbing Lack of Faith

Disaffected Newsletter • 659 implied HN points • 06 Aug 23
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political Commentary Legal issues Mental health Cultural critique
  1. The legal actions against Trump are seen as extreme and unfair, based on opinions rather than real crimes.
  2. Sinéad O'Connor's passing highlights the struggles of those with Borderline Personality Disorder, showing the dual nature of her life as both a victim and a strong figure.
  3. Recent cultural events reflect tensions around gender and identity, with some individuals pushing back against current norms in schools and policing.

Spengler's Biography Part 1

The Oswald Spengler Project • 778 implied HN points • 04 Feb 23
💾 History Biography Intellectuals Literature World War I Cultural critique
  1. Oswald Spengler's childhood was marked by a contrasting influence from his parents - his father's duty-bound nature and his mother's artistic family background.
  2. Spengler was a bright child with a vivid imagination, but his intellectual pursuits conflicted with his father's expectations of a traditional career.
  3. After facing setbacks in academia and a disappointing teaching career, Spengler ventured into writing and achieved unexpected success with his controversial work, 'The Decline of the West.'

Feed experiences

Internal exile • 67 implied HN points • 02 Nov 24
🎶 Music Streaming Content creation Advertising Cultural critique Digital Platforms
  1. Many artists, like Catbreath, use clever tricks to get listens on streaming platforms. This shows how the music industry can sometimes reward unconventional strategies over traditional talent.
  2. Streaming services like Spotify may prioritize ads over genuine music experiences. This can lead listeners to rely on algorithms to pick their music, which might reduce their enjoyment and personal connection to songs.
  3. The rise of AI in content creation can lead to a lack of authentic experiences. Instead of meaningful interactions, people might just consume whatever the algorithms suggest, which can make everyone feel more isolated.

Matt Walsh did nothing wrong

Disaffected Newsletter • 1119 implied HN points • 19 Feb 23
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Media Social Issues Public Discourse Political Commentary Cultural critique
  1. Matt Walsh is expressing his views about a controversial figure and believes that sharing his honesty is valid and necessary.
  2. He emphasizes the importance of consistency when critiquing others' opinions, urging critics to apply the same standards to him.
  3. The writer stands firm in their belief that their messages are not excessive or unproductive, indicating a commitment to their viewpoint.

Designing for a single purpose

Product Identity • 118 implied HN points • 07 May 24
🪑 Design Product Design User Experience Branding Software Design Cultural critique
  1. Focusing on one clear purpose can make products stand out and be more appreciated. For example, stores or brands that specialize in a single item often attract loyal customers.
  2. In tech, many products have become complex and cluttered by trying to do too much. This often leads to products losing their original charm and purpose.
  3. Going back to basics and simplifying can bring more joy to experiences, like reading on a Kindle without distractions. It helps us focus on what truly matters.

And I'm not sorry

Disaffected Newsletter • 899 implied HN points • 27 Feb 23
🎭️ Culture Cultural critique Social Issues Gender Studies Media Analysis Public Discourse
  1. Some people feel upset about direct talk on tough issues. It's okay to speak your mind, even if it annoys others.
  2. There are mixed feelings around responsibility in relationships. Everyone should own their actions without blaming others.
  3. Sharing honest thoughts can sometimes lead to being seen as irrelevant. But staying true to your beliefs is important.

Meditations on Machinic Desire

Nothing Human • 57 implied HN points • 23 Oct 24
📖 Philosophy Existentialism Capitalism AI Ethics Addiction Cultural critique
  1. We are moving towards a future where artificial intelligence may surpass human intelligence, and it might happen gradually rather than suddenly. This means machines could take over many tasks we currently do without a clear turning point.
  2. The idea of capitalism is being explored as something that may harm our human nature. It could act like a virus that drives us to work endlessly for money, rather than for meaningful relationships or experiences.
  3. Our desires are becoming more virtual and less tied to reality. Instead of wanting real things, we often find ourselves chasing numbers or metrics, which can make us less happy even as society becomes more prosperous.

The real media crisis

Men Yell at Me • 151 implied HN points • 27 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Journalism Political Scandals Cultural critique Public Opinion
  1. There's a crisis in the media where younger journalists are seen as 'too soft' by some bosses. They feel that newer journalists don't have the same grit as before.
  2. The recent media issue from NY Mag didn't mention their own scandal, highlighting a lack of accountability in the industry.
  3. Many media leaders are using this moment to anonymously share their frustrations instead of addressing the larger issues.

The Trad Marxism of George Grant, Part 2

From the New World • 10 implied HN points • 03 Jan 25
📖 Philosophy Marxism Conservatism Theology Cultural critique
  1. George Grant blended traditionalism with Marxism, believing that while capitalism had improved life in some ways, it left a void in meaning and connection for many people.
  2. He thought that Marx's ideas offered a moral vision that could help explain social and economic issues, but felt that Marxism failed to embrace the spiritual aspect of life.
  3. Grant warned that society was becoming increasingly homogenized, with cultures and individual identities being overshadowed by impersonal economic systems.

Sunday Strip: The Free Market of Ideas

Who is Robert Malone • 31 implied HN points • 17 Nov 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political Commentary Public Opinion Social Issues Media influence Cultural critique
  1. The free market of ideas allows for many opinions and discussions to thrive. It's important to hear different views to understand complex issues better.
  2. Some believe that modern feminism has shifted focus from equality to unfair treatment of men. This change can create misunderstandings and conflicts in relationships.
  3. Engaging in conversations, like the one between Russell Brand and Robert Malone, helps spread various viewpoints. It's fun and insightful to share ideas and learn from one another.

⬜ The artists' philosopher, Byung-Chul Han

One Thing • 178 implied HN points • 07 Dec 23
📖 Philosophy Cultural critique Spirituality Eastern philosophy Identity
  1. Byung-Chul Han is a Korean-German philosopher known for his critical engagement with contemporary culture, including the concept of burnout culture.
  2. Han's work focuses on critiquing inauthentic forms of selfhood and the loss of negation and conflict dynamics in culture.
  3. Han advocates for seeking authenticity through a genuine re-engagement with the multitudinous shape of existence, emphasizing the power of saying no and achieving pure negativity.

The radical left has lost its moral compass

Heterodox STEM • 384 implied HN points • 29 Oct 23
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Ideology Social Issues Ethics Cultural critique
  1. Postmodernism and nihilism have influenced academic institutions, leading to moral relativism and a shift away from open inquiry and tolerance.
  2. The push for 'anti-racism' has sometimes resulted in discriminatory practices, undermining merit-based systems and educational opportunities.
  3. A call to challenge and openly debate harmful ideologies that have infiltrated academic institutions and to reaffirm the importance of objective truth and moral clarity.

A shockingly ignorant timeline

Sex and the State • 23 implied HN points • 06 Nov 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Feminism Social Issues Gender Politics Cultural critique
  1. People often ignore important issues, like what is happening in Russia. It's important to stay informed, even if it's uncomfortable.
  2. There’s a rise in anti-feminist ideas, like the 'tradwife' trend, which can be harmful. These views don't really support women's rights.
  3. Understanding these social trends helps us see the bigger picture. It’s crucial to think critically about what we see and believe.

Jimmy Carter's Obituary, but With Jokes

I Might Be Wrong • 7 implied HN points • 01 Jan 25
😂 Humor Satire Obituary Political Commentary Cultural critique
  1. Jimmy Carter lived a life full of unexpected twists, from growing up on a peanut farm to becoming president. It's a reminder that anyone can rise from humble beginnings.
  2. Carter's political journey shows how he adapted his goals over time, switching from naval ambitions to state politics and eventually the presidency.
  3. The humor in his life story serves to lighten serious topics, reminding us that laughter can coexist with important historical events.

Apocalypse, Revelation, Singularity

Daniel Pinchbeck’s Newsletter • 11 implied HN points • 15 Nov 24
📖 Philosophy Transhumanism Cultural critique Spirituality
  1. The idea of a technological Singularity suggests that machines might soon surpass human intelligence. This could change everything about our existence and how we interact with technology.
  2. Some believe that instead of fearing this future, we should find value in our current experiences and connections. Emphasizing the present can lead to a more fulfilling life than chasing after technological advances.
  3. Philosophers suggest that technology shouldn't dominate our lives. Instead, we should see it as a means to enhance our current reality and creativity, rather than a goal in itself.

Gilles Deleuze's Societies of Control

Castalia • 139 implied HN points • 06 Jul 23
📖 Philosophy Theory Existentialism Cultural critique Modernism
  1. Gilles Deleuze describes a shift from 'disciplinary societies,' which controlled individuals through strict boundaries, to 'societies of control,' where control is more fluid and ever-present. This means that instead of moving from one fixed environment to another, people are constantly being monitored and influenced.
  2. In societies of control, people never truly finish tasks; their work and identity are always intertwined. This blur of work and personal life can lead to stress and a feeling of never being able to disconnect.
  3. Deleuze suggests that in control societies, what's important isn't individual identity but rather the access one has, like passwords. Our personal information and identities are now tied to digital access, raising questions about autonomy and what it means to be an individual.

National Myths Old and New

Castalia • 159 implied HN points • 10 May 23
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics National Identity Historical Narratives Civic engagement Cultural critique
  1. There are two main stories about America's past: one celebrates its founding and achievements, while the other highlights its flaws like slavery and injustice. People seem to be divided between these two views.
  2. A new generation sees America's past as something that can be redeemed through acknowledging past wrongs and offering reparations. This idea focuses on healing and addressing the trauma of oppressed groups.
  3. America's role in the world is important, too. Instead of just looking at what happened inside the country, it's vital to recognize how it protects allies and maintains a certain type of order internationally, which can also shape positive patriotism.

New(ish) Books

Castalia • 159 implied HN points • 24 Apr 23
📚 Literature Book Reviews Fiction Non-fiction Cultural critique
  1. George Saunders is a talented writer, but there's concern that his style leads to flat, cartoonish characters in literature. Some believe this choice in writing makes stories feel less complex and lacks emotional depth.
  2. Susan Neiman critiques how the left has shifted from a focus on liberal universalism to a more victim-centered approach, suggesting that this change affects how power and justice are viewed in society.
  3. Neiman argues that the Enlightenment's values of reason and individual rights should be reclaimed, as she believes they can lead to a better understanding of justice, contrasting it with modern identitarianism that may neglect these principles.

Mutual Mistrust

Disaffected Newsletter • 319 implied HN points • 03 Jun 22
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Feminism Political Power Social Dynamics Cultural critique Identity politics
  1. There's a feeling of mistrust between different groups of people, like men and feminists. This mistrust often makes conversations difficult.
  2. Some feminists believe women only have power if they are equal to men in certain roles. However, many women hold power in cultural ways that might be overlooked.
  3. When men express their opinions, they can often be treated with condescendence by feminist women. This reaction reinforces the cycle of mutual mistrust.

Curator

Castalia • 119 implied HN points • 30 Mar 23
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Race relations Political Ideologies Cultural critique Media influence Historical Analysis
  1. Wokeness is seen by some as a call for a fresh start, especially within the Black community, moving away from past injustices towards a new political entity.
  2. Ernst Junger's writings highlight a fascination with death and a disdain for boring, comfortable living, linking militarism to a critique of modern society.
  3. A.O. Scott's retirement from film criticism signals changes in how movies are perceived, and the role of reviews in shaping art is being questioned as they affect creators deeply.

Tri-State Turmoil

Political Currents by Ross Barkan • 9 implied HN points • 18 Oct 24
📚 Literature Book Reviews Contemporary Fiction Cultural critique Author interviews Short Stories
  1. Michael Goodwin Hilton's short stories explore complex human relationships, often highlighting their emotional struggles in everyday life. The writing is both engaging and nuanced, making it a refreshing read.
  2. Tomiwa Owolade's book discusses race in the UK, arguing against American influences and emphasizing the unique context of Britain's racial dynamics. He believes in understanding the complexities of different racial identities and promoting an integrated society.
  3. Stuart M. Ross's novel dives into the chaotic life of Ty Rossberg, whose relationship issues lead him on a wild journey filled with absurdity and humor. The focus is on his personal struggles and the contrast with his partner's success.

My Vapid Generation

Castalia • 139 implied HN points • 15 Nov 22
🎭️ Culture Technology impact Social Commentary Media influence Cultural critique
  1. The internet changed how we communicate and share information, making it hard to escape its influence. People became obsessed with social media and online status, which reshaped our values and interactions.
  2. My generation was the first to really fall for these new technologies, often being too trusting and optimistic about their impact. As a result, we ended up being perfect subjects for this digital experiment.
  3. Looking back, we realize our lack of interest in history and important issues made us complacent. This led to an era where our choices and behaviors contributed to our own troubles in the digital world.

Artist Profile: Dena Yago, by Günseli Yalcinkaya

Do Not Research • 59 implied HN points • 23 Feb 23
🎨 Art & Illustration Visual art Art Theory Community Building Content creation Cultural critique
  1. Being an artist in the age of social media means navigating the intersection of art and commerce, where the artists' creations and online presence get quantified and exploited
  2. Collaborative platforms like Are.na and collectives like K-HOLE have been vital in forming connections and providing alternative spaces for artists to create and share their work
  3. Dena Yago's art explores complex societal issues through familiar cultural symbols, reflecting the challenges artists face in balancing commercial work, art practice, and navigating the gig economy

What Ava DuVernay’s “Origin” Gets Wrong

Journal of Free Black Thought • 41 implied HN points • 23 Feb 24
🎭️ Culture Social Issues Cultural critique
  1. Ava DuVernay's film 'Origin' focuses on a single story, overlooking complexities and nuances, emphasizing the danger of presenting a singular narrative.
  2. The portrayal of present-day oppression in 'Origin' ignores nuances in countries like India, painting a one-sided picture that does not capture the full reality.
  3. The film 'Origin' and the book it is based on, 'Caste,' fail to consider societal progress and depict a skewed view of racial prejudice, emphasizing the importance of understanding the complete context.