The hottest Historical Analysis Substack posts right now

And their main takeaways
Category
Top U.S. Politics Topics

Meditations On The Notion That Obama "Never Had Any Scandals"

Caitlin’s Newsletter • 2249 implied HN points • 20 Feb 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political Commentary Media Critique Public Perception Historical Analysis Government Accountability
  1. Barack Obama is often seen as scandal-free compared to other presidents, but this ignores serious actions he took that caused harm. Many people focus more on political feelings rather than real events.
  2. A lot of Americans don't recognize the destructive consequences of U.S. actions abroad, viewing them as problems only for other countries. This shows a disconnect from the reality of global issues.
  3. The media and social platforms shape our thoughts and beliefs, leading to a limited understanding of what's really happening. It’s important to question and think critically to have a clearer view of the world.

The leading AI models are now good historians

Res Obscura • 15240 implied HN points • 22 Jan 25
🕹 Technology AI Models Historical Analysis Generative AI Research Methods
  1. AI models are getting really good at history, especially in specific areas. They can help with tasks like translating old texts and offering historical context.
  2. While some people worry that AI tools lead to cheating in education, they can also enhance research efficiency. They help researchers to gather information and insights quickly.
  3. Despite AI's advancements, human creativity and understanding are still irreplaceable. There's a recognition that the unique human experience and thoughts are valuable and cannot be fully replicated by AI.

Fascism lives in the house capitalism built

Quid Amo • 857 implied HN points • 24 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political theory Historical Analysis
  1. Fascism is not a fixed idea; it changes over time. Understanding it requires looking at its history and how it adapts to new contexts.
  2. Fascism thrives in moments of crisis and often uses nostalgia to rally support. This means it can appeal to people's feelings about the past to gain power.
  3. Fascism isn't just something separate from capitalism; it's closely linked to it. It can be seen as a reaction to the flaws within capitalist societies, showing that both ideas can coexist.

1911-1943: Continued non-existence of legal provisions directing federal agencies to establish and enforce biological product definitions and standards.

Bailiwick News • 1783 implied HN points • 09 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Public Health Government funding Historical Analysis
  1. From 1911 to 1943, U.S. Congress didn't create laws to establish clear definitions or standards for biological products, like vaccines and toxins. This meant there were no guidelines for safety or labeling requirements.
  2. The 1902 Virus-Toxin Act only focused on the licensing of manufacturers, not the products themselves. This led to a lack of oversight on what was in those products and whether they were safe to use.
  3. Even with new regulations in later years, there was still confusion and gaps in laws about the safety and efficacy of biological products, allowing manufacturers to operate without strict requirements.

2,000-year-old wine and the uncanny immediacy of the past

Res Obscura • 5287 implied HN points • 15 Jan 25
💾 History Archaeology Artifacts Ancient Civilizations Cultural heritage Historical Analysis
  1. Ancient artifacts like the Carmona Wine Urn help us connect with the past. They remind us that people long ago lived lives similar to ours.
  2. Discoveries like the oldest known wine show how well-preserved objects can teach us about history. They tell us more than famous artworks or historical figures.
  3. Historical artifacts like the Pazyryk Rug and the Sword of Goujian highlight everyday life in the past. They help us imagine what it was like for ordinary people back then.
Get a weekly roundup of the best Substack posts, by hacker news affinity:

Chartbook 344: Curzio Malaparte's war

Chartbook • 1444 implied HN points • 12 Jan 25
📚 Literature Historical Analysis Literary Criticism Memoir
  1. Curzio Malaparte wrote three important books about World War II, with 'The Volga Rises in Europe' offering unique insights into the war's industrial aspects. It explains how both German and Soviet soldiers were more like technicians working with machines than traditional soldiers.
  2. Malaparte's other two books, 'Kaputt' and 'The Skin', depict the decay of European civilization during the war. They present a nightmarish view of society under conflict and how people struggled for survival in brutal circumstances.
  3. By reading all three works together, we see a broader picture of war's impact on humanity and morality. Each book provides a different perspective on the chaos and trauma of World War II, emphasizing the horrors faced by civilians and soldiers alike.

Book Review: The Rise Of Christianity

Astral Codex Ten • 27117 implied HN points • 12 Nov 24
📚 Literature Book review Religious Studies Historical Analysis Cultural Commentary Christianity
  1. Early Christianity grew slowly but steadily, with a strong growth rate mainly from interpersonal connections and participation in social networks, rather than just mass conversions or miracles.
  2. The appeal of Christianity, especially to women, played a key role in its spread, as it offered more rights and better treatment compared to pagan societies, leading to higher female engagement.
  3. Christians often cooperated during plagues, caring for the sick while pagans fled, which not only saved lives but showcased their moral values, drawing more people to their faith.

Chartbook 342 Are we all dead in the long run? John Maynard Keynes and the politics of time

Chartbook • 2617 implied HN points • 22 Dec 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Economic Theory Political theory Future studies Historical Analysis
  1. Keynes' famous quote 'In the long run we are all dead' is often misunderstood. It doesn't mean he didn't care about the future; instead, he criticized how some economists ignore present issues in favor of uncertain future predictions.
  2. Keynes saw the future as full of possibilities, suggesting we should focus on bold and significant plans that address current crises rather than worrying too much about long-term outcomes.
  3. He believed in experimentation and creativity in political action, encouraging open-ended approaches to solve today's problems while keeping an eye on the potential futures we can create together.

Civil War in MAGA World. Plus…

Common Sense with Bari Weiss • 1956 implied HN points • 30 Dec 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Immigration Political Discourse Legislation Political Identity Historical Analysis
  1. There is a big debate in the MAGA community about the H-1B visa program, which allows companies to hire skilled foreign workers. Some people support it because it helps tech companies find talent, while others think it harms American workers by lowering wages.
  2. The disagreement over this visa issue has stirred up uncomfortable racial sentiments, particularly against immigrants from countries like India. Some critics express openly racist views, suggesting that America should stay 'white European' despite its history as a nation of immigrants.
  3. Jimmy Carter, who recently passed away at 100, is remembered not just for his troubled presidency but also for his impactful post-presidential work, like building homes with Habitat for Humanity and promoting global health and democracy.

The Deep Roots of Irish Antisemitism

Common Sense with Bari Weiss • 1813 implied HN points • 17 Dec 24
🌍 World Politics International relations Antisemitism Middle East Human Rights Historical Analysis
  1. Ireland's criticism of Israel has grown significantly, becoming more intense than other countries, including some in the Arab world.
  2. The Israeli government decided to close its embassy in Ireland, citing the country’s extreme stance against Israel.
  3. The roots of Irish antisemitism are highlighted through personal family history and the historical context of Ireland's relationship with the Jewish community.

⚡️ When Jimmy Carter proposed his own DOGE

Faster, Please! • 731 implied HN points • 08 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Regulation Energy Policy Environmental Policy Historical Analysis
  1. Jimmy Carter's administration pushed for deregulation in industries like airlines and trucking to boost the economy. The goal was to make it easier for businesses to operate and compete.
  2. The Energy Mobilization Board was proposed to speed up energy project approvals, but it faced backlash from environmentalists and various interest groups. They were concerned it could weaken environmental protections.
  3. Carter's ideas for energy reform highlighted a struggle between meeting energy needs and protecting the environment. Ultimately, the board was rejected, showcasing the challenges of balancing these competing interests.

Devant la guerre

Global Inequality and More 3.0 • 1087 implied HN points • 05 Dec 24
🌍 World Politics International relations War Studies Historical Analysis Political theory Peace Studies
  1. E. H. Carr's book highlights how the international system can be unfair and lead to conflict. He sees similar patterns in past events and today's world.
  2. Carr argues that for peace to last, stronger nations need to share power and resources with weaker ones. If they don't, it creates resentment and can eventually lead to war.
  3. The current situation with Russia shows parallels to what happened with Germany before World War II. Both situations involved dissatisfied powers that used force to change their circumstances.

The Dawn of a New Civilization

Contemplations on the Tree of Woe • 7578 implied HN points • 08 Nov 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Elections Political theory Historical Analysis Civic engagement Societal Change
  1. The emergence of the Aenean civilization represents a shift from ambition-driven actions to thoughtful and cautious progress. This new mindset respects both history and the fragility of our future.
  2. Elon Musk's support for Donald Trump symbolizes a collaboration between futurism and populism, which aims to take humanity beyond Earth and face existential threats together.
  3. The Aenean spirit understands the importance of balancing dreams of exploration with the reality of potential risks. It seeks to ensure humanity's survival through deliberate actions rather than reckless pursuits.

Do you know? Is your county red or blue? Take a history tour!

COVID Reason • 118 implied HN points • 11 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political trends Voting Patterns Historical Analysis
  1. You can easily see how political views in different counties have changed over time. It's interesting to watch states like Florida and California shift from one political side to another.
  2. There’s a new tool that helps visualize these political trends at the county level, making it easier to understand local changes over the years.
  3. New members have a limited-time chance to access exclusive political insights and resources, which can help them stay informed about current events.

Why I Think Alexander Hamilton's Big Constitutional Convention Speech Is Worth Reading Today

Brad DeLong's Grasping Reality • 192 implied HN points • 17 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Constitution Democracy Governance Political theory Historical Analysis
  1. Hamilton's big speech at the Constitutional Convention is important because it shows his true thoughts on government and leadership. He believed in strong national leadership, even suggesting that Washington should be a monarch.
  2. Current political systems from the 1960s and even the founding era have not worked well, leading to frustration with both leftist and centrist politicians. There's a need for a better approach to ensure government truly reflects the people's needs.
  3. The discussion about democracy today often misses the point. It's not just about people expressing their views, but also about having representatives who really listen and act on those values.

Who speaks of the Armenians?

Wrong Side of History • 731 implied HN points • 19 Nov 24
🌍 World Politics International relations Conflict Studies Human Rights Historical Analysis Geopolitics
  1. The Armenian genocide in 1915-1917 is often overlooked, despite its horrific nature. Many Armenians fear that the hatred from that time still exists, leading to more violence.
  2. The conflict between Armenia and Azerbaijan has roots in historical tensions, but it intensified with recent wars over the Nagorno-Karabakh region. Many civilians have suffered and been forced to flee.
  3. Azerbaijan has significant oil and gas resources that influence its global relationships, often overshadowing its human rights abuses. Western countries continue to engage with Baku for energy supplies, ignoring its actions against Armenians.

The Fall of Democracy is a Markov Process

Maximum Effort, Minimum Reward • 383 implied HN points • 19 Dec 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political theory Government Systems Historical Analysis Democracy Governance
  1. Political systems can change between different types, like moving from democracy to tyranny. This pattern has been studied using historical data from ancient Greek city-states.
  2. The concept of 'anacyclosis' describes how governments can cycle through forms of rule, leading to predictable changes over time. It suggests that democracies can end up in tyrannical rule.
  3. Having a mix of government types can create stability. The Roman Republic is seen as an example of this mixed constitution, combining elements of democracy, aristocracy, and monarchy.

More on the Vibes Shift, Alexander the Great, Elderly Mobsters, and More

Richard Hanania's Newsletter • 1194 implied HN points • 30 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political Dynamics Government Policy Cultural critique Populism Historical Analysis
  1. The discovery of Propecia for hair loss came from studying children in the Dominican Republic who had unique genital characteristics. This led to the development of a drug that helps prevent hair loss by replicating a natural enzyme deficiency.
  2. In South Korea, older people are becoming involved in right-wing politics, similar to trends seen in the U.S. This shows how different generations can align politically for various reasons, often driven by fear or conspiracy beliefs.
  3. The shift in Silicon Valley regarding corporate power highlights that political influence often outweighs economic power. Companies can change their policies quickly under political pressure, showing that government authority is central to real power.

Thinking About Teaching Economic History to the First-Year Economic History Graduate Students This Forthcoming Semester

Brad DeLong's Grasping Reality • 199 implied HN points • 02 Jan 25
🚌 Education Economic History Teaching Methods Historical Analysis Economic Theory
  1. Economic history helps us understand how preferences and market structures formed over time. Looking back can show us why things are the way they are today.
  2. It's important for economics students to learn about the historical context of economic principles. This context can enrich their understanding and practical applications in the real world.
  3. Questions about past economies can shed light on current issues, like inequality and technology progress. Exploring these questions can lead to valuable insights for today's economists.

Catholic Integralists Versus America

Richard Hanania's Newsletter • 2608 implied HN points • 21 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political theory Religious Influence Nationalism Historical Analysis Cultural Identity
  1. America was founded on Enlightenment values that emphasized individual liberty and the separation of church and state, rather than being strictly a Christian nation, especially not a Catholic one.
  2. Recent Catholic nationalism contrasts sharply with historical American anti-Catholic sentiment, as many of today’s Catholic conservatives prioritize state intervention over individual freedoms.
  3. The rise of Catholic integralists in modern conservatism reflects a shift towards collectivist ideas that some believe could threaten the core values of American society.

New(ish) Books

Castalia • 539 implied HN points • 03 Jul 24
📚 Literature Book Reviews Fiction Non-fiction Cultural critique Historical Analysis
  1. Vinson Cunningham's _Great Expectations_ blends personal reflections and cultural commentary but lacks a clear story structure, leaving readers unsure of its purpose. The writing feels overdone at times, trying to impress rather than convey meaningful insights.
  2. Hugh Wilford's _The CIA: An Imperial History_ offers a comprehensive look at the CIA's role in American foreign policy, framing it as an imperial organization rather than a mere intelligence agency. It dives into the agency's history without dwelling on popular conspiracy theories, presenting a more nuanced view.
  3. Both authors highlight a disconnect between personal experiences and broader cultural narratives. Cunningham struggles to make his memories relevant, while Wilford presents the CIA's actions as complex but often poorly understood, emphasizing that there's more to uncover about the agency's true impact.

😨 How the Crisis Decade set the stage for an Up Wing 21st Century

Faster, Please! • 548 implied HN points • 28 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Policy Debate Economic Growth Technological progress Historical Analysis Future outlook
  1. The 2010s were tough due to a financial crisis and slow recovery, but they set the stage for future progress. People were worried about jobs and the economy, but good changes were coming.
  2. Despite the problems of the Crisis Decade, new technologies and ideas are emerging that can improve our future, like advancements in AI and space exploration. These are exciting challenges for policymakers to tackle.
  3. Many people felt hopeless during the 2010s, but this period showed that sometimes, after tough times, we can find a path to growth and opportunity. It's important to remember that there can be light after darkness.

The Power of the Charlatans; Maurizio Serra on Malaparte; Bidenomics; Zoë Hu on Andrew Tate

Unpopular Front • 38 implied HN points • 19 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political Commentary Influencers Biographies Economic Policy Historical Analysis
  1. There are many charlatans today who seem to gain respect, often promoting false ideas and oversimplified solutions. It's important to be aware of who we listen to.
  2. Grete de Francesco wrote a significant book about the dangers of charlatans and how they influence public opinion. Her insights show that charlatans take advantage of people's confusion during times of rapid change.
  3. De Francesco’s life story is also a tragedy; she was a talented journalist who was murdered in a concentration camp. Her work deserves to be remembered and reissued.

Social Theory for the Mid-21st Century: Part II. From -73000 to 2055: Malthusian Poverty to Modern Economic Growth

Brad DeLong's Grasping Reality • 269 implied HN points • 17 Nov 24
📖 Philosophy Social theory Economic Growth Technological Change Historical Analysis
  1. Throughout history, technological growth has drastically changed, particularly in the last 150 years. This period saw growth that's far beyond anything in earlier times.
  2. Today's society is much better off than before, with greater access to resources and technology. Most people have standards of living that are far superior compared to the past.
  3. Understanding our economic growth is complex. It's important to measure not just resources, but also how people work together and use ideas to improve life.

Contraptionist History Book Club

Breaking Smart • 56 implied HN points • 03 Jan 25
💾 History Book Club Historical Analysis
  1. There will be a monthly book club where participants can discuss history and related themes together. This is a fun way to explore interesting books.
  2. The subscription price for the newsletter will increase, but current subscribers can keep their old rate if they stay subscribed. This is to manage costs and encourage ongoing support.
  3. There is a contest where you can share photos of your work environment and a motto for the year. Winners can get free subscription months, making it a creative way to start the year.

What Happened to the Black-Jewish Alliance?

Glenn Loury • 1666 implied HN points • 17 Dec 23
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Race relations Historical Analysis Foreign Policy Nationalism Political Ideologies
  1. Black-Jewish alliance started strong but faced challenges over time, especially with disagreements over issues like affirmative action and Israel-Palestine.
  2. Historical tensions between Blacks and Jews stemmed from economic factors and differences in experiences of discrimination.
  3. Racially preferential policies, like affirmative action, deepened enmity between Black and Jewish communities by bringing to light symbolic and ideological differences.

The revolution will be organized by group chat

Jeff Giesea • 539 implied HN points • 29 Mar 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Social Change Digital Media Political theory Historical Analysis
  1. Group chats are powerful tools for change, similar to historical meeting places like coffee houses and salons. They allow people to connect and organize around common interests in real-time.
  2. Group Chat Theory suggests that important movements today will likely be coordinated through digital communication rather than just in-person meetings. This means that social and political changes can happen quicker and on a larger scale.
  3. While group chats can promote positive causes, they're also used for bad purposes. It's important to recognize that the same tools for good can be misused for harmful activities.

A Philosopher from the 1960s Knew All About Our Doomscrolling

OK Doomer • 104 implied HN points • 06 Dec 24
📖 Philosophy Ethics Existentialism Social Critique Historical Analysis Cultural Theory
  1. Doomscrolling is not just a bad habit; it's a way people try to understand threats and protect themselves. It's about getting the facts to feel in control.
  2. Telling people to stop doomscrolling or ignoring bad news isn't a good solution. It can actually make the problems worse by promoting toxic positivity.
  3. Historically, institutions have labeled undesirable behaviors as mental health problems, which often ignores the real issues. This creates stigma instead of solutions.

Christmas Mailbag - Questions Wanted!

Odds and Ends of History • 335 implied HN points • 10 Dec 24
💾 History Historical Events Cultural heritage Historical Figures Historical Analysis
  1. The author is looking for questions to include in a Christmas-themed Q&A post. People can submit their questions in the comments.
  2. There is an upcoming transport event in January, and tickets are selling quickly, so interested people should book soon.
  3. This post aims to engage the audience and encourage interaction through questions and event participation.

"Self Defense" is a Common Excuse for Genocide.

JoeWrote • 66 implied HN points • 17 Dec 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Genocide Self defense Historical Analysis Military Affairs Colonialism
  1. The concept of 'self-defense' is often misused to justify violent actions, including genocide. Many times, countries or groups claim they are protecting themselves while their actions actually harm innocent people.
  2. History shows that justifications for violence, like 'self-defense', have been used in various genocides, such as the Armenian Genocide and the Holocaust. These tragedies remind us that this reasoning can lead to horrific outcomes.
  3. It's important to question the narrative of self-defense when it leads to widespread harm. We should critically evaluate claims made by powerful entities and hold them accountable for their actions.

Should Women be in Combat Roles?

Erik Examines • 44 implied HN points • 09 Dec 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Military Policy Gender Equality Social Issues Historical Analysis Conflict resolution
  1. Women have historically been kept out of many fields due to false ideas about their abilities. This includes education, medicine, politics, and even the military.
  2. While there are biological differences between men and women, these differences don’t mean one gender is entirely superior. Each has unique strengths that can be valuable in different situations.
  3. Including women in the military can improve not just combat effectiveness but also peacekeeping efforts, as women often excel in social interactions and conflict de-escalation.

On regret: Two poets from two different centuries

Subtle Digressions • 99 implied HN points • 30 May 24
📚 Literature Poetry Creative Writing Artistic expression Historical Analysis
  1. Many people feel deep regret about not pursuing their creative passions as they reach the end of their lives. It's important to honor your creative urges and make time for them.
  2. According to poets Mary Oliver and Margaret Elizabeth Sangster, the regrets often come from things left undone rather than mistakes made. Missing opportunities can lead to heartache.
  3. Both poets highlight the emotional weight of unexpressed feelings and neglected connections. It’s a reminder to reach out and do the things that matter to us.

Interview with Constantin von Hoffmeister

The Oswald Spengler Project • 559 implied HN points • 21 Feb 23
📚 Literature Translation Historical Analysis Cultural criticism
  1. In his translations, Constantin corrected typos in the CFA translation of Spengler's work and kept a meticulous approach to ensure the translations did justice to the original texts.
  2. Spengler's work on 'Early Days of World History' introduces concepts like 'culture-amoebas' and explores the role of myth and religion in early civilizations, providing unique perspectives on the early history of human civilization.
  3. The interest in Spengler's works today is driven by his challenging views on the decline of Western civilization, the rise of authoritarianism, and his literary style that blends history, culture, and philosophy.

November 27, 2024

Letters from an American • 22 implied HN points • 28 Nov 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Civil Rights Historical Analysis American history Political Events
  1. Thanksgiving started as a shared celebration between Pilgrims and Indigenous people, but many stories about its origins have been forgotten over time.
  2. The holiday took on new meaning during the Civil War as President Lincoln encouraged Americans to give thanks while acknowledging the struggles of the country.
  3. Lincoln's thanksgivings were about uniting the nation and celebrating progress, including the end of slavery and a growing economy, even amid war.

Reading, Watching 10.27.24

Unpopular Front • 31 implied HN points • 27 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political Discourse Public Figures Historical Analysis Media Coverage
  1. The debate about fascism has moved from academics to politics, with notable figures openly calling Trump a fascist. This shows that such discussions are becoming more mainstream.
  2. Several high-ranking officials, including generals and former Trump staff, are expressing serious concerns about Trump's actions and their implications for democracy.
  3. Historian Robert Paxton is being highlighted for his views on Trump and fascism, indicating that experts are increasingly weighing in on these topics.

DRAFT: How Can We Deal wiþ Zombie Neoliberal Ideas?

Brad DeLong's Grasping Reality • 445 implied HN points • 26 Aug 23
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Neoliberalism Economic Policy Government intervention Political Ideologies Historical Analysis
  1. The text discusses the persistence of neoliberal ideas despite criticism.
  2. It emphasizes the importance of industrial policy in addressing societal challenges.
  3. The comparison between the Western market-focused approach and the developmental states of East Asia is highlighted.