The hottest Philosophy Substack posts right now

And their main takeaways
Category
Top Philosophy Topics

Beyond the Grade: "Everything Happens for A Reason." But What Does that Mean?

Humanities in Revolt β€’ 59 implied HN points β€’ 25 May 22
πŸ“– Philosophy Meaning of life Human experience Ethics Critical Thinking Beliefs
  1. Saying 'everything happens for a reason' can be vague and not add depth to discussions, as we are already aware of cause and effect.
  2. The phrase may imply larger forces at play, but without clarity on what these forces are, the statement remains ambiguous.
  3. The popularity of 'everything happens for a reason' may stem from our tendency to fill in unspecified reasons with personal beliefs, helping us cope with challenges.

You are astonishingly unique

inexactscience β€’ 19 implied HN points β€’ 27 Jul 23
πŸ“– Philosophy Existentialism Humanism Metaphysics Ontology Ethics
  1. Your existence is extremely rare and special. Every generation of your ancestors had to survive for you to be here today.
  2. The chances of your specific lineage and circumstances coming together are astronomically low. It's like winning a cosmic lottery.
  3. Everyone you meet is also incredibly unique. We are all part of a vast story of chance and choices that led to our existence.

Tiling the universe and 'simple' theories of wellbeing plus an update on my life

Philosophy bear β€’ 107 implied HN points β€’ 16 Jun 23
πŸ“– Philosophy Ethics Wellbeing Narrative
  1. Well-being theories based solely on desire satisfaction or pleasure may not fully capture what makes a life 'good'.
  2. Comparing universes with simple lives to complex lives highlights the importance of diversity, continuity, and relationships for overall well-being.
  3. Considering well-being as forming a coherent and positive narrative could provide a richer perspective than solely focusing on desire satisfaction or pleasure.
Get a weekly roundup of the best Substack posts, by hacker news affinity:

To see clearly with universal indifference

Meaningful Particulars β€’ 65 implied HN points β€’ 14 Feb 24
πŸ“– Philosophy Self Reality Love Justice Morality
  1. The ego, while well-meaning, often leads to negative emotions like fear, anxiety, and criticism by exaggerating threats that no longer exist.
  2. Eastern traditions suggest silencing the ego by giving up worldly desires, while Western traditions propose 'unselfing' to gain a clearer understanding of reality.
  3. Artists, unlike the Buddhist advice to detach, become deeply involved in their work, showing that greater participation and attachment to reality can lead to a clearer perspective beyond the self.

Uneasy Riders: Part One

Daniel Pinchbeck’s Newsletter β€’ 27 implied HN points β€’ 24 Nov 24
πŸ“– Philosophy Psychedelics Consciousness Reality Society
  1. Psychedelics might mix up our minds and reality, making it harder to understand what's really happening in the world. This confusion could lead to more personal and societal issues.
  2. While many people benefit from psychedelics at first, there's a worry about how widespread use can have negative effects over time. It may increase feelings of isolation and paranoia.
  3. The current state of the world and the psychedelic movement seem linked, and there needs to be more awareness about the potential downsides of this movement on society as a whole.

What happened four years ago feels more like four lifetimes ago, no?

Tessa Fights Robots β€’ 29 implied HN points β€’ 31 Oct 24
πŸ“– Philosophy Existentialism Ethics Metaphysics Freedom Self-awareness
  1. It's important to understand who you truly are and why you're here. Once you figure that out, the right actions will follow naturally.
  2. There’s a lot of noise in the world that seems important, but it often distracts us from what really matters. Focus on genuine love and connection instead of getting caught up in trends.
  3. Real change and understanding come from love and unity, not division or judgment. Emphasizing kindness can help break free from negative influences.

Box #4

What Is Called Thinking? β€’ 21 implied HN points β€’ 17 Jan 25
πŸ“– Philosophy Ethics Existentialism Metaphysics Mind Religion Aesthetics
  1. Being outraged online seems to be popular, even though it's not a nice feeling. People share outrage more than any other emotion, which might say a lot about our current social media habits.
  2. Our minds focus on what we find important, similar to how certain AI models operate. This brings to light how rituals and habits can shape our thinking and keep what matters most in our attention.
  3. There's a growing recognition that we all have a perspective on the future, even if we don't realize it. Discussions about technology and its impact hint at deeper societal issues that we need to consider.

This is the New Real World

Breaking Smart β€’ 83 implied HN points β€’ 17 Sep 23
πŸ“– Philosophy Reality Life Belief Morality Existence
  1. The 'real' world we live in is a collection of only a few dozen significant worlds that shape our lives.
  2. Not all individual worlds are consequential in shaping the real world - only a few hundred are significant.
  3. The real world is not necessarily more real than private fantasies, but it is vastly more consequential.

Why the Principle of Sufficient Reason is Self-Evident and its Criticisms are Self-Defeating

Ethics Under Construction β€’ 20 implied HN points β€’ 01 Feb 25
πŸ“– Philosophy Logic Existence Truth Reason Knowledge Determinism
  1. The Principle of Sufficient Reason (PSR) states that everything has a reason for existing. It means for every fact, there's an explanation behind it.
  2. Critics of the PSR often make self-defeating arguments because they need reasons to argue against it. Thus, denying the PSR actually supports its validity.
  3. PSR is important for understanding the world and making sense of knowledge. It encourages us to seek underlying reasons rather than accept things as random.

Mapping the analogy of institutions as organisms (1)

Space chimp life β€’ 1 HN point β€’ 23 Jul 24
πŸ“– Philosophy Metaphysics Epistemology Systems Thinking
  1. Institutions can act like living organisms, but they don't fit neatly into that analogy because humans can belong to multiple institutions and change roles often. This shows that people aren't static and can adapt in many ways.
  2. The way institutions operate can be better understood through concepts from thermodynamics and statistics. This means they can change how they function based on rules and roles assigned to their members, similar to how particles behave in biology.
  3. Institutions perceive the world through their policies and data, rather than physical objects alone. What they 'see' influences their actions and decisions, just like biological organisms react to their environment based on internal processes.

Relinquishing control

Random Minds by Katherine Brodsky β€’ 84 implied HN points β€’ 10 Sep 23
πŸ“– Philosophy Human nature Critical Thinking Ethics Values Leadership
  1. Relinquishing control can lead to blind compliance, which has historically resulted in significant atrocities.
  2. Human nature inclines people to seek charismatic leaders, but it's important to maintain personal identity and critical thinking.
  3. To resist manipulation, individuals should develop critical thinking skills, recognize psychological manipulation tactics, and build independence.

Abundance vs Scarcity Mindset

Perspectives β€’ 8 implied HN points β€’ 10 Jul 25
πŸ“– Philosophy Mindset Self-help Personal Growth Leadership Coaching
  1. An abundance mindset looks for opportunities instead of focusing on what's lacking. It helps you see possibilities where others see limitations.
  2. Creating win-win situations benefits everyone involved. Sharing resources and support can lead to greater success for all, not just for one individual.
  3. Seeing potential in others and believing in their capabilities can transform relationships. By lifting each other up, we all can thrive together.

"BαΊ©n thỉu vΓ  mαΊ₯t dαΊ‘y"

ThΓ‘i | Hacker | Kα»Ή sΖ° tin tαΊ·c β€’ 179 implied HN points β€’ 10 Aug 20
πŸ“– Philosophy Debate Learning Reflection
  1. When engaging in debates, focus on understanding the other person rather than attacking them. It's an opportunity to learn and correct mistakes.
  2. The attitude you bring to a debate influences the outcome. Debating to win might not lead to real learning, while debating to learn can lead to personal growth.
  3. Success in a debate isn't just about winning arguments; it's about being open to learning and improving by acknowledging mistakes.

Box #7

What Is Called Thinking? β€’ 18 implied HN points β€’ 14 Feb 25
πŸ“– Philosophy Existentialism Theology Mind Ethics Literature
  1. Expertise is not just about having more knowledge; it's about knowing how to organize that knowledge effectively, a skill known as chunking.
  2. As software development becomes easier for AI, university professors need to prove why their teaching is still valuable or risk being replaced by technology.
  3. Finding deeper meaning in life is important; comfort and ease can lead to a lack of purpose, so striving for something greater is crucial.

"Just Tell Me What To Do"

Living Fossils β€’ 26 implied HN points β€’ 13 Nov 24
πŸ“– Philosophy Existentialism Decision-making Cultural Commentary Mental health
  1. Many people today feel overwhelmed by choices and just want someone to guide them. This need comes from the stress of having to make so many decisions in life.
  2. Science provides clear and accurate answers but often lacks comforting explanations for big life questions. This can leave people feeling lost and spiritually empty.
  3. We’re seeing a shift in how society shares values and norms, leading to individualism. This makes it hard for people to know the right choices, causing them to seek external guidance.

A general argument for the left

Philosophy bear β€’ 85 implied HN points β€’ 24 Aug 23
πŸ“– Philosophy Political Ideologies Ethics Social Issues Utilitarianism
  1. The main challenge is the significant polarization in politics, raising a question of reliability of conflicting propositions from different sides.
  2. Historically, movements favoring the weak have been vindicated, indicating a common theme of standing up for underdogs.
  3. Utilitarian perspective suggests prioritizing the needs of the weak over the strong for a greater good.

The Cave of Consensus is Collapsing

What's Important? β€’ 20 implied HN points β€’ 29 Jan 25
πŸ“– Philosophy Consciousness Spirituality Wisdom Reality Transformation
  1. The Cave of Consensus is where we learn common knowledge safely. However, focusing only on known facts can limit our growth.
  2. Outside this cave lies the Cavern of Consciousness, where we explore deeper topics like spirituality and the unknown. This space can be intimidating but also incredibly transformative.
  3. Leaving the Cave allows us to see everything differently and tap into our creativity. It's a space full of potential and freedom, unlike the restrictions of the Cave.

The Phenomenological Statespace

Through the Looking Glass β€’ 2 HN points β€’ 12 Jun 24
πŸ“– Philosophy Consciousness Reality Experience Imagination Exploration
  1. William James proposed two types of consciousness: rational waking and a 'special' hidden consciousness.
  2. The Phenomenological Statespace (TPS) represents all possible brain activations unique to an individual, crucial for exploring consciousness.
  3. Exploration of consciousness can occur through means like dreams, movies, hallucinogens, travel, and music.

The Uterine Lottery

Polymathic Being β€’ 66 implied HN points β€’ 03 Dec 23
πŸ“– Philosophy Evolutionary biology Economics Geopolitics Sociology
  1. Our existence is not entirely random; it is influenced by mate selection, education, health, and life decisions passed down through generations.
  2. Economic and geopolitical factors contribute to inequality, with the Pareto Principle indicating that a small percentage holds a majority of wealth and success.
  3. Sociological structures, traditions, and decisions made by our ancestors play a significant role in shaping who we are today.

A Short Reflection on Examining

Theory Matters β€’ 1 implied HN point β€’ 02 Jan 26
πŸ“– Philosophy Ethics Epistemology Political Philosophy Existentialism Philosophy of Mind
  1. Self-examination is important for growth and moral improvement, pushing us to question life instead of passively accepting it.
  2. Easy shortcuts to knowledgeβ€”like AI, quick videos, and the internetβ€”can undermine deep contemplation and make us intellectually and emotionally poorer while also spreading shallow or false ideas.
  3. Too much introspection can be paralyzing, so we need a balance that preserves the difficult work of learning and meaning without falling into harmful overthinking.

Is Reality Mental?

Daniel Pinchbeck’s Newsletter β€’ 10 implied HN points β€’ 25 May 25
πŸ“– Philosophy Consciousness Metaphysics Idealism Psychedelics Quantum physics
  1. Consciousness might be the most important part of existence, not just something our brains make. This changes how we see reality.
  2. The old view of the universe being random and lifeless doesn't explain how we feel and experience life. We need a new way to understand what reality truly is.
  3. Many new studies and ideas support the thought that consciousness isn't just from our brains, but something bigger we all tap into. This could help us understand life and death better.

Fifty-four ideas from a philosophical bear

Philosophy bear β€’ 78 implied HN points β€’ 20 Aug 23
πŸ“– Philosophy Ethics Metaethics Politics Concepts Society
  1. Cringe culture can lead us to make misguided choices based on avoiding embarrassment.
  2. In philosophy, exploring wild and speculative ideas can lead to significant contributions and should be encouraged.
  3. The dynamics between white-collar and blue-collar jobs may shift with advancements in AI, impacting societal connections and values.

The Paradox of Choice

Integrity Talk β€’ 99 implied HN points β€’ 29 Mar 23
πŸ“– Philosophy Decision-making Self-reflection
  1. Personal goals have evolved along with societal changes and technologies.
  2. Despite a wide array of choices, human motives for pursuing goals remain consistent over time.
  3. Excessive choices can lead to difficulty in decision-making and a tendency to prioritize social desirability over personal values.

Every Mantra has a Counter-Mantra

Olshansky's Newsletter β€’ 22 implied HN points β€’ 02 Dec 24
πŸ“– Philosophy Life lessons Self-reflection Problem Solving Advice
  1. Every mantra has a counter-mantra, meaning there's always an opposing idea that can offer balance or a different perspective. It's important to remember this when you take advice or hear a popular saying.
  2. Mantras can be viewed as tools rather than strict rules. Just like you wouldn't use a hammer for everything, you shouldn't apply every piece of advice to every situation.
  3. Finding balance in life is not about sticking to one mantra but understanding that different situations may require different approaches or mindsets. It's all about using the right tool at the right time.

When No One Can Work, What Will We Do?

Tessa Fights Robots β€’ 87 implied HN points β€’ 31 May 23
πŸ“– Philosophy Predictions Challenges Healing Spirituality Existence
  1. The decline in physical health and cognitive ability may impact the way we work and function in society.
  2. There is a concern about the increasing toxicity in physical and spiritual health, leading to potential long-term consequences.
  3. Despite challenges and predictions, finding love and healing can help us navigate through difficult times.

illusory expertise

Midnight Musings β€’ 39 implied HN points β€’ 05 Dec 22
πŸ“– Philosophy Self-reflection Knowledge Confidence Human behavior Cognitive Biases
  1. People often think they know more than they really do, which is called the Dunning-Kruger effect. This means we can be really confident but also very clueless at the same time.
  2. It's common to focus on sharing our opinions rather than listening to others. This can lead to misunderstandings and make it harder to work together and empathize with different viewpoints.
  3. Knowledge comes in two types: explicit (things you can easily write down) and tacit (things learned through experience). True understanding requires experience, not just knowing facts.

Fragments, Chapter 7, pp.116-20 - Reading Club posting 22

Journal of Gurdjieff Studies β€’ 19 implied HN points β€’ 17 Feb 23
πŸ“– Philosophy Consciousness Self-awareness Reality Existence Mind-Body Connection
  1. Consciousness is a property that changes, not always present, with different degrees and levels, challenging to define scientifically or philosophically.
  2. Self-remembering is emphasized as a crucial aspect of self-observation, where individuals need to actively remember themselves to truly observe and understand their actions.
  3. Dividing attention between observing external phenomena and focusing on oneself, known as self-remembering, leads to unique sensations and enhanced perception, unlocking rare experiences in everyday life.