The hottest Nationalism Substack posts right now

And their main takeaways
Category
Top World Politics Topics

Chartbook 353 How Munich got Maga-ed, or Vance, bull**** & the European furore.

Chartbook • 4306 implied HN points • 16 Feb 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Nationalism Populism Security Immigration Political parties
  1. MAGA politics often come off as confusing and illogical, but they do pose a real threat. Leaders like J.D. Vance play on nationalistic ideas, creating divisions rather than solving actual problems.
  2. Europe's relationship with the U.S. is strained, especially after Vance's speech at the Munich Conference. Many Europeans feel they might have to treat the U.S. as a foreign country due to these differences in political style and values.
  3. For Europe to dismiss radical right-wing ideas effectively, it needs to develop its own security strategies. Relying solely on American support could backfire and bring MAGA-style politics into European conversations.

No, you are not on Indigenous land

Noahpinion • 106119 implied HN points • 30 Nov 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Ethnicity Nationalism Social justice
  1. Land ownership is complicated and often involves historical conquests, meaning most land has been taken and reclaimed many times throughout history.
  2. Assigning land ownership based on race or ethnic groups might create more conflict rather than solve past injustices. Instead, citizenship and belonging should be based on institutions, not ethnicity.
  3. Supporting Native American tribes today means respecting their modern institutions and allowing them autonomy in developing their land rather than just acknowledging past grievances.

What the Right Kind of Nationalism Sounds Like.

Breaking the News • 2206 implied HN points • 02 Feb 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Leadership Nationalism Trade policy International relations
  1. Leadership requires addressing national interests clearly and passionately. Trudeau spoke strongly about the importance of Canada and the negative effects of trade wars.
  2. Effective communication is about explaining complex issues without being rude. Trudeau made sure his American audience understood the consequences of tariffs without sounding threatening.
  3. National pride can be expressed in a respectful way. Trudeau delivered a firm message about Canada’s values and partnerships while emphasizing that the country would stand up for itself.

Fault Lines

Comment is Freed • 78 implied HN points • 27 Feb 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Conservative movement Global Politics Nationalism Authoritarianism
  1. The CPAC event has evolved into a global gathering for right-wing leaders, with participants from many countries, showing a rise in nationalist movements worldwide.
  2. Tension is growing between moderate and extreme factions within the right-wing movement, as seen with the response to controversial gestures and ideology.
  3. Right-wing parties in Western Europe face challenges in balancing their base and broader electorate, which could lead to splits and conflicts within their ranks.

What’s Really Wrong With Anti-Immigrants

Bet On It • 322 implied HN points • 17 Feb 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Immigration Racism Xenophobia Nationalism
  1. A lot of anti-immigration feelings come from xenophobia, which is a fear or dislike of foreigners. Many people seem to think negatively about immigrants without clear reasons.
  2. Another factor in anti-immigrant sentiment is misanthropy, or a general dislike of humanity. Some people view most humans as not worth having around, which colors their views on immigrants.
  3. Racism plays a smaller role than often believed. Many anti-immigrants don’t express clear racial biases, and their opposition is more about a negative view of people in general than about race.
Get a weekly roundup of the best Substack posts, by hacker news affinity:

Trumpers Are Not Entitled to Respect

Erik Examines • 1209 implied HN points • 14 Feb 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Politics Trumpism Nationalism Empathy
  1. Respect has to be earned, and many MAGA supporters haven't done that. They often act disrespectfully towards others but expect respect in return.
  2. There is a double standard where MAGA supporters don't recognize their own harmful statements. They can insult others but get upset when the same is done to them.
  3. Freedom is often misinterpreted. For some, it means the freedom to dominate others instead of true liberty for everyone.

“To the Finland Station”

Global Inequality and More 3.0 • 2627 implied HN points • 07 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Nationalism Neoliberalism Inequality History Ideology Trump
  1. The post suggests that Trump represents a shift away from global neoliberalism, which dominated since the 1980s. It argues that this new ideology is still taking shape and its full impact won't be clear for years.
  2. Neoliberalism is criticized for creating wealth inequality and pretending to support equality while actually benefiting a ruling class. It is seen as a false promise that is now coming to an end.
  3. The new political landscape might resemble 'global Caesarism,' which may keep lower classes content with limited political participation while benefiting elites. This approach is different from traditional political parties and appears to offer fresh cynicism.

Does America Require an "Anglo-Protestant" Majority?

Glenn Loury • 515 implied HN points • 15 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Immigration Demographics Cultural Identity Political Philosophy Nationalism
  1. Some believe that America needs an 'Anglo-Protestant' majority to maintain its success and values, arguing that this group historically shaped the nation.
  2. Immigrants often come to America for its opportunities and quality of life, and there's skepticism about the idea that they would change the culture negatively once they arrive.
  3. There is a debate about how important a dominant culture is for national stability, with some suggesting that laws and institutions play a larger role than the ethnic or cultural origins of the people.

Germany’s Neglect of National Interests

Glenn’s Substack • 939 implied HN points • 10 Sep 24
🌍 World Politics Nationalism International relations European Politics Security Studies Political theory
  1. Germany's current approach to foreign policy often neglects its own national interests, which could lead to negative consequences for the country.
  2. There is a historical pattern of Germany sacrificing its interests for external powers, similar to its past under France and now the US.
  3. A rise in nationalism may occur as a reaction to this neglect, with people seeking to reclaim control over their national identity and sovereignty.

The War Film That Turned Dietrich Bonhoeffer Away From Nationalism

The Take (by Jon Miltimore) • 237 implied HN points • 10 Oct 24
💾 History War Nationalism Theology Cinema
  1. Dietrich Bonhoeffer changed his views on nationalism after watching the antiwar film 'All Quiet on the Western Front.' It made him see the harsh realities of war and question the idea that fighting for one's country is a noble cause.
  2. Alongside a French theologian, Bonhoeffer felt sad and moved by a scene where a German soldier comforts a dying French soldier. This moment helped him understand the deep connections between people, beyond national borders.
  3. Bonhoeffer believed that being a Christian should come before national loyalty. He saw nationalism as a dangerous idea that could harm human values, showing that real bravery means standing up against harmful beliefs, not just fighting in wars.

To be young, perchance to dream

Global Inequality and More 3.0 • 951 implied HN points • 28 Dec 24
💾 History Political History Cultural History Economic History Social movements Nationalism
  1. The historical view of the assassination in Sarajevo changed over time depending on political climates. Initially, it was seen as justified but later viewed negatively as political perspectives shifted.
  2. The Young Bosnia movement was driven by a mix of national unity desires and social injustices. Many members came from impoverished backgrounds and sought change, inspired by various revolutionary ideas.
  3. Literature and poetry significantly influenced the Young Bosnia activists. They saw themselves as heroes and believed in dramatic actions because they felt the political system was against them.

Nationalists Already Have the World They Want but Need to Pretend Otherwise

Richard Hanania's Newsletter • 3706 implied HN points • 07 Feb 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Nationalism Foreign Aid Immigration Public Policy Political Discourse
  1. Nationalists often claim that the U.S. government prioritizes foreigners over citizens, but the reality shows that a tiny percentage of the federal budget actually goes to foreign aid. Most funds are directed towards helping American citizens.
  2. Even though nationalists argue for policies that benefit Americans, they often ignore facts about how much the government already does for its own people. This leads to misconceptions about foreign aid and immigration.
  3. The nationalist mindset may come from a tribal instinct, where they feel the need to show loyalty to their group. However, this can make them overlook the good that comes from global connections and shared interests.

Defeat Racism by Heightening the Contradictions

Richard Hanania's Newsletter • 3706 implied HN points • 17 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Racism Nationalism Far-right Identity politics Social Issues
  1. There are two types of people in white nationalist groups: some are smarter and focus on ideas, while others are just angry and uneducated. This creates a conflict in their beliefs.
  2. A lot of the smart people might avoid extremist groups because they don’t want to associate with those who have more basic racist views. They care about progress and quality.
  3. Talking about these contradictions can help people see that there are better ideas out there. Engaging with their views might not win over everyone, but it can show some there's no future in extreme identity politics.

SITREP 1/28/24: US Troops Suffer Fatalities in Strikes as Escalation Grows

Simplicius's Garden of Knowledge • 10791 implied HN points • 29 Jan 24
🌍 World Politics Warfare Geopolitics Diplomacy Nationalism
  1. US troops suffered fatalities in strikes, highlighting escalation tensions.
  2. Confusion arises about the location of the troop fatalities, raising questions about US involvement in the region.
  3. Potential for a major conflict or withdrawal in the Middle East, with significant implications for the US and global economy.

An uncivil civil war

Wood From Eden • 2016 implied HN points • 04 Nov 24
💾 History Civil War Political Conflict Cultural History Social movements Nationalism
  1. Civil wars often have deep political or ideological divides. In Finland's case, it was the working class versus the upper class, which led to a very intense conflict over power.
  2. The formation of armed groups was crucial in the lead-up to the Finnish Civil War. Both the workers and the upper class created their own forces, which escalated tensions.
  3. Post-war, Finland struggled with the aftermath of the violence but eventually unified. A process of reflection and an amnesty helped rebuild society despite longstanding divisions.

Blood and Soil

KERFUFFLE • 57 implied HN points • 02 Feb 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Nationalism Identity Culture History Right-wing
  1. Many people today feel a loss of connection and trust in their communities. This feeling of dislocation has led some to seek meaning and identity in traditional or nationalistic roots.
  2. The idea of America as just an abstract idea is fading. More people are starting to see it as a nation with a shared culture and history.
  3. The current political movements often focus on identities that divide rather than unite. There is a need for a renewed sense of national identity that brings people together instead.

Chartbook 338 You don’t exit the force field, you alter your position within it.

Chartbook • 700 implied HN points • 11 Dec 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Economic Policy Nationalism Global Trade Political Response Market Reaction
  1. You can't just leave a difficult situation; you have to find a better way to deal with it. This means finding a new position or approach within the existing challenges.
  2. Different countries react differently to major events, like Brexit or Trump's policies, reflecting their unique economic power roles. For instance, when news breaks, some currencies soar while others crash based on local reactions.
  3. The way countries negotiate and manage their economic rules greatly impacts reform efforts. A left-leaning government in the U.S. or elsewhere would face specific challenges shaped by these dynamics.

The Real Enemy

Dana Blankenhorn: Facing the Future • 79 implied HN points • 11 Oct 24
🌞 Climate & Environment Global Warming Nationalism Political polarization International cooperation
  1. Nationalism is a big problem for addressing climate change. It stops countries from working together and tackling the urgent issue of global warming.
  2. People are often focused on their own countries and ignore the need for cooperation. This 'mine' vs 'ours' mindset won’t help solve climate issues.
  3. For real change to happen, everyone needs to unite and fight against climate change together. Without that, the planet will keep suffering.

Colonization, Replaceable Man, and Love of One’s Own

The Upheaval • 1852 implied HN points • 11 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Nationalism Colonialism Cultural Identity Populism Migration
  1. Colonization changes how people see themselves and their culture. It often leads to a loss of national identity and local traditions.
  2. Modern society is experiencing a kind of self-colonization driven by globalization. People and cultures are treated more like replaceable cogs than unique communities.
  3. Nationalism is rising as people respond to the loss of their identity. Many are now striving to take pride in their own culture and seek to protect it.

This is Zion

Freddie deBoer • 8663 implied HN points • 23 Feb 24
🌍 World Politics Israel-Palestine conflict Nationalism Immigration Anti-Semitism
  1. The United States is considered a place of safety and prosperity for Jews, and some argue that it could be a better home for them than Israel.
  2. Critics of Jewish nationalism suggest that Israel's reliance on American support raises questions about its long-term viability.
  3. Encouraging Jewish immigration to the United States as an alternative to Israel is proposed as a solution for Jewish safety and success.

Leaving behind the history written in letters of blood

Wrong Side of History • 275 implied HN points • 23 Dec 24
💾 History European history Nationalism Immigration Philosophy Ethics
  1. European society changed a lot after World War II, and old ideas of guilt and hospitality mixed with a new horror from the war. This shift influenced how people thought about nationalism and morality.
  2. People became very afraid of nationalism after the war, often going too far in pushing it away, which made them overlook other important values like order and liberty.
  3. There is a strong belief among European elites that immigration is always a good thing, even if the reasons they give can be confusing. This ideology has become common in their discussions.

Dispatches from the Group Chats, Vol 4

Erik Torenberg's Thoughts • 195 implied HN points • 30 Dec 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Immigration Policy Cultural Discourse Political alliances Nationalism
  1. There's a growing divide between tech supporters and nationalists regarding immigration. Some want to reform H1B visas while others feel the whole system is unfair.
  2. Many believe America is defined by its people and shared history, not just by ideas. This leads to different views on who should be considered 'American'.
  3. The pressures of culture and values clash here, showing that while some want a welcoming environment for immigrants, others feel it complicates their own identity and opportunities.

Jen Gerson: The immigration consensus is collapsing

The Line • 3439 implied HN points • 18 Jan 24
🌍 World Politics Immigration Conservatives Nationalism Multiculturalism Identity
  1. The consensus on immigration in Canada is shifting due to economic stress, housing issues, and health-care system challenges.
  2. Polls show a significant portion of Canadians believe immigration levels are too high, leading to a cross-partisan consensus on the need for change.
  3. The conversation around immigration in Canada involves addressing the effects on national identity, culture, and the potential for generational economic inequality.

Catholic Integralists Versus America

Richard Hanania's Newsletter • 2608 implied HN points • 21 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political theory Religious Influence Nationalism Historical Analysis Cultural Identity
  1. America was founded on Enlightenment values that emphasized individual liberty and the separation of church and state, rather than being strictly a Christian nation, especially not a Catholic one.
  2. Recent Catholic nationalism contrasts sharply with historical American anti-Catholic sentiment, as many of today’s Catholic conservatives prioritize state intervention over individual freedoms.
  3. The rise of Catholic integralists in modern conservatism reflects a shift towards collectivist ideas that some believe could threaten the core values of American society.

On the Tory Cult of Personality and its Consequences

Wrong Side of History • 322 implied HN points • 06 Dec 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Immigration Policy Political culture Nationalism Election Analysis
  1. The UK implemented open borders, which some believe was planned rather than accidental. Brexit provided a reason to change immigration policies.
  2. The previous government's approach to immigration seemed to be based on short-term goals and a belief that immigration was positive.
  3. Boris Johnson's leadership style appeared to be influenced by a desire for approval from elite groups, rather than focusing on nationalist policies.

Will Belgium become Europe's next hard-right government?

Gulf Stream Blues • 19 implied HN points • 18 Oct 24
🌍 World Politics Political Systems European Politics Federalism Nationalism
  1. Belgium is experiencing a rise in far-right politics, similar to trends in Italy and the Netherlands. This means more far-right parties could gain power in Europe.
  2. The New Flemish Alliance (N-VA) has been the largest party in Belgium for years, advocating for more regional control and less federal influence. They want a system where regions manage their own taxes.
  3. Belgium's complicated political system is affecting its unity, with ongoing debates about taxation and regional independence. Many believe the country functions more like separate states instead of a united nation.

A Requiem For Ba'athism (Part 3 of 3)

Fisted by Foucault • 60 implied HN points • 26 Jan 25
🌍 World Politics Geopolitics Nationalism Conflict Identity Ideology History
  1. Ba'athism, meant to unite Arabs, failed because tribal identities are stronger than national ones in many regions. People often identify more with their local tribes than a broader Arab identity.
  2. Religious differences present another challenge, as the intertwining of state and religion makes it hard for diverse groups to bond over a single national identity. This creates conflict among different confessions.
  3. The struggle for Ba'athist leadership between Syria and Iraq shows how internal divisions, personality clashes, and tribal loyalties made it difficult to create a unified movement in the Arab world.

Conservatism’s Path Not Taken

Persuasion • 2731 implied HN points • 10 Jan 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Conservatism Nationalism Liberalism Foreign Policy
  1. Conservatism has two main competing ideologies: Fusionism and National Conservatism.
  2. National Conservatives risk bureaucratic tyranny and extremism, while Fusionists have economic successes but cause societal divisions.
  3. Humanist Conservatism offers a moderate, inclusive, and community-focused alternative to the existing conservative schools.

America First! Privatizing FEMA Will Kill Americans, But At Least the Hurricanes Will Have Patriotic Names.

JoeWrote • 68 implied HN points • 28 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political theory Nationalism Disaster relief Government Policy
  1. Nationalism can trick people into thinking they have more in common with wealthy Americans than with workers from other countries. This can stop them from standing together for better working conditions.
  2. Privatizing FEMA could lead to worse disaster relief because profit motives might take priority over helping people. This means less support for those who need it during crises.
  3. Many working-class voters may not realize that they could suffer more from political decisions like privatization. They need to focus on class issues instead of being distracted by patriotic symbols.

My view on Putin Tucker interview: I see a man Putin who loves his nation like how Trump loves America, as simple as that to start; I admire Putin, we always be guarded, but Russia is NOT our enemy

Alexander News Network -Dr. Paul Elias Alexander's substack • 1592 implied HN points • 09 Feb 24
🌍 World Politics Leaders Relations Nationalism Borders
  1. Putin loves Russia like Trump loves America; Russia is not our enemy.
  2. Both Putin and Tucker advocate for secure borders.
  3. Discussions around Ukraine and bioresearch facilities involve prominent figures like Hunter Biden, Jeffrey Epstein, and others.

The Great MAGA Immigration Meltdown

Unpopular Front • 93 implied HN points • 29 Dec 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Immigration Economic Policy Nationalism Racism
  1. The H-1B visa program ties workers to their jobs, making it hard for them to leave and seek better opportunities, which some compare to indentured servitude.
  2. The current debate about immigration among Trump supporters isn't just about policy; it's linked to deeper beliefs about race and who should get priority in the workforce.
  3. There are two contrasting views on how to approach immigration: one sees it as a way to foster fair economic competition and freedom, while the other focuses on grabbing a select group of skilled workers based on racialized criteria.

It's Jean-Marie's World, We're Just Living In It

Unpopular Front • 56 implied HN points • 08 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Populism Nationalism Political Movements Political History Xenophobia
  1. Jean-Marie Le Pen's passing may seem like a relief, but his far-right ideas have become more mainstream through his daughter's leadership.
  2. Le Pen's style of politics, which focuses on populism and scapegoating immigrants, has influenced other global leaders, including Trump.
  3. The rise of national populism weakens traditional democratic values and promotes division based on race and nationality.

Trump persuades British Tories to betray their country

Writing from London • 1179 implied HN points • 27 Jan 24
🌍 World Politics Security Conservatives Nationalism Extremism Geopolitics
  1. Donald Trump is seen as a threat to European security by some, especially due to his influence on Republicans' actions related to aid to Ukraine
  2. Some British Conservatives are prioritizing their hatred of progressives over national security concerns, leading to support for Trump
  3. There is concern that the right-wing betrayal and alignment with Trump may lead to consequences similar to the left's fate in the 1980s regarding national security

What Happened to the Black-Jewish Alliance?

Glenn Loury • 1666 implied HN points • 17 Dec 23
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Race relations Historical Analysis Foreign Policy Nationalism Political Ideologies
  1. Black-Jewish alliance started strong but faced challenges over time, especially with disagreements over issues like affirmative action and Israel-Palestine.
  2. Historical tensions between Blacks and Jews stemmed from economic factors and differences in experiences of discrimination.
  3. Racially preferential policies, like affirmative action, deepened enmity between Black and Jewish communities by bringing to light symbolic and ideological differences.

A Requiem For Ba'athism (Part 2 of 3)

Fisted by Foucault • 64 implied HN points • 01 Jan 25
🌍 World Politics Middle East Political Movements Nationalism Authoritarianism
  1. Ba'athism emerged as a political movement in Syria after some early Arab intellectuals, who were influenced by their time in the West, wanted to unite Arabs through secular ideas rather than Islam.
  2. The Ba'ath party faced many internal splits and rivalries, highlighting the difficulties of creating a united political ideology in a traditionally conservative society.
  3. Throughout the mid-20th century, Syria experienced a series of coups and political instability, with influential figures who rallied for social change and land reform, further complicating the Ba'athist agenda.

Creating insular information bubbles

Not On Your Team, But Always Fair • 943 implied HN points • 07 Jan 24
🌍 World Politics Media Migration Identity Progressivism Nationalism
  1. Narratives are about making meaning, not just facts, and protecting them from facts is crucial for them to continue to make meaning.
  2. Dysfunctional policy responses can suppress feedback and drive mainstream media narratives that may lack accountability.
  3. Internationalisation can reduce accountability in policy-making and contribute to undermining democratic systems across large populations.

On Taiwan's Election Results and How to Promote "National Reunification" by Prof. Zheng Yongnian

Sinification • 825 implied HN points • 15 Jan 24
🌍 World Politics China Taiwan Nationalism Cross-strait relations Political Science
  1. Prof. Zheng Yongnian suggests using new media platforms to influence young people in Taiwan.
  2. China's reaction to Taiwan's election results has been relatively subdued according to intellectuals.
  3. Scholars discussing cross-strait relations usually align closely with the party line.

BLAME IMMIGRANTS

The Carousel • 54 implied HN points • 27 Dec 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Immigration Racism Political Identity Nationalism
  1. Some people believe that immigrants, especially from the subcontinent, don't fully embrace American culture and traditions. They feel that the contributions of white American men should not be overshadowed.
  2. There are concerns that increased immigration might lead to economic issues and social tensions, as seen in other countries. This raises questions about how to manage future immigration effectively.
  3. There's a strong sentiment that immigrants should assimilate into American culture to be truly accepted. Critics argue that some groups keep their own practices and don't fully integrate.