The hottest Policy Analysis Substack posts right now

And their main takeaways
Category
Top U.S. Politics Topics

Focusing on Healthcare’s Administrative Costs Is Misguided

Cremieux Recueil • 610 implied HN points • 07 Dec 24
🏥 Health Politics Healthcare Reform Policy Analysis Economic Impact Public Health
  1. The idea that administrative costs in healthcare are the main issue is often wrong. Many studies show the key costs come from provider payments, not just administration.
  2. Comparing U.S. administrative spending to other countries shows Americans spend similar percentages on administration, but overall higher costs are mostly due to higher payments to healthcare providers.
  3. Improving how healthcare is managed, especially through better corporate governance, can help reduce administrative costs, but we need broader reforms to really lower healthcare prices.

The "Deaths of Despair" narrative is wrong

Slow Boring • 7842 implied HN points • 10 Oct 23
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Public Health Social Trends Policy Analysis Political implications Economic Factors
  1. The 'Deaths of Despair' narrative linking declining life expectancy to social and political trends like right-populist politics has fundamental statistical flaws.
  2. The increase in deaths of despair is mainly due to opioid overdoses and differences in pharmaceutical marketing laws between the US and Europe.
  3. Public health outcomes differing between states can be attributed to the implementation (or lack thereof) of paternalistic health policies.

What to watch for: Aaron Reichlin-Melnick on immigration and mass deportations

The Watch • 416 implied HN points • 20 Dec 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Immigration Deportation Policy Analysis Political Commentary Civil Rights
  1. The Trump administration's immigration plan could cause a lot of harm, affecting not only undocumented immigrants but also their families and the U.S. economy. There’s a risk of mass deportations, which can create fear in communities.
  2. There are many challenges to implementing plans for mass deportation. Even though there are threats and promises, practical limitations like resources, laws, and the need for due process can make it very difficult to achieve the massive deportation numbers that have been proposed.
  3. Fear is a powerful tool used in immigration policy, impacting how people live their daily lives. Even without actual mass deportations, the threat alone can lead to many people feeling unsafe and acting differently, which can hurt communities and their social fabric.

Weekend Update #116: One Day Until A New World: Case Study on Sanctions

Phillips’s Newsletter • 163 implied HN points • 19 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Policy Analysis Elections International relations War Strategy Sanctions
  1. Sanctions against Russia have toughened recently, making it harder for them to sell oil and damaging their economy. This could weaken their war efforts.
  2. Ukraine's attacks against Russia are increasing in frequency and coordination. They are successfully hitting key targets, which may give them an advantage.
  3. The war seems to be a race to see which side can keep fighting longer. While Ukraine fears running out of support, Russia is also showing signs of weakening, especially if Western aid continues.

The Virtue of Diversity

David Friedman’s Substack • 431 implied HN points • 10 Dec 24
🏥 Health Politics Pandemic response Public Health Epidemiology Policy Analysis Scientific research
  1. Many countries had similar Covid-19 policies, even though their cultures and situations were very different. This shows that having different approaches can be useful because it allows for diverse solutions.
  2. The Great Barrington Declaration suggested protecting vulnerable people while allowing the virus to spread among others. This idea faced strong opposition, highlighting how challenging it can be to propose different solutions in a uniform system.
  3. Countries like Sweden took a different path during the pandemic, opting for lighter restrictions. This led to a less severe impact than predicted, suggesting that a variety of strategies can lead to better outcomes.
Get a weekly roundup of the best Substack posts, by hacker news affinity:

The MAGA Civil War Over H-1B Visas

Common Sense with Bari Weiss • 180 implied HN points • 30 Dec 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Immigration Political Discourse Identity politics Policy Analysis
  1. The H-1B visa program allows U.S. companies to hire skilled workers from abroad, mainly benefiting tech companies that want to pay lower wages. It has become a point of conflict within the MAGA movement.
  2. Supporters of the program argue that it helps bring in talented workers that American companies need. However, critics say it creates a system that exploits workers and harms American wages.
  3. The debate over H-1B visas has highlighted deeper divisions in the right, between those who support immigration as part of America's identity and those who view it through a lens of racism and protectionism.

Retrospective: Trump's Executive Order on Males in Women's Sports

House of Strauss • 38 implied HN points • 08 Feb 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Policy Analysis Social Issues Government Action Public Sentiment Political Opposition
  1. Trump's recent order restricts biological males from competing in women's sports, which has sparked varying reactions, especially from sports media. It shows a shift in the conversation around gender and sports.
  2. There seems to be a growing consensus among the public against the inclusion of trans women in women's sports, with polls indicating strong support for this stance.
  3. Some individuals feel uncomfortable joining activist movements, even if they agree with the cause, indicating a hesitance to publicly associate with political movements.

Biden’s Final Export Control Salvo Misfires

ChinaTalk • 266 implied HN points • 03 Dec 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Policy Analysis Export Controls International relations Economic strategy
  1. Biden's new export controls for chips were seen as weak and complicated. They might not effectively slow down China's progress in chip technology.
  2. The rules have too many loopholes that companies can exploit, allowing China to stockpile resources and continue its chip production relatively unhindered.
  3. There are debates about the effectiveness of the regulations and whether they should be focused more on strategic goals or just enforcement of the law.

Tax Policy: Breaking the Impasse

Comment is Freed • 93 implied HN points • 16 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Tax policy Political Reform Government Structure Policy Analysis
  1. Tax reform in the UK is really hard because changes lead to public outrage, making it tough for politicians to make sensible decisions. Politicians often focus on how changes will be viewed rather than on what makes sense.
  2. The current tax system is too complicated and has become a way to solve a variety of issues, leading to confusion and resistance. There needs to be a clearer and simpler approach to tax policy that takes all aspects into account.
  3. Creating a separate office for tax policy could help develop better ideas and solutions without getting caught up in daily politics. This could support governments in making more informed decisions about tax reform.

SB 1047 with Socialist Characteristics: China’s Algorithm Registry in the LLM Era

ChinaTalk • 355 implied HN points • 14 Nov 24
🕹 Technology AI Regulations Policy Analysis Data security Global Governance
  1. China has introduced strict rules for generative AI, requiring all output to reflect socialist values. This highlights the government's focus on controlling AI content that interacts with the public.
  2. There are two separate registration processes for algorithms in China: a simpler one for regular algorithms and a more complex one for generative AI. The more complicated process involves direct testing by authorities, making it tougher for companies to launch AI products.
  3. The regulatory environment is still evolving and can be confusing for companies. Some might face delays in getting their models approved, which could lead to a preference for targeting businesses over regular consumers.

Will Elon's Team of Elite Math Twinks Tell Him That You Can't Close a $1.8 Trillion Budget Gap By Eliminating a $0.04 Trillion Agency?

I Might Be Wrong • 25 implied HN points • 06 Feb 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Budgeting Government Federal Spending Policy Analysis Economic Theory
  1. Elon Musk's team is trying to find ways to cut a massive budget deficit, but suggestions like eliminating a small agency won't make a real difference.
  2. Young and inexperienced teams can bring fresh ideas, but they might also lack the courage to challenge big figures when things don't add up.
  3. Real budget solutions will likely involve tough decisions like tax increases or cuts to popular programs, which are often avoided in flashy discussions.

If I Ran the DOGE

In My Tribe • 1199 implied HN points • 17 Nov 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Government Structure Political Reform Public Administration Policy Analysis
  1. Reorganizing the government can make it more efficient by reducing the number of management layers and clarifying who is in charge. This could lead to better decision-making and less wasted effort.
  2. Creating a Chief Operating Officer to manage executive branch operations would help streamline authority and reduce overlap between agencies. This would allow a focus on running the government smoothly.
  3. The government could be simplified by cutting down from many agencies to just eight main ones, which would help eliminate redundancy and make it easier to manage services for the public.

An Analysis of AI Political Preferences from a European Perspective

Rozado’s Visual Analytics • 383 implied HN points • 28 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political Bias AI Ethics Policy Analysis European Politics Political Ideologies
  1. Most AI models show a clear left-leaning bias in their policy recommendations for Europe and the UK. They often suggest ideas like social housing and rent control.
  2. AI models have a tendency to view left-leaning political leaders and parties more positively compared to their right-leaning counterparts. This means they are more favorable towards leftist ideologies.
  3. When discussing extreme political views, AI models generally express negative sentiments towards far-right ideas, while being more neutral toward far-left ones.

Investigations into health care consolidation, profiteering lack necessary insurer angle

HEALTH CARE un-covered • 499 implied HN points • 20 May 24
🏥 Health Politics Healthcare system Policy Analysis Insurance Industry Market Regulation Corporate Accountability
  1. Private equity firms are not the only problem in healthcare. Insurers, especially those owned by Wall Street, are also making big profits and taking over more doctor practices.
  2. A lot of attention is on private equity's role in healthcare, but insurance companies like UnitedHealth are also growing and may pose an even bigger issue. They have control over many doctors and healthcare facilities.
  3. There's a new effort from the DOJ to look into how much power insurers have in the healthcare market. This could bring more focus on the actions of insurance companies, not just private equity.

Where Does Medicare Go From Here: Profit-Driven Chaos or Patient-Centered Community?

HEALTH CARE un-covered • 679 implied HN points • 17 Apr 24
🏥 Health Politics Medicare Health Insurance Healthcare Reform Patient Care Policy Analysis
  1. Medicare is facing serious issues due to privatization, which could harm millions of seniors and disabled people who rely on it for health care.
  2. Insurance companies are overcharging the government for Medicare Advantage plans, leading to higher costs for both the program and patients.
  3. There are two possible futures for Medicare: one that could focus on patient care without profit motives, or one that could worsen access and services for people who need care.

The point of politics

Sex and the State • 29 implied HN points • 22 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Elections Political parties Gender Politics Voter Behavior Policy Analysis
  1. Winning elections is the most important goal for political parties. If they don't win, they can't implement their policies.
  2. When swing voters are misinformed on issues, sometimes it's better for politicians to change the conversation back to popular topics.
  3. Policies regarding gender and rights can sometimes hurt a party if voters aren't educated about them, so they should be careful in how they communicate these issues.

Identity Politics Come From the Center, Not the Left.

JoeWrote • 252 implied HN points • 21 Nov 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political theory Democratic Party Identity politics Election Strategies Policy Analysis
  1. Identity politics often focuses on symbols rather than real change. It's when politicians talk a lot about supporting a group but don't actually put policies in place to help them.
  2. Centrist politicians sometimes use identity politics to appear progressive while avoiding meaningful actions. They try to win votes by using friendly language without making real changes.
  3. Instead of blaming the left for identity politics, many centrist Democrats use it as a strategy to beat more progressive candidates. They need to focus on real issues that matter to people instead of just symbolic gestures.

Jay Bhattacharya is a superb pick for NIH director

Vinay Prasad's Observations and Thoughts • 209 implied HN points • 30 Nov 24
🏥 Health Politics Public Health Policy Analysis Epidemiology Healthcare systems Health Equity
  1. Jay Bhattacharya wants to study the effects of lockdowns and other COVID-19 measures. He believes this research will help prevent similar harsh actions in the future.
  2. He plans to improve how scientific research is done, focusing on making findings repeatable and clear. This could really help how science is understood and applied.
  3. Jay aims to change leadership rules at NIH and make grant processes better through trials. He believes changes in these areas could lead to more effective research.

CDC Director Is Exhibit A That 'Experts' Have Learned Nothing From COVID

Unmasked • 73 implied HN points • 08 Jan 25
🏥 Health Politics Public Health Policy Analysis Crisis Management Pandemic response
  1. The CDC made mistakes in managing COVID-19, like failing to roll out tests properly and giving confusing mask advice. This led to a lot of public criticism.
  2. Their guidance on masks changed too many times without strong evidence to support the changes. They often relied on poor studies that were quickly disproven.
  3. Despite the backlash and criticism, the CDC didn't seem to learn from their mistakes or adjust their approach effectively during the pandemic.

Mini Exasperation #4

Exasperated Infrastructures • 7 implied HN points • 14 Feb 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Policy Analysis Executive orders Transportation Media influence Public Safety
  1. Safety has become a complicated topic, with over 40,000 road deaths each year. This shows that how we manage road safety affects everyone, regardless of beliefs.
  2. There's a lot of confusion in the government about which transportation projects are funded or canceled. This uncertainty impacts many people's lives and jobs.
  3. The way information flows can drown out important stories, making it hard for the public to know what's really going on. It’s like a messy strategy to control the narrative.

Congestion Pricing: Because Nothing Says ‘New York’ Like Paying More to Get Less

Gad’s Newsletter • 23 implied HN points • 03 Feb 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Urban Policy Transportation Public Opinion Economic Impact Policy Analysis
  1. Congestion pricing in New York is aimed at reducing traffic in the city center, but it has also led to increased traffic in other areas. This means the problem of congestion might just be moving around rather than getting solved.
  2. Not all routes are affected the same way. While some key entry points into the city have traffic improvements, local streets used for everyday travel show little to no change, which raises questions about the overall effectiveness of the plan.
  3. Public support for congestion pricing varies greatly and people are concerned about fairness and how the revenue will be used. Making sure to communicate how the money is spent and improving transit options could help gain more acceptance from the public.

It’s official! Control of women's and girls' single-sex spaces in Christchurch, NZ, is no longer in the hands of women and girls.

A B’Old Woman • 599 implied HN points • 20 Mar 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Women's Rights Gender Issues Policy Analysis Civil Rights Local Governance
  1. The new Equity and Inclusion Policy in Christchurch has removed the protection of single-sex spaces for women and girls. This means that these spaces are now open to people who identify as women, including men.
  2. By not including the term 'sex' in the policy, it's hard to enforce rights for single-sex areas. This change makes it unclear if women's rights in these spaces will be respected or considered at all.
  3. Women and girls can no longer directly ask a man to leave a female space. Instead, they must call a staff member to deal with the situation, which takes away their control and comfort in these spaces.

The Enemy is Us on Health Policy

In My Tribe • 440 implied HN points • 25 Dec 24
🏥 Health Politics Health care Policy Analysis Public Health Consumer behavior Health economics
  1. Many Americans see health care as a gift, not a product, which makes it hard to talk about costs. Doctors want to be paid, but they don't want to think of themselves as selling their services.
  2. There are certain cultural attitudes that shape the way our health care system works today. These attitudes include the reluctance to view health care as a commodity.
  3. People often ignore other ways resources can be used when it comes to health care. This can create issues in how we manage and think about health care policies.

As Medicare Advantage's shortcomings echo in the press, key legislators still push to privatize traditional Medicare

HEALTH CARE un-covered • 639 implied HN points • 07 Mar 24
🏥 Health Politics Health Insurance Medicare Policy Analysis Legislation Healthcare access
  1. There are concerns about the move to privatize Medicare, especially with more seniors being pushed towards Medicare Advantage plans. Many seniors might not know the downsides of these plans, which can include delays in care and unexpected out-of-pocket costs.
  2. Medicare Advantage plans often have strict rules that can limit care for patients, and these plans are favored because they make profits for private insurance companies. Some patients have difficulty getting necessary treatments due to these limitations.
  3. There's a push from certain lawmakers to make Medicare Advantage the default option for new Medicare recipients, which could make traditional Medicare less accessible. This raises worries that Medicare as we know it could disappear in favor of profit-driven plans.

"It's just so very, very small"

Letters from Fiddler's Greene • 982 implied HN points • 08 Jan 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Social Issues Progressivism Identity politics Policy Analysis
  1. The article discusses the dismissal of concerns about transgender issues by emphasizing the insignificance of certain anatomical aspects.
  2. There is a critique of progressive attitudes that avoid addressing serious issues by downplaying their significance.
  3. The text highlights the importance of taking responsibility for one's beliefs and decisions, even if they may seem small or insignificant at first glance.

Passing the Peak, or: The Great Correction

eugyppius: a plague chronicle • 146 implied HN points • 25 Nov 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political Behavior Policy Analysis Public Opinion Government intervention Crisis Management
  1. Modern liberal democracies often react to issues with heightened emotion and hysteria. This can lead to many government interventions that might not be effective in solving the actual problems.
  2. Over time, people's attention on issues wanes, and the original concerns often fade away, leaving behind new laws and bureaucracy without significant change.
  3. Inertial politics affects everyday life, focusing on issues like health and safety or humanitarianism. It often starts with a strong emotional appeal that encourages people to act based on a sense of urgency.

The definition of madness

Comment is Freed • 112 implied HN points • 30 Nov 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Policy Analysis Government spending Public Administration
  1. Governments often miss problems because they focus too narrowly on specific issues, ignoring bigger trends. This makes it hard to spot similar mistakes across different areas of policy.
  2. When the government tries to cut support in one area, it often leads to increased demand for even more expensive services elsewhere. For example, reducing GP appointments has pushed more people to hospital emergency services.
  3. Fixing these problems is tough because once people adapt to new habits, changing them back is hard. To really improve services, governments need to think more broadly and learn from past mistakes.

New Data Once Again Proves Sweden Was Right About Masks

Unmasked • 130 implied HN points • 20 Nov 24
🏥 Health Politics Public Health COVID-19 Mask Mandates Policy Analysis Epidemiology
  1. Sweden's approach to COVID-19, particularly regarding masks, suggests that their policies were more effective compared to strict mandates. Many believe masks didn't help much, and the data supports this view.
  2. Experts' predictions and mandates around masks and vaccines were often incorrect, leading to public distrust. A lot of information from that time is either ignored or downplayed now.
  3. Recent studies reinforce that Sweden's strategies during the pandemic were valid while challenging the widely accepted methods enforced elsewhere. This raises questions about what really works in handling health crises.

Chaos kills coordination

Economic Forces • 10 implied HN points • 06 Feb 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Policy Analysis Economic Policy Investment Strategies Market Dynamics
  1. Chaos in policies can hurt the economy by making it hard to predict what will happen next. This uncertainty stops businesses from wanting to invest money.
  2. When prices change unpredictably, they become less helpful as signals for making decisions. This means people may hold off on projects that could benefit the economy.
  3. A stable set of rules is important for economic growth. Even if policies aren't perfect, having clear and consistent ones helps businesses and workers plan for the future.

Inaccurate Study Claims More Masking Would Have Stopped COVID

Unmasked • 79 implied HN points • 12 Dec 24
🏥 Health Politics Public Health COVID-19 Mask Mandates Misinformation Policy Analysis
  1. There is no solid evidence showing that wearing masks helps stop the spread of respiratory viruses like COVID-19. Many studies from before 2020 found that masks are not effective.
  2. Despite the lack of evidence, some people continue to insist that more masking would have made a difference during the pandemic.
  3. It's important to recognize that a lot of the information about masks has been based on political beliefs rather than scientific facts.

Public health should be distrusted

Vinay Prasad's Observations and Thoughts • 176 implied HN points • 17 Oct 24
🏥 Health Politics Public Health Policy Analysis Vaccine debate Trust Issues
  1. Public health policies, like mask mandates, may not have strong evidence supporting their effectiveness. It's important to question if these rules actually help reduce virus spread.
  2. There seems to be no clear reason for timing these mandates, like starting in November. This raises doubts about their real necessity.
  3. Distrust in public health may be justified if they impose rules without credible data or consideration of their impact on people. It's okay to ask for better evidence and accountability.

Venture incentives, tariffs, and who owns Trump?

Alex's Personal Blog • 131 implied HN points • 07 Nov 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Elections Political strategy Policy Analysis Market Impact Political Influence
  1. Venture capital has changed a lot. Now, big funds often focus on collecting management fees instead of helping companies grow well. This could hurt the overall success of the startups.
  2. There's a mix of excitement and doubt about what Trump will do in office. Many in the business world hope he won't act on some of his strict campaign promises, like high tariffs.
  3. The influence of the business community might lead Trump to prioritize economic relationships over extreme policies. People are curious about which side he'll listen to more once he's in charge.

Postmortem 2024

Skeptic • 95 implied HN points • 14 Nov 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Elections Campaigns Policy Analysis Political Commentary Political strategy
  1. The 2024 election saw Trump winning decisively, and it's important to note that it wasn't just about Harris losing, but Trump running a strong campaign.
  2. Harris should have better addressed key issues like crime, economics, and immigration and connected more with voters by engaging in important discussions on platforms like podcasts.
  3. Looking ahead, while many may feel upset about the results, it's crucial to remain optimistic about the future and know that political power can shift back to Democrats in upcoming elections.

Overestimating Climate Change Damages

Something to Consider • 79 implied HN points • 30 Jun 24
🌞 Climate & Environment Climate Science Policy Analysis Economic Impact
  1. Estimating climate change damages is tricky. It's important to look at unexpected temperature changes instead of just the overall rise in temperatures over time.
  2. People adapt better in the long run than we might think. While weather shocks can hurt people immediately, they learn and adjust to new conditions over time.
  3. The costs of climate change are serious but not as high as some estimates suggest. Humanity has a good capacity for adaptation, which should be considered when assessing potential damages.

Latest Piece Out in the Atlantic: Biden's Catastrophe

Phillips’s Newsletter • 69 implied HN points • 30 Nov 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Policy Analysis Foreign Relations Political critique Government International Affairs
  1. The Biden Administration's approach to Ukraine has been unsuccessful and has made the world a more dangerous place.
  2. This failure has weakened the United States and its position in global affairs.
  3. The author shared a first draft of the article to give readers insight into what was eventually published in The Atlantic.

The National Academy of Medicine is only inducting COVID commenters who were incorrect

Vinay Prasad's Observations and Thoughts • 103 implied HN points • 01 Nov 24
🏥 Health Politics Public Health COVID-19 Policy Analysis Trust Issues
  1. The National Academy of Medicine is mostly recognizing people who gave wrong advice about COVID-19. It's surprising that many who commented about COVID-19 and were inducted were incorrect.
  2. There seems to be a focus on honoring those who were strongly in favor of measures like masking and lockdowns. This suggests a loyalty to a specific viewpoint rather than evaluating based on facts or merit.
  3. This trend can hurt public trust in health institutions. If organizations are driven by ideology instead of balanced evidence, it makes people skeptical about their recommendations.

No, men’s views on policy haven’t really changed

Of Boys and Men • 99 implied HN points • 31 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Voting Trends Gender gap Policy Analysis Political engagement Public Opinion
  1. Men's views on key issues have not changed much in the past two years. They generally care about the same topics as women.
  2. The gender gap in policy preferences is actually getting smaller. Men and women are aligning more closely on what they consider important.
  3. Even when they see issues like voting rights as important, men and women might have different reasons for why they care, reflecting broader cultural divisions rather than just policy differences.