The hottest Political theory Substack posts right now

And their main takeaways
Category
Top Philosophy Topics

Catholic Integralists Versus America

Richard Hanania's Newsletter • 2608 implied HN points • 21 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political theory Religious Influence Nationalism Historical Analysis Cultural Identity
  1. America was founded on Enlightenment values that emphasized individual liberty and the separation of church and state, rather than being strictly a Christian nation, especially not a Catholic one.
  2. Recent Catholic nationalism contrasts sharply with historical American anti-Catholic sentiment, as many of today’s Catholic conservatives prioritize state intervention over individual freedoms.
  3. The rise of Catholic integralists in modern conservatism reflects a shift towards collectivist ideas that some believe could threaten the core values of American society.

Whose Standards Are Too High?

Bet On It • 573 implied HN points • 11 Nov 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Elections Political theory Democracy Government Regulation Public Policy
  1. Many people have high standards for politicians and democracy, but they should consider that the alternatives might not be better.
  2. The free market is often held to very high standards, but voters and politicians should think about whether government actions can truly improve things.
  3. Instead of pushing for more government intervention, maybe people should appreciate the benefits of a free market and how it has worked historically.

Germany: The Land of Stuck Politics

eugyppius: a plague chronicle • 133 implied HN points • 18 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political theory Elections Governance International relations Public Policy
  1. Germany's politics are stuck and slow to change. Other countries are moving forward, but Germany is lagging behind in responding to new challenges.
  2. The current political system in Germany seems to prioritize maintaining the status quo over adapting to citizens' needs. This could lead to poor governance in the future.
  3. There is a sense that Germany wants to set a good example for the world, but this approach may not solve its domestic issues or reflect the changing global landscape.

The Politics of Cultural Despair

The Chris Hedges Report • 607 implied HN points • 06 Nov 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political theory Elections Social Issues Corporate Influence Civil Rights
  1. Despair is a major issue in society today. Many people are struggling with feelings of hopelessness due to lost jobs, poor economic conditions, and a lack of political representation.
  2. The rise of cult leaders reflects a society that feels powerless. People often turn to these leaders in hope of regaining control and finding meaning in their lives.
  3. To create real change, we need to focus on organizing and striking against corporate power. This can help restore dignity and purpose to people's lives and tackle the problems caused by a failing system.

The Weak Strongman

Thinking about... • 731 implied HN points • 13 Feb 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political theory Foreign Policy Political Behavior Electoral Politics Governance
  1. Trump's style of leadership can seem strong, but it's actually making America weaker on the world stage. His actions are damaging key government institutions and alliances.
  2. While many Americans fear Trump's behavior, he doesn’t inspire the same fear abroad. Instead, other countries see his actions as a chance to gain more power without concern for his threats.
  3. Trump's government strategy relies on chaos and destruction rather than solid policies. This creates a situation where adversaries like Russia and China can take advantage of America's declining strength.
Get a weekly roundup of the best Substack posts, by hacker news affinity:

The Political Miscalculation of the "Squid Game" Rebellion And How To Avoid It In Real Life

JoeWrote • 29 implied HN points • 13 Feb 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political theory Capitalism Cultural critique Media Analysis Social movements
  1. _Squid Game_ reflects the harsh realities of capitalism and how it affects people's lives. The show serves as a warning about chasing wealth and the struggle between different classes.
  2. Despite its anti-capitalist message, many viewers misunderstand the show and view it as a celebration of capitalism. This shows how deeply some individuals can miss the real critique being presented.
  3. In the upcoming season, the characters will focus on fighting against the oppressive system. Their mistakes in planning a rebellion mirror real-life struggles faced by working-class movements.

The Gramsci Gap

Breaking Smart • 94 implied HN points • 11 Jan 25
📖 Philosophy Political theory Marxism Etymology Cultural critique
  1. The 'Gramsci Gap' talks about a time when old systems are fading and new ones are struggling to emerge. It's a confusing period filled with strange and troubling events.
  2. It connects ideas of power and control, showing how rulers and the rules they create influence society. Both individual actions and larger systems can produce negative effects.
  3. Understanding this gap helps us recognize how both personal decisions and structural issues can create problems, pointing to the need for change in how we govern and relate to one another.

A Solon, a King, or a Tyrant?

Gideon's Substack • 28 implied HN points • 10 Feb 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Constitution Executive Power Political theory Elections Authoritarianism
  1. There are different views among Trump's supporters about what kind of leader they want him to be. Some see him as a potential king or tyrant, while others hope he can restore the republic.
  2. Many believe that Trump’s use of executive power might lead to a significant change in the American political system. This has sparked concerns about whether it could evolve into a form of dictatorship.
  3. It’s important to recognize the differences among supporters' visions for America’s future. Understanding these differences can help shape the opposition's strategy moving forward.

Elite Human Capital in Open and Closed Cultures

Richard Hanania's Newsletter • 755 implied HN points • 03 Feb 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political theory Ideology Culture Wars Public Discourse Media Studies
  1. People with high human capital often prefer reading and writing over watching videos or listening to podcasts. This preference comes from a higher intelligence and a desire for deeper understanding.
  2. Not all groups with high human capital are liberal; some can be conservative. However, these conservative groups may create closed cultures that do not accept different views.
  3. Currently, in American politics, there is a divide between open-minded thinkers with high human capital and those who are less open and informed. This division shapes political discussions and community attitudes.

The Hypocrisy of the New Upper Class

Rob Henderson's Newsletter • 2215 implied HN points • 13 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political theory Inequality Social Commentary
  1. The new upper class shows a lot of hypocrisy in their beliefs and actions. They often preach one thing while living another way.
  2. This group often criticizes the working class yet benefits from the very systems they speak against. They want to appear virtuous but don’t always act that way.
  3. The contrast between what they say and what they do makes people question their sincerity. It highlights a common issue of double standards among elites.

America First! Privatizing FEMA Will Kill Americans, But At Least the Hurricanes Will Have Patriotic Names.

JoeWrote • 68 implied HN points • 28 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political theory Nationalism Disaster relief Government Policy
  1. Nationalism can trick people into thinking they have more in common with wealthy Americans than with workers from other countries. This can stop them from standing together for better working conditions.
  2. Privatizing FEMA could lead to worse disaster relief because profit motives might take priority over helping people. This means less support for those who need it during crises.
  3. Many working-class voters may not realize that they could suffer more from political decisions like privatization. They need to focus on class issues instead of being distracted by patriotic symbols.

Social Theory for the Mid-21st Century: Part I. What Do I Ask My Students to Read so That They Will Understand the World of 2055?

Brad DeLong's Grasping Reality • 415 implied HN points • 15 Nov 24
🚌 Education Teaching Methods Curriculum Development Social theory Philosophy Political theory
  1. Teaching students about human affairs is essential to prepare them for their future. We need to help them understand how to navigate their lives and the society they'll be part of.
  2. History provides valuable lessons and analogies, but it's important to synthesize these into useful theories. Good theories help us learn from the past and think about the future.
  3. It's necessary to adapt our teaching to current and future realities, rather than relying only on past approaches. Students need knowledge that applies to the world of 2055, not just what was relevant 40 years ago.

DOGE this

bad cattitude • 302 implied HN points • 23 Nov 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Governance Regulation Bureaucracy Elections Political theory
  1. The growing belief is that cutting back government regulations can lead to more freedom and innovation. People think reducing the power of bureaucracies might actually help the economy.
  2. There's a debate about whether the current federal system should be preserved or changed. Some feel the government needs major reform to better serve the people.
  3. Recent court rulings suggest that agencies can't make big decisions without input from Congress. This could shift control back to the people and limit unchecked power from these agencies.

Migration and the sovereign firm

Gray Mirror • 189 implied HN points • 29 Dec 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Immigration Policy Political theory National Identity Economic Policy Sovereignty
  1. The relationship between a state and its citizens can be viewed in terms of ownership, where the state should safeguard and nurture its people as valuable assets. This perspective contrasts with the modern belief that the state exists to serve its citizens.
  2. Free movement of labor may negatively impact local human capital by creating job competition that reduces job quality for some citizens, affecting their value and contribution to society.
  3. Mass migration policies are often motivated by corporate interests and political goals rather than a genuine need to develop local talent or improve society, leading to ineffective and exploitative outcomes.

SBSQ #14: Election Day lightning round!

Silver Bulletin • 507 implied HN points • 05 Nov 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Elections Polls Forecasting Campaigns Political theory
  1. Election Day tends to be calm since there’s not much to do until results come in. It's a good time to reflect instead of focusing too much on exit polls.
  2. Different prediction models, like FiveThirtyEight's, can have varying odds for candidates which might not reflect the true situation. It's important to pay attention to both polls and the underlying fundamentals.
  3. There are concerns that too many prediction models can lead pollsters to stick closely to common predictions, impacting the variety of polling results we see.

Shiri's Margin Attractor Part 2

Handwaving Freakoutery • 509 implied HN points • 25 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Elections Media Political theory Polarization
  1. Elections are getting closer to 50/50 splits because media focuses on controversial topics. This means both political sides are becoming more polarized over time.
  2. The Electoral College gives a voting advantage to less populous states, which could lead to more rural control of the presidency in the future.
  3. As media continues to capitalize on cultural divisions, this trend towards even vote splits may solidify, changing the political landscape significantly.

Saturday Commentary and Review #182

Fisted by Foucault • 140 implied HN points • 29 Dec 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics International relations Election Analysis Political theory Social movements Government Policy
  1. Europe is facing a tough time with the rise of far-right politics, and things might get worse as economic problems grow. Many traditional left-wing parties are losing support and influence.
  2. The U.S. is in a strong global position as it hands off power to Trump, with a focus on maintaining military support for Ukraine in the ongoing conflict with Russia.
  3. In Georgia, political tensions are high with protests ongoing after a controversial election. The new president has divided opinions, and many are calling for a rerun of the elections.

Of olfactory ethics and oaf-factory hysterics.

Philosophy bear • 286 implied HN points • 04 Dec 24
📖 Philosophy Ethics Political theory Social Issues Cultural criticism
  1. Dr. Ally Louks is facing criticism online for her PhD topic about the social meaning of smell. Some people find her work pointless and label it as 'woke'.
  2. There is a divide in intellectual circles over what it means to be smart or knowledgeable, with some critiques focusing on how certain ideas are oversimplified or misrepresented.
  3. The online discussions often trend toward name-calling and dismissive attitudes instead of engaging with the actual arguments and ideas presented.

If the doctrine fits, ...

In My Tribe • 1002 implied HN points • 20 Dec 24
📖 Philosophy Ideology Political theory Ethics History Human behavior
  1. Some ideologies, like Communism, can attract people who seek power and control, often leading to oppressive regimes. This happens because the ideology allows leaders to justify cruelty in pursuit of a supposed utopia.
  2. Certain belief systems can be appealing to individuals with violent tendencies, while others attract more peaceful people. This means that personality can shape which doctrines someone might follow.
  3. The way people interact with each other, such as cooperating or competing, is influenced by their personal traits. People usually lean toward beliefs that match their nature, which affects how societies function.

This Chinese philosopher reformed politics in one generation

The Novelleist • 923 implied HN points • 27 Dec 24
📖 Philosophy Political theory Ethics Social reform Humanism
  1. Mòzǐ believed that political corruption in ancient China came from leaders acting in their own self-interest. He thought that if everyone cared about the community instead of just themselves, society would improve.
  2. He started a movement called 'inclusive care' that focused on helping others and making decisions for the benefit of all. This idea gained support among the middle class, leading to initiatives that helped the poor and promoted social welfare.
  3. Mòzǐ's efforts led to changes in government where more community-minded leaders emerged. His teachings inspired reforms that improved society, but ultimately Confucianism became the dominant philosophy in China.

The Conservative Worry

In My Tribe • 1184 implied HN points • 23 Nov 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political theory Revolution Conservatism Governance Leadership
  1. There's a concern that Trump’s style is more about radical changes than traditional conservatism. This could lead to extreme actions rather than stable governance.
  2. People in leadership roles, like running the Defense Department, need to have experience managing other managers. Without this experience, they might struggle to lead effectively.
  3. The new appointments might focus on what they want to change, but managing large organizations is hard, and mistakes could happen if they move too quickly.

Can Constitutions Limit Government?

Fake Noûs • 348 implied HN points • 09 Nov 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Constitutional Law Government Structure Civil Liberties Political theory
  1. Many people believe constitutions limit government powers, but in reality, governments often operate outside these limits. Most actions by the government are not authorized by the Constitution.
  2. One big reason the Constitution fails is that there's no one to enforce its rules against the government. It's like letting robbers control the police; they won't enforce laws against themselves.
  3. To make a better constitution, we might need new ideas, like requiring a supermajority to pass laws or having a special court to deal with constitutional issues. This could help protect people's rights from government overreach.

Producers and Parasites

In My Tribe • 759 implied HN points • 01 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political theory Political Ideologies Social Class Political elites Political Activism
  1. Political elites can be divided into two groups: producers who create goods and services and parasites who rely on those producers for income. This distinction helps understand their political leanings.
  2. Some professions, like lawyers and government workers, can straddle the line between being productive and parasitic. Not all roles in these fields are equally beneficial to society.
  3. There is debate about the Woke movement. Some see them as part of the parasitic group, while others argue that many symbolic professionals also contribute positively to society.

Black Republicans and Big Man Syndrome

Richard Hanania's Newsletter • 1536 implied HN points • 09 Oct 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political theory Voting Trends Party Dynamics Identity politics
  1. Some black Republicans are seen as performing for the audience, trying to challenge leftist views. Their backgrounds and statements can lead to controversy.
  2. Republicans may actively seek out black leaders to show they aren't racist, even if those candidates have questionable traits.
  3. The term 'Big Man Syndrome' describes leaders who gain power through charisma and personal control, rather than official positions. This idea comes from studying how some societies operate around influential figures.

Be the elite you wish to see

Jeff Giesea • 1317 implied HN points • 18 Mar 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Populism Leadership Political theory Society
  1. Populism often focuses on complaining about elites rather than solving problems. It can lead to a mindset that values grievances over constructive actions.
  2. Elitism can be redefined as a positive force for leadership and excellence. Society needs leaders who can guide people and address real challenges instead of just gaining power.
  3. If you see problems in the world, you should step up and take action. You have the ability to be a leader in your own way and make a difference where you are.

Liberals have always emphasized the need for collective action

Demodexio • 132 implied HN points • 30 Dec 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Liberalism Socialism Collective action Democracy Political theory
  1. Liberals believe people should work together to solve problems, not just focus on individual efforts. Collective action is really important in creating change.
  2. Socialism is often seen as a barrier to this teamwork because it can fixate on class issues. Liberals argue that this focus makes it hard to address other important aspects of people's lives, like race and gender.
  3. Throughout history, thinkers have emphasized that a successful society relies on people coming together for common goals. This idea has been part of liberal thought for over 2,400 years.

Labour and the challenge of coherence

Comment is Freed • 81 implied HN points • 12 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political theory Governance Public Policy Political parties Elections
  1. The Labour party is struggling to make progress in government, facing frustrations from both members and leadership. This has been made tougher by external challenges like fiscal issues and global tensions.
  2. Keir Starmer, the leader, prefers practical decision-making over deep philosophical discussions, but this can hinder a clear direction for governance. Without guiding principles, it's hard for his team to make confident decisions.
  3. There's a lot of activity within the government, but it lacks a coherent strategy. Different departments may have conflicting agendas, which can lead to confusion and ineffective use of resources.

Where are the Realists Defending Trump?

Phillips’s Newsletter • 95 implied HN points • 11 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Elections Policy Governance Political theory International relations
  1. Great powers, especially nuclear ones, act to protect their interests. This means they are sensitive to threats near their borders.
  2. The idea of security and power is important in international relations, with all states seeking to ensure their safety, no matter their government type.
  3. Donald Trump is using language that aligns with realist views in foreign policy, particularly in how he frames issues related to Russia.

Proem to the Aenean Future

Contemplations on the Tree of Woe • 927 implied HN points • 06 Dec 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political theory Environmental Policy Resource Management Sustainability
  1. The future holds challenges around resource scarcity, but there's hope in human creativity and technology. People believe we can find solutions to navigate tough times ahead.
  2. Emphasizing the need for green energy and a sustainable way of life is crucial. Society must transition to alternative energy sources, like solar and hydrogen, while addressing environmental concerns.
  3. Space exploration could become practical and profitable. Investing in space tech might help solve Earth's resource problems and allow humanity to expand beyond our planet.

The Vatnik Tell

Phillips’s Newsletter • 128 implied HN points • 31 Dec 24
🌍 World Politics International relations Conflict Studies Political theory Geopolitics Security Studies
  1. The term 'non-aligned' is a key point in discussions about Ukraine's future and its relationships with NATO and Russia.
  2. For Ukraine to maintain this 'non-aligned' status, it can't join NATO or host foreign troops for security.
  3. The statements from different speakers show a consistent view that Ukraine must stay clear of foreign military influence to avoid escalating tensions.

The Widening Gyre

Gideon's Substack • 57 implied HN points • 20 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Constitutional Law Political theory Civil Rights Government Policy State power
  1. There's a big difference between law and sheer power. Law can be understood and followed, while totalitarian regimes can do whatever they want without following the law.
  2. Biden's declaration about the Equal Rights Amendment raises questions. If he can declare something to be law just because he believes it, then what prevents future presidents from doing the same with their own beliefs?
  3. The whole situation might just be for show and not really change anything. This can make people lose trust in what the law actually is and think it's just about who has the most power.

Scrip, Apokálypsis, Ho'oponopono & High Strangeness

Dr. Pippa's Pen & Podcast • 53 implied HN points • 21 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Elections Campaigns Government Policies Political theory
  1. The shift in power from Biden to Trump has significant implications, including a new way of fundraising through cryptocurrencies that could change political contributions.
  2. Trump's new currency strategy could allow him more control over funding without relying solely on Congress, as he builds his own financial resources.
  3. There is growing unrest among military operatives regarding secrecy around Unidentified Aerial Phenomena, indicating a possible shift in how classified information is managed and revealed.

"Greatness" after the Bulldozer

Charles Eisenstein • 13 implied HN points • 13 Feb 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political theory Social Issues Immigration Civil Rights International relations
  1. Human beings are all equal and deserve compassion. No matter where we come from, we all share the same fundamental worth.
  2. A nation's greatness can’t come from hurting others. We must remember that helping others strengthens our own society.
  3. The real change we need is about love and understanding, not just switching one group in power for another. We should focus on healing and forgiveness to create a better world.

My Debate with Curtis Yarvin

In My Tribe • 486 implied HN points • 24 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Governance Debate Political theory Public Policy
  1. Democracy allows for change in leadership, which can prevent bad leaders from staying in power. It's important that citizens can vote out leaders who aren't doing a good job.
  2. Absolute monarchies might seem appealing as they could mean strong leadership, but they come with risks like power struggles and potential tyranny. History shows that not all leaders are good.
  3. Choosing leaders based on competence is essential. In democracy, we try to pick capable people, while in monarchies, we might end up with unstable or dangerous leaders.

Friederich Hayek and Will Rogers on the Democratic Party

David Friedman’s Substack • 350 implied HN points • 04 Nov 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political parties Elections Political theory Policy Making Political Behavior
  1. The Democratic Party often acts more like a collection of individuals than a unified organization. This means that each member prioritizes their own goals, which can lead to conflicting actions and beliefs.
  2. Politicians, like Biden, may not shift their policies towards the center because it could risk their own elections and support. They often focus more on their personal objectives than the party's overall strategy.
  3. The behavior of political parties can reflect individual interests rather than a cohesive plan. This can result in decisions that don't necessarily align with making the party stronger or defeating opponents.

On the "elite overproduction" problem

In My Tribe • 774 implied HN points • 10 Dec 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political theory Social Issues Education Inequality Public Policy
  1. The idea of 'elite overproduction' suggests that there are too many people aiming for top positions, which leads to instability. However, many college graduates still find good jobs, showing this idea might not hold true.
  2. Mounk argues that while many pursue fame in arts and media, this ambition has always existed. It can't explain the current issues in society.
  3. There are concerns that some sectors, like nonprofit and education, prioritize their own status too much, leading to a misunderstanding of what 'elite' really means.

Khomeini on Brain Drain

Bet On It • 261 implied HN points • 12 Nov 24
🌍 World Politics International relations Immigration Policy Political theory Human Rights Regional conflicts
  1. Khomeini expressed indifference towards the brain drain from Iran, suggesting those who left were not valuable to the country. He believed that if people felt the need to leave, they should just go.
  2. He argued that the fleeing intellectuals would not contribute positively to Iran, indicating a preference for different thinkers. Khomeini felt that the country should not mourn those who left.
  3. He highlighted the struggles of Iranians wanting to emigrate due to restrictions, imagining how different Iran's population would be if those people had been welcomed elsewhere.

Establishment Politicos Keep Pretending They're Anti-Establishment.

JoeWrote • 88 implied HN points • 07 Jan 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political theory Political narratives Public Opinion
  1. Many politicians and media figures like to act like they're underdogs, even when they're part of the political establishment. They do this to gain sympathy and support from the public.
  2. The idea of being an outsider is especially common among Republicans, who often claim to fight against the establishment despite having a lot of power. It's like the New England Patriots pretending to be underdogs while winning championships.
  3. This behavior is not just a political strategy; it affects how people see themselves and their beliefs. By framing their views as forbidden or unique, they distract from the real issues that need fixing in society.

Identity Politics Come From the Center, Not the Left.

JoeWrote • 252 implied HN points • 21 Nov 24
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Political theory Democratic Party Identity politics Election Strategies Policy Analysis
  1. Identity politics often focuses on symbols rather than real change. It's when politicians talk a lot about supporting a group but don't actually put policies in place to help them.
  2. Centrist politicians sometimes use identity politics to appear progressive while avoiding meaningful actions. They try to win votes by using friendly language without making real changes.
  3. Instead of blaming the left for identity politics, many centrist Democrats use it as a strategy to beat more progressive candidates. They need to focus on real issues that matter to people instead of just symbolic gestures.