The hottest Housing Substack posts right now

And their main takeaways
Category
Top U.S. Politics Topics

The Elusive Cost Savings of the Prefabricated Home

Construction Physics • 28812 implied HN points • 12 Mar 26
đź’Ľ Business Housing
  1. Moving homebuilding into factories has rarely produced big cost cuts compared to traditional on‑site building; most savings are modest (often 5–20%) and can vanish once site work and finishing are counted, with manufactured single‑wide homes being the main outlier.
  2. Prefabrication’s main practical benefits are faster schedules, tighter quality control, and more predictable budgets and timelines, not large long‑term price reductions.
  3. True industrial gains in housing require deeper changes than simply building in a factory — transport, codes, customization, and the need for new standardized processes limit how much prefab alone can lower costs.

Build-to-Rent Isn’t the Problem

Progress and Poverty • 1308 implied HN points • 26 Mar 26
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Housing
  1. Build-to-rent is a symptom, not the root cause — the real problem is a system that lets private owners capture untaxed land value created by public investment.
  2. Policies that only limit corporate ownership won’t fix the underlying incentives and could shrink housing supply; the focus should be on changing who benefits from rising land value.
  3. Cities should recapture more land value through tools like land value taxes or long-term ground leases so they can fund infrastructure, promote infill, and reduce suburban sprawl.

BOOM: Senate Votes to Block Private Equity from Buying Homes

BIG by Matt Stoller • 60391 implied HN points • 13 Mar 26
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Housing
  1. The Senate voted 89-10 to ban large institutional investors from owning big portfolios of single-family homes, setting ownership caps and limits on build-to-rent holdings. It aims to keep homes available to ordinary buyers rather than Wall Street landlords.
  2. Institutional investors have grown their share of single-family housing since 2008, turning homes into an asset class and contributing to higher rents, fee abuses, and reduced homebuying opportunities. Regulators and researchers have documented rent hikes and consumer harms tied to corporate landlords.
  3. The measure now goes to the House where powerful lawmakers, industry lobbyists, and political maneuvering could weaken or block it, so final passage is uncertain. Political alliances are split and influence campaigns are expected as the bill moves forward.

Erdmann Housing Tracker, 2025 Year in Review (January to March)

Erdmann Housing Tracker • 252 implied HN points • 25 Mar 26
đź’Ľ Business Housing
  1. The housing shortage and rules that block new construction, along with tighter mortgage access, have pushed rents way up and suppressed household formation, which hits low-income families hardest.
  2. Common economic measures get the story backwards: rising rents drive price/rent ratios and displace poorer households, and metro-area averages mask the within-city inequalities that matter most.
  3. Policy choices — from lending rules to bans on investor activity and restrictive zoning — are a major cause of the problem, and building more homes is the practical market solution that would reduce inequality.

The "Bullet Train" - Where Does the Money Go?

Life Since the Baby Boom • 1383 implied HN points • 19 Mar 26
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Housing
  1. The rail authority bought thousands of properties ahead of construction and spends huge sums on evictions, repairs and upkeep — often at state prevailing wages and through costly certified contractors, so even worthless buildings rack up massive bills.
  2. Construction demand for concrete, steel and labor is straining supply chains and driving up costs and delays, while farms, wells and utility-scale solar fields have been uprooted or relocated at high expense.
  3. Thick bureaucracy, red tape and poor leadership make routine property work slow and inefficient, causing costs to balloon and many sites to sit in limbo for years rather than being promptly demolished or put to use.
Get a weekly roundup of the best Substack posts, by hacker news affinity:

Reading List 03/07/2026

Construction Physics • 12318 implied HN points • 07 Mar 26
đź•ą Technology Housing
  1. California’s Prop 13 has pushed a record share of home transfers into inheritance—about 18% last year. That makes inheriting a house a major path into homeownership and reduces normal market turnover.
  2. Data centers suddenly switching to backup power can cause rapid drops in electricity demand that threaten grid stability, and operators worry that larger simultaneous disconnects could do serious damage.
  3. Solar is gaining both technological and political momentum—efficiency records and manufacturing are increasingly centered in China while solar finds new allies in U.S. political circles—and at the same time U.S. nuclear safety rules were substantially pared back in a recent rewrite.

Why does America feel worse than other countries? Crime.

Noahpinion • 48177 implied HN points • 26 Feb 26
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Housing
  1. The U.S. stands out among rich countries for its very high violent-crime and murder rates and for visible public disorder that people notice every day.
  2. Progressive ideas and policies—like decarceration, tolerance of disorder, and softer prosecutorial approaches—often suppress serious public debate about crime and may have contributed to higher crime in some places.
  3. High crime reshapes American life: it pushes people into suburbs, keeps riders off trains, blocks housing and transit projects, and broadly lowers urban quality of life.

🏙️ Higher love: The case for building up

Faster, Please! • 1188 implied HN points • 22 Mar 26
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Housing
  1. There’s broad agreement that the US needs more housing and that regulations block much of that supply, but current fixes like small infill and accessory units are too modest to meet the scale of the problem.
  2. Cities need to build up as well as out—taller buildings are a key way to increase density and urban productivity rather than just expanding footprints.
  3. Without allowing significant height, America’s most productive cities will constrain growth, so bolder vertical development is required to unlock more housing and economic opportunity.

Roundup #78: Roboliberalism

Noahpinion • 17882 implied HN points • 27 Feb 26
đź’Ľ Business Housing
  1. We still don’t know if AI caused a real productivity boom in 2025 — micro studies show task-level gains but macro data are noisy, subject to revisions, and other explanations exist.
  2. Building lots of new, high-end housing can actually lower rents for lower-income people by freeing up older, cheaper units — evidence from multiple cities supports this “Yuppie Fishtank” effect.
  3. The decline in extreme poverty has largely finished outside Africa, and because African poverty rates remain high while population grows, forecasts show global extreme poverty could rise again unless African growth or fertility patterns change.

An indigenous nation just built a better city than California Forever

The Novelleist • 162 implied HN points • 12 Mar 26
🪑 Design Housing
  1. We should build more cities, but they must be designed to benefit residents, not just developers or outside investors.
  2. The ideal new city needs real fiscal power — the authority to raise and keep its own revenue so it can fund services and long-term planning.
  3. That fiscal power must actually flow back to residents; real-world examples like indigenous-led towns and autonomous regions show cities can return value to people instead of outside shareholders.

February 2026 Erdmann Housing Tracker Update

Erdmann Housing Tracker • 147 implied HN points • 24 Mar 26
đź’° Finance Housing
  1. Inflation excluding rent has tracked very closely to a 2% trend for nearly four years.
  2. Rent inflation is starting to moderate, and if building more new homes remains legal it should continue easing, which would reduce pressure on the Fed.
  3. Past housing supply constraints pushed policy toward being too tight, and continued rent moderation could flip that bias toward being too loose; a congressional ban on new single-family rentals would be far more damaging to housing supply.

Trends in US Construction Productivity

Construction Physics • 17537 implied HN points • 12 Feb 26
đź’Ľ Business Housing
  1. U.S. construction productivity has been stagnant or fallen for decades, especially compared to strong gains in the rest of the economy. Many sector-wide measures show little to no growth and some show long-term declines.
  2. How productivity is measured matters a lot — sector, subsector, project, and task metrics can tell different stories, and results are highly sensitive to deflators, changing output mix, labor accounting, and quality adjustments. These measurement problems make precise conclusions difficult.
  3. Other countries also show weak construction productivity gains since the 1990s, and while some tasks or subsectors have improved, overall construction growth is much lower than manufacturing and the broader economy.

Reading list 02/14/26

Construction Physics • 9186 implied HN points • 14 Feb 26
đź’Ľ Business Housing
  1. Housing policy and the homebuilding market are in flux, with new laws and zoning talks aiming to boost supply while regulators eye possible price coordination by builders.
  2. Coastal erosion and sea-level effects are increasing building collapses in parts of the southern Mediterranean, raising urgent structural and safety concerns for port cities.
  3. Manufacturing is shifting: AI demand is driving a boom in fiber-optic production, even as cheaper foreign-made goods and changing tariff policies are squeezing some domestic producers.

Reading List for 01/31/2026

Construction Physics • 16911 implied HN points • 31 Jan 26
đź•ą Technology Housing
  1. A new vertically integrated startup is building modular family homes using structural insulated panels and acting as both developer and builder to control design and delivery.
  2. US tariffs have pushed domestic aluminum prices well above global levels, raising input costs and threatening to make American manufacturing less competitive.
  3. Tesla is scaling back traditional EV production and repurposing factories while Chinese manufacturers now account for roughly two-thirds of global EV sales, signaling China’s growing dominance in the electric vehicle market.

Lawler: Some Observations on the February Existing Home Sales Release

CalculatedRisk Newsletter • 258 implied HN points • 19 Mar 26
đź’° Finance Housing
  1. The National Association of Realtors moved its monthly existing-home sales release earlier in the month, and that earlier timing has likely caused larger-than-normal revisions to their monthly sales estimates.
  2. Based on state and local realtor/MLS data, February’s annualized sales rate is likely to be revised down slightly to about 4.03 million, while the year-over-year median single-family home price for February will probably be revised up to around 1.0%.
  3. FOMC dot plots now show over half of participants see the long-run federal funds rate above 3%, a big shift since 2021, even though all participants still assume long-run inflation will be 2% despite current inflation being higher.

Reading List 01/24/26

Construction Physics • 18790 implied HN points • 24 Jan 26
đź•ą Technology Housing
  1. Data centers are eating a huge share of memory chips and electricity, causing supply shortages and a rapid push to expand capacity; that pressure is driving new laws and projects to speed construction and secure power.
  2. Rebuilding domestic manufacturing is harder than it looks: Chinese makers are scaling quickly while equipment and parts production often stays overseas, and tariffs and supply-chain realities keep reshoring expensive.
  3. Housing and construction are being shaped by policy, labor deals, and new tech — from limits on institutional homebuyers and giant union agreements to faster permitting and AI tools — all of which will change what gets built and how.

New Home Sales Decline Sharply to 587,000 Annual Rate in January

CalculatedRisk Newsletter • 239 implied HN points • 19 Mar 26
đź’° Finance Housing
  1. New home sales fell sharply to a 587,000 annual rate in January, down 17.6% from December and 11.3% from a year earlier, with recent months revised lower.
  2. Housing inventory and months' supply have risen — supply is about 9.7 months now, well above the 4–6 month normal range, with completed homes and 'not started' units notably elevated.
  3. The median new home price is about 13% below its peak, largely because the mix of homes sold has shifted toward lower-priced or different types of units.

Should US homebuilders emulate Sweden?

Construction Physics • 28185 implied HN points • 01 Jan 26
đź’Ľ Business Housing
  1. Sweden has widely adopted prefabricated housing, but the observable data don’t show clear productivity gains or lower costs for single-family homes compared with the US.
  2. New Swedish homes cost substantially more per square foot than US homes, and higher energy-efficiency and construction standards partly explain that premium, so prefab hasn’t obviously made them cheaper.
  3. Factory-built methods do offer benefits like better quality control, faster delivery, and predictable pricing, and they may be more promising for multifamily projects, but the cost and productivity advantages there remain uncertain.

Monopoly Round-Up: Why Did Trump Just Attack the Fed and Corporate America?

BIG by Matt Stoller • 24981 implied HN points • 12 Jan 26
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Housing
  1. The administration has pivoted from "Make America Wealthy Again" to an affordability message, attacking big landlords, credit card companies, and defense contractors as a way to respond to public anger about high prices.
  2. There is a big gap between rhetoric and reality: enforcement decisions and personnel moves have often helped consolidation and weakened consumer protections, so the tough talk may not become real policy.
  3. The White House is even using aggressive moves against institutions like the Fed to try to lower costs, but those tactics risk backfiring and make the affordability agenda look conflicted and unpredictable.

A few comments on the Weak Start for 2026 Existing Home Sales

CalculatedRisk Newsletter • 282 implied HN points • 17 Mar 26
đź’Ľ Business Housing
  1. The existing-home market is off to a weak start in 2026, with year-to-date sales down and pending home sales showing a small year-over-year decline, so there’s no clear pickup yet.
  2. The MBA purchase index has climbed from its lows but is still about 29% below the 2017–2019 average, which matches sales being roughly 25% below that period and implies continued weak activity.
  3. The purchase index can be misleading because shifts in which lenders are counted or fewer cash buyers can raise the index without more actual sales, so it should be interpreted with caution.

At least five interesting things: Buy Local edition (#74)

Noahpinion • 17941 implied HN points • 31 Dec 25
đź’Ľ Business Housing
  1. Reducing regulatory costs and investing in infrastructure makes it much easier for small businesses to start, compete, and find customers. This kind of "abundance" policy lowers barriers to entry and helps local economies revive.
  2. Building more market-rate or "luxury" housing lowers rents for everyone by giving high earners places to live so they don’t bid up older, affordable units. Increasing overall housing supply acts like a containment for upward pressure on rents.
  3. Tariffs have raised some prices and hurt certain industries, but the broader U.S. economy has been resilient because actual tariffs paid are much lower than headline rates due to exemptions and trade rules. Also, much of the damage from tariff shocks can appear with a year or two of delay.

Reading List 01/17/2026

Construction Physics • 9186 implied HN points • 17 Jan 26
đź•ą Technology Housing
  1. The Department of Energy appears to be moving away from the ALARA radiation-safety principle, which could lower nuclear project costs but also change long-standing safety practices.
  2. Big tech is betting on nuclear power to fuel AI centers, with Meta backing new reactors and buying output from existing plants to secure gigawatts of electricity by the early 2030s.
  3. OLED displays give brighter colors and faster refresh rates but use uneven subpixel layouts that can cause colored fringing on text and static graphics, due to blue-pixel lifespan limits, human vision quirks, and manufacturing constraints.

Part 2: Current State of the Housing Market; Overview for mid-March 2026

CalculatedRisk Newsletter • 205 implied HN points • 16 Mar 26
đź’° Finance Housing
  1. Home sales are very low and months-of-supply is above pre-pandemic levels, which is putting downward pressure on prices, though not triggering a crash because most homeowners hold substantial equity and many have low mortgage rates.
  2. Mortgage rates first fell briefly but have moved up to seven-month highs, and geopolitical uncertainty plus stock market weakness are hurting buyer demand and could further weaken sales.
  3. Price indexes show only modest year-over-year gains (around 1–2%) with small month-to-month rises, but the trend is slowing and the Case-Shiller data has a lag that may understate current price pressure.

The Monday Media Diet with Gillian Morris

Why is this interesting? • 1025 implied HN points • 24 Feb 26
🎭️ Culture Housing
  1. Communal living can be both a lifestyle and a career; people set up shared homes, co-own apartments, and earn money by writing, speaking, and consulting about community living.
  2. A deliberate media diet avoids breaking news and favors long-form analysis in weeklies, magazines, and focused blogs to get deeper context.
  3. Curiosity about travel, literature, apps, and online oddities shapes life. Long train journeys and places like Puerto Rico offer rich experiences, while serious books and niche apps or rabbit-hole videos feed both intellectual and playful interests.

The "$140,000 poverty line" is very silly

Noahpinion • 24529 implied HN points • 29 Nov 25
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Housing
  1. The $140,000 "poverty line" mostly comes from simple data and math mistakes — using the wrong food-share number and the wrong income benchmark makes the figure much higher than it should be, and a corrected back-of-envelope comes in closer to about $80,000.
  2. The method of redefining poverty by scaling a 1963 food-based rule to modern middle-class spending is flawed — it treats voluntary upgrades (bigger houses, fancier goods) and temporary costs (full-time daycare for young kids) as permanent necessities, which produces absurd results.
  3. Reality checks show most families today have food, housing, insurance, and adequate transport, so calling a majority "poor" is misleading; that said, rising costs for housing, healthcare, and childcare are real problems that merit policy attention.

At least five interesting things: Debunking the Debunkers edition (#73)

Noahpinion • 18353 implied HN points • 12 Dec 25
đź“° News Housing
  1. Basic income trials boost recipients' cash but don’t meaningfully raise their labor income or reduce crime in the short run, so unconditional cash alone won’t solve many social problems.
  2. Mississippi’s big gains in fourth‑grade reading don’t appear to be just a selection artifact from holding kids back, since improvements show up across all score deciles and have persisted beyond the first retained cohorts.
  3. Nick Fuentes’ online popularity was at least partly manufactured by coordinated, anonymous (often foreign) accounts that artificially amplified engagement, demonstrating how viral platforms can be gamed to inflate extremist influence unless better gatekeeping is built.

The Unchecked Rise of Crazy Race Theory in Academia

TK News by Matt Taibbi • 9309 implied HN points • 08 Jan 26
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Housing
  1. A city housing official’s past social posts promoting collective ownership and using legal means against landlords caused a public uproar and the mayor publicly defended the appointment.
  2. An academic idea often called "whiteness as property" has gained traction in some university and activist circles, arguing that white identity and property rights are historically linked.
  3. Critics say this theory is racist and dangerous, warning it could undermine private property and Enlightenment values, and it has drawn legal and political scrutiny.

Highlights From The Comments On Vibecession

Astral Codex Ten • 11494 implied HN points • 31 Dec 25
🎭️ Culture Housing
  1. Since about 2021–2022 public mood about the economy dropped sharply even when many objective indicators didn’t, creating a separate “vibecession” driven by collapsing trust and meaning-making.
  2. There’s no consensus on causes: plausible drivers include inflation, housing affordability (especially for new movers and aspiring homeowners), rising expectations of what counts as success, media and algorithm effects, and measurement issues in inflation.
  3. Similar pessimism appears in other countries, showing feelings can be disconnected from real prosperity, and fixing the disagreement will take better empirical work on housing, inflation metrics, and generational consumption baskets.

Highlights From The Comments On Boomers

Astral Codex Ten • 9085 implied HN points • 06 Jan 26
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Housing
  1. Anti-Boomer anger actually bundles three different claims — that boomers had it easier, that the system favors them politically, and that they’re uniquely selfish — and those claims should be argued about separately.
  2. Housing and tax policy are a core fight: proposals like repealing protected property tax rules, higher taxes payable on death or sale, or simply building more homes can redistribute housing access, but forced moves would hurt elders with deep place attachments.
  3. A lot of the tension is structural — a large, long-lived boomer cohort stuck in institutions creates real redistribution and entitlement pressures — so the problem isn’t just moral blame but demographic and political power dynamics.

January 2026 Residential Construction

Erdmann Housing Tracker • 147 implied HN points • 17 Mar 26
đź’Ľ Business Housing
  1. Residential construction in January 2026 is described as capacity-constrained according to the available data.
  2. Detailed metrics and explanations are implied to support that capacity-constraint conclusion, indicating deeper analysis exists.
  3. The full detailed findings are behind a paywall and require a subscription to access.

Reform has a point (about this one, very specific thing)

Odds and Ends of History • 201 implied HN points • 16 Mar 26
🎙 Podcasts Housing
  1. Changing how political control works in the Civil Service could have real benefits and is worth a calm, open debate instead of instant rejection.
  2. A local playground being unusable for kids for two years shows how everyday public services can get stuck and cause real frustration for communities.
  3. Text and data mining sits at the heart of the ongoing AI vs copyright debate, and we need clear rules that balance innovation with protecting creators' rights.

The Housing Crisis as a Land Crisis

Progress and Poverty • 2155 implied HN points • 05 Feb 26
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Housing
  1. The housing affordability problem is really a land crisis: scarce, desirable urban land near jobs and amenities is constrained, so prices rise even though there’s plenty of land elsewhere and building costs themselves haven’t driven the spike.
  2. A long run of policy and technological changes de-densified cities, and modern shifts (congestion, tighter credit, dual-career households, more single adults) have re-concentrated demand in a few job-rich places, making central land much more valuable and harder to expand.
  3. Solving the problem means loosening the land constraint — allow more housing where demand is highest and curb land speculation with tools like land value taxes or public land leasing so the location premium benefits the community.

The St. Louis Fed reminding me I can still be surprised

Erdmann Housing Tracker • 105 implied HN points • 16 Mar 26
đź’° Finance Housing
  1. The 2008 mortgage crackdown was a huge, lasting drop in buyer demand that reshaped housing markets, and leaving it out of explanations leads to misleading conclusions about rising prices.
  2. Most post-2009 price gains happened in the cheapest neighborhoods because investors bought up homes left unattainable to denied buyers, so investor activity often signals the mortgage access collapse rather than acting as an independent cause.
  3. Homebuilding capacity fell after 2008 and completions remain well below pre-crisis levels, meaning supply shifted left and affordability worsened; treating the crash as an inevitable, unquestioned correction blocks better policy thinking.

How to buy a duplex (or triplex)

Supernuclear • 579 implied HN points • 07 Oct 24
đź’Ľ Business Housing
  1. Buying a duplex or triplex can save you money compared to single-family homes. They are typically about 30% cheaper per square foot, making them an affordable option for many.
  2. Duplexes offer a blend of private space and the ability to live close to friends. You can enjoy your own area while still maintaining close connections with others.
  3. There are different ways to buy a duplex, each with its own financial and legal considerations. It's important to explore these options to find what works best for your situation.

The Housing Ladder's Broken Promise

Progress and Poverty • 2347 implied HN points • 29 Jan 26
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Housing
  1. Housing cannot be both widely affordable and treated as a perpetually appreciating investment; treating homes as investment vehicles pushes prices up and locks many people out.
  2. If the conflict is left unresolved the system can break in several bad ways—sudden crashes that wreck the economy, slow neo-feudal stagnation where landlords extract huge rents, or demographic decline as people leave or fail to form families.
  3. A practical off-ramp is to unlock supply and curb land speculation: make it easier to build (YIMBY reforms) and shift taxes onto land value (Georgist ideas) so housing becomes more affordable without unfairly wrecking current owners.

Another cool paper and more notes on a bad paper on housing supply

Erdmann Housing Tracker • 463 implied HN points • 02 Mar 26
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Housing
  1. Preapproved permits carry a large market premium: land and sites with ready-to-issue permits sell for much more and are far likelier to be developed, so permitting frictions explain a meaningful share of the gap between housing prices and construction costs.
  2. Common economic models and supply measures rest on assumptions like identical workers and costless mobility that don’t match how people actually behave, so those models can misread affordability, displacement, and migration dynamics.
  3. The 2008 mortgage crash and collapse in single-family construction shifted the supply picture nationwide, making many standard metro-level supply metrics uninformative; high prices in expensive cities often reflect broad demand vs. constrained supply, not unique local popularity.

The Revolution of Rising Expectations

Don't Worry About the Vase • 5465 implied HN points • 22 Dec 25
🎭️ Culture Housing
  1. People are objectively better off in many material ways today, but rising expectations make people compare to a much higher standard so lots of people still feel like they’re falling behind.
  2. New social and legal requirements — especially intense child‑supervision rules plus higher de facto minimums for housing, healthcare, and schooling — have raised the real cost of family life and made one‑income households much harder to pull off.
  3. Many of these problems are fixable: cheaper housing, cheaper childcare and healthcare, better public goods, tax and transfer reforms, and cultural shifts to normalize simpler living would help, but political and social will are the constraints.

Some actual good news for once!

Odds and Ends of History • 469 implied HN points • 02 Mar 26
🎙 Podcasts Housing
  1. Cornwall could become Britain’s lithium and geothermal powerhouse as new projects develop there.
  2. London is finally set to get a pedestrianised Oxford Street after years of institutional gridlock.
  3. UK astronomy funding is under threat, and cuts to curiosity-driven fundamental research could seriously damage the country’s leadership in astronomy.

In California, Decline Is a Choice

Common Sense with Bari Weiss • 862 implied HN points • 04 Feb 26
🎭️ Culture Housing
  1. An entrepreneur aims to build an entirely new city in Solano County to house about 400,000 people with walkable neighborhoods, schools, and offices.
  2. He argues California’s problems are largely self-inflicted—heavy regulation and a 'degrowth' mindset have stifled building and driven companies away.
  3. The project faces major hurdles like regulatory red tape, political and public skepticism, and financing challenges, but he has secured investors and remains determined to try.

Yes, liberal hypocrisy has an actual face

Unreported Truths • 39 implied HN points • 19 Mar 26
🇺🇸 U.S. Politics Housing
  1. A Princeton history professor openly opposes Donald Trump and generally supports progressive ideas and science, though he admits limits to how progressive he is.
  2. He lives in a university-subsidized house on Edgehill Road and objects to new housing being built close to his home.
  3. Many see this as a clear case of liberal hypocrisy — backing broad progressive policies while fighting local development that would affect his own neighborhood — and others find the contrast ironic.